Is Ethereum really the best blockchain to form a DAO?

Cointelegraph发布于2022-04-04更新于2022-04-04

文章摘要

The crypto community and industry have chosen Ethereum as the chain of choice for most blockchain-based decentralized applications.

The crypto community and industry have chosen Ethereum as the chain of choice for most blockchain-based decentralized applications, but other chains may be better suited to handle the workload for decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs).
Technical advantages and cheaper transactions have yet to become a major pull factor from Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) chains. EVM compatibility enables a network to use Ethereum’s security features.
Ethereum (ETH) and its compatible chains have a clear advantage in the number of DAOs compared to any other. They house more than 4,200 DAOs and protocols requiring governance participants according to data from blockchain voting platform Snapshot.
Comparatively, the Solana (SOL) ecosystem has only 140, Cardano has 10 DAOs according to ecosystem tracker Cardano Cube, and Polkadot (DOT) Substrate says it has just eight. This is not to discount the fact that among the top 10 DAOs by the number of decisions made over the past seven days, DAO tracker DeepDAO shows that three are based on Solana.
Ethereum’s leg up over the rest may be due to simple, yet practical reasons, according to DAO tracker DeepDAO CEO Eyal Eithcowich in emailed responses to Cointelegraph. He attributes Ethereum’s dominance to the fact that it is “the chain where the DAO movement started.”
“More importantly, (Ethereum’s) the most mature ecosystem in terms of tools for starting and managing all facets of DAOs, mostly financial but not only. This may change as other chains grow in popularity.”
On the other hand, he pointed to high gas fees as a shortcoming of Ethereum. He added that Solana allows DAOs to make fast and cheap transactions, “But, again, the supporting features and tools in the ecosystem are less robust.”
Additionally, Solana has become vulnerable to infrequent network outages.
The co-founder of the nonfungible token (NFT) game on the EOSIO-based WAX network Alien Worlds, Saro McKenna, told Cointelegraph last week that she believes EOSIO (EOS) is better for building DAOs.
In her view, Ethereum is too expensive for voting purposes and was designed to be a “general-purpose blockchain” to handle any number of different tasks. This contrasts with EOSIO, which McKenna said “was partly built for the purpose of DAOs.”
“The EOSIO codebase is extremely powerful, allowing for layered multisig permissions and dynamic collection election mechanisms that are critical for DAOs to function properly.”
Gas fees have long been an issue for Ethereum users, but in March, fees were at their lowest levels since last August.
However, CEO of blockchain consulting firm Koinos, Andrew Levine, had pointed criticisms of EOSIO which could explain why it falls short of Ethereum’s rate of adoption. In February, he wrote that while EOS transactions are virtually fee-less, there is an account creation fee. Furthermore, holding coins on an account is fairly complicated compared to Ethereum:
“The EOS database is built on something called “memory-mapped files,” another vestige of the Steem design, an important consequence of which is that it is designed to use the most expensive form of storage possible: random-access memory (RAM).”

你可能也喜欢

卡尔达诺(Cardano)要完了吗?查尔斯·霍斯金森警告“失败浪潮”将至——他自己的社区怒不可遏

卡尔达诺(Cardano)联合创始人查尔斯·霍斯金森近日发布视频警告,称2026年下半年该生态系统将出现项目失败潮、被迫整合及DeFi关闭。此番言论引发其社区强烈不满。此次预警的导火索是卡尔达诺核心数据分析平台TapTools于6月2日宣布将在两周内停止运营,原因是基础设施成本与开发支出难以为继,团队多名核心成员也已离职。 霍斯金森将此事视为生态系统深层压力的征兆,指出许多早期项目已不具备投资价值,并承认自己曾提议的国库资助指数计划未能落实。他随后在X平台上表示将“休息一下”,此言在当下时点引发更多猜测。 加密社区反应迅速且尖锐。Nansen首席执行官安德烈亚斯·斯瓦内维克等人批评霍斯金森过往对卡尔达诺的机构潜力与开发采用做出了不切实际的承诺,导致社区期望落空。数据显示,卡尔达诺总锁仓价值(TVL)仅约1.2385亿美元,排名第28位,远远落后于以太坊等公链。此外,2026年卡尔达诺峰会被取消,工程预算遭大幅削减,ADA价格也跌至五年多来最低点约0.20美元。 霍斯金森的言论让社区不得不面对一个尖锐问题:在其创始人近乎“末日预言”的描述下,卡尔达诺能否逆转颓势?目前,生态系统尚未给出明确答案。

bitcoinist5分钟前

卡尔达诺(Cardano)要完了吗?查尔斯·霍斯金森警告“失败浪潮”将至——他自己的社区怒不可遏

bitcoinist5分钟前

中国Web3创业,有哪些好路子?(五)

本文探讨了中国Web3团队向AI领域迁移的可行路径,重点聚焦于安全风控团队和应用层及社区型团队。 对于安全风控团队,其机遇在于从传统的链上合约、资产安全,转向AI Agent时代的行为安全。随着AI Agent在企业的渗透,其工具调用、数据访问和自动支付等行为将催生新的安全需求,如权限管控、操作审计和风险监控。Web3安全团队可将原有的审计与风控能力迁移至此,为企业提供Agent行为日志、权限边界设定和合规审计等服务,这一B2B方向有明确的付费需求且合规风险相对较低。 对于应用层和社区型团队(如内容、投研、教育、社区产品),迁移的关键在于将AI作为能力增强器,而非彻底转型。应专注于利用AI解决现有产品或运营中的具体痛点,例如:用AI帮助投研工具高效处理海量信息、辅助社区产品进行用户分层与运营、为教育平台提供个性化学习路径。核心是让AI深度嵌入现有工作流,提升效率、决策质量或用户体验,避免脱离真实场景空谈AI概念。 文章同时提醒了应谨慎进入的方向:1)需巨大投入的通用大模型;2)缺乏明确任务与付费方的泛Agent平台;3)易触碰资金与合规红线的AI交易员、自动收益类产品;4)仅为原有项目简单套上AI外壳、而无实质价值提升的“伪创新”。 总之,迁移成功的关键在于团队能否将Web3领域已沉淀的核心能力(如数据、支付、安全、运营经验)与AI新场景有效结合,并找到真实的业务需求与付费方,而非追逐热点概念。

marsbit2小时前

中国Web3创业,有哪些好路子?(五)

marsbit2小时前

交易

现货
合约

热门文章

加密市场宏观研报:美国“加密货币周”来袭,ETH开启机构军备赛高潮

本周,加密市场迎来两股重磅催化——华盛顿“加密货币周”的立法攻势与以太坊机构布局的密集爆发,共同构成加密行业2025年下半年的“政策拐点”与“资金拐点”。这一轮加密周期的深层逻辑,正从比特币转向以太坊、稳定币及链上金融基础设施。我们认为:美国的政策明朗化+以太坊的机构化扩展,标志着加密行业正进入结构性转正阶段,市场配置的重心亦应逐步从“价格博弈”过渡至“规则+基础设施的制度红利捕捉”。

1.7k人学过发布于 2025.07.17更新于 2025.07.17

加密市场宏观研报:美国“加密货币周”来袭,ETH开启机构军备赛高潮

相关讨论

欢迎来到HTX社区。在这里,您可以了解最新的平台发展动态并获得专业的市场意见。以下是用户对ETH(ETH)币价的意见。

活动图片