每人最多20篇？ICLR新规遭DeepMind研究者「反讽」请愿

marsbitPublished on 2026-08-03Last updated on 2026-08-03

Abstract

ICLR 2027 会议近日公布新规，规定每名作者最多只能提交20篇论文，超出限额的论文若未调整将被随机拒稿。此举旨在应对投稿量激增给评审系统带来的压力。ICLR 2026 投稿量较前一年增长约68%，达到19525篇，导致评审工作量巨大。 新规引发了讨论。Google DeepMind 访问研究员 Dan Roy 在社交平台发起讽刺性“请愿”，反对此限制。他表面上称限制会阻碍 AI 发展，并主张应鼓励 AI Agent 大量生成渐进式论文，同时暗指评审工作也已由大语言模型处理，以此揶揄当前 AI 对学术环境的影响。 此前，有分析显示 ICLR 2026 约21%的评审意见被怀疑完全由 AI 生成，引发了学术界对评审质量和 AI 滥用的担忧。Dan Roy 的讽刺性请愿实则抛出一个深层问题：当论文生产、投稿和评审都可能大量依赖 AI 时，单纯限制投稿数量或许并非根本解决之道。

一名作者,一届顶级 AI 会议,到底参与多少篇论文比较合适?

ICLR 给出的答案是 20 篇。

近日,ICLR 2027 公布新的投稿规则,明确规定,任何作者最多只能出现在 20 篇投稿的作者名单中,超出配额的论文会在摘要提交阶段收到提醒。如果到全文截止时仍未调整,会议将随机拒绝部分论文,直到每位作者都回到限额以内......

ICLR 给出的解释很简单:投稿数量增长过快,评审系统已经承受巨大压力,需要通过配额维持公平且有信息量的评审。

而这背后,是来自 ICLR 2026 经历的投稿与评审「危机」。

资料显示,ICLR 2026 共收到 19525 篇有效投稿,最终 13763 篇论文获得正式接收或拒绝决定,背后涉及 18054 名评审提供的 76139 份审稿意见。

而相较于 ICLR 2025 的约 11603 篇投稿,2026 年的投稿量增长了约 68%。这意味着,一年之内,会议需要额外消化接近 8000 篇论文,以及数万份评审任务......

消息一经公布,引起网友的热议。Google DeepMind 访问研究员、加拿大多伦多大学教授 Dan Roy 也注意到这一改变,并针对这一规则发起一场「请愿」:请愿取消在 ICLR 会议中对论文投稿限制在 20 篇。

他在 X 上发文写道:

「ICLR 将每位作者的投稿数量限制在 20 篇,这太荒谬了!也会拖慢人工智能的发展。

为什么偏偏是 20 篇?这完全是一个随意设定的数字。如今,AI Agent 已经能够在几乎不需要多少指导的情况下,完成一些有趣但偏渐进式的 AI 研究工作。我们应该鼓励所有人尽可能多地完成并提交论文,尤其是现在所有评审工作都已经交给大语言模型处理了...... 承认吧!

点击链接,签署我的请愿书!」

显然,Dan Roy 对 20 篇的数量限制明显不满,但也在偷偷「揶揄」当前 AI 对学术环境的影响。整条帖子带有反讽意味。

比如,ICLR 提醒研究者,目前的 AI Agent 仍无法独立完成一篇达到顶会标准的论文。代码助手和研究基础设施提高效率后,研究者应当挑战更有雄心的问题,提交更加完整、成熟的成果,减少大量渐进式论文涌入会议。

而 Dan Roy 则把这套表述完全反了过来。

ICLR 希望看到更完整的「慢科学」,Dan Roy 就假装主张「让 Agent 尽可能多地生产渐进式成果」;ICLR 试图限制论文「洪水」,他则假装担心,「这会拖慢人工智能发展」。

尤其是「现在所有评审工作都已经交给大语言模型处理了...... 承认吧」,也在讽刺,其实大模型不止进入论文写作环节,同行评审环节也同样存在 AI 的身影。

这一点,Dan Roy 并没有夸张。

2025 年底,在 ICLR 2026 的审稿高峰期间,卡内基梅隆大学的著名 AI 研究员 Graham Neubig 在收到几份审稿意见后,察觉到异常,怀疑有 AI 的「水分」,于是,利用 Pangram Labs 开发的 AI 文本检测工具 EditLens,对会议公开的评审意见进行了扫描分析。

结果显示,在对 75800 条评审意见进行检测后发现,约有 21% 的评审意见被高度怀疑为「完全由 AI 生成」。

消息一经传出,业界哗然,更是引发学术界对评审质量下滑及「AI 滥用」的担忧。

或许,在这场「请愿」中,Dan Roy 真正想提出的问题是,当「Agent 批量生成论文、研究者批量投稿、审稿人再用大模型批量完成评审」的情况愈发成为常态的时刻,直接「一刀切」,仅仅通过限制论文投掷数量,也许并非良策......

那么你呢,如何看待 ICLR 的做法,以及 Dan Roy 的「请愿」?欢迎在评论区留言、交流!

参考链接:

https://iclr.cc/Conferences/2027/AuthorGuidelines

https://x.com/roydanroy/status/2083202134414102594

本文来自微信公众号“机器之心”(ID:almosthuman2014),作者:关注AI的

Trending Cryptos

ctr
CitreaCTR
wstusdt
wrapped stUSDTWSTUSDT
apr
aPrioriAPR
ctx
Cryptex FinanceCTX
audio
AudiusAUDIO
comp
CompoundCOMP
mantra
MantraMANTRA
waxl
AxelarWAXL
bill
Billions NetworkBILL
pyth
PYTH (Pyth)PYTH
rune
THORChainRUNE
brev
BrevisBREV
zrx
ZRX（0X）ZRX
cake
PancakeSwapCAKE
jst
JUSTJST

Related Questions

QICLR 2027新规对每名作者的最大投稿数量限制是多少？

AICLR 2027新规限制每名作者最多只能在20篇投稿的作者名单中出现。

QICLR实施作者投稿限额的主要原因是什么？

A主要原因是投稿数量增长过快（如ICLR 2026较2025年增长约68%），评审系统承受巨大压力，需要通过配额来维持公平且有信息量的评审。

QGoogle DeepMind研究员Dan Roy对ICLR新规发起了什么行动？其真实意图是什么？

ADan Roy在X上发起了一场要求“取消ICLR会议中对论文投稿限制在20篇”的请愿。但这并非其真实意图，其发帖带有明显的反讽意味，旨在讽刺当前AI Agent批量生成论文以及大语言模型可能参与同行评审的学术生态，质疑单纯限制投稿数量并非根本解决之道。

Q根据文章，ICLR 2026的审稿意见中，被高度怀疑为完全由AI生成的比例大概是多少？

A根据对ICLR 2026公开的约75800条评审意见的扫描分析，约有21%的评审意见被高度怀疑为“完全由AI生成”。

Q文章中提到，面对AI工具提升研究效率的背景，ICLR官方希望研究者朝什么方向努力？

AICLR官方希望研究者在代码助手和研究基础设施提高效率后，去挑战更有雄心的问题，提交更加完整、成熟的成果，即鼓励“慢科学”，以减少大量渐进式论文涌入会议。

Related Reads

Bithumb Reveals Timeline for Exchange Listing

South Korean cryptocurrency exchange Bithumb has unveiled its roadmap for an initial public offering (IPO), aiming to complete the listing by 2028. The plan includes strengthening internal controls in 2026 and transitioning its accounting to Korean International Financial Reporting Standards (K-IFRS). In 2027, Bithumb intends to apply for a preliminary listing review with local authorities. The company noted that the timeline could shift due to market conditions and regulatory processes. The IPO has been under discussion for years, with initial plans targeting a 2025 listing on KOSDAQ. However, the timeline has been postponed several times. Bithumb is currently restructuring its business to separate responsibilities, streamline operations, and diversify its revenue model away from trading fees. The exchange's internal controls came under scrutiny in early 2026 following a major operational error. During a promotional campaign, an employee mistakenly credited users with approximately 620,000 BTC instead of Korean won, far exceeding the exchange's actual reserves of about 46,000 BTC. This caused Bitcoin's price on the platform to plummet by 15%. Bithumb recovered about 99.7% of the erroneously distributed assets but was unable to retrieve roughly 125 BTC.

cryptonews.ru2m ago

Bithumb Reveals Timeline for Exchange Listing

cryptonews.ru2m ago

SEC to Review Approval of Nasdaq's Bitcoin Options Following CME's Challenge

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has suspended its approval of Nasdaq PHLX's cash-settled bitcoin index options (QBTC) and will review the decision following a legal challenge from CME Group, according to a July 31 order. The SEC had granted conditional approval for the product in May, pending an exemption from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). CME Group petitioned against the SEC's approval in June, arguing that bitcoin is a commodity. Consequently, options directly linked to its price should fall under the exclusive jurisdiction of the CFTC, not the SEC. CME contends that if it is correct, the SEC lacks the authority to approve QBTC. This would require Nasdaq to register as a CFTC-regulated futures or swaps exchange or redesign the contracts to track bitcoin-related securities like a spot ETF. The petition also warns that the SEC's approval could set a precedent allowing securities exchanges to list derivatives on other commodities. Notably, Nasdaq's proposed contracts would utilize CME CF benchmarks. The SEC's order suspends the May approval and invites public comments until August 24. The stay took effect on June 11. The SEC's initial approval was contingent on CFTC exemptions, which CME argues agencies cannot use to transfer a product between regulators. QBTC will remain on hold pending a full commission review.

cryptonews.ru2m ago

SEC to Review Approval of Nasdaq's Bitcoin Options Following CME's Challenge

cryptonews.ru2m ago

Robinhood's Revenue Structure Undergoes Dramatic Shift: Predictive Markets Revenue Surpasses Stock Trading

Robinhood's revenue structure has undergone a major shift, with income from its prediction markets now surpassing that from stock trading. In its Q2 report, Robinhood revealed prediction market revenue soared over tenfold year-over-year to $156 million, accounting for 20% of total trading revenue and becoming its second-largest trading business after options, less than two years after its launch. Analysts attribute this growth to the platform's user base, which is drawn to the instant, simple "yes/no" betting format on real-world events like sports and elections. The recent surge was significantly driven by the World Cup. Robinhood initially partnered with platform Kalshi but has since moved to gain more control by co-founding its own trading platform, Rothera, with Susquehanna International Group, reducing its dependence on Kalshi. While Robinhood's prediction market business is growing rapidly—now at a $600+ million annualized revenue run rate—Kalshi remains the dominant player in the space. The industry is attracting new competitors like Coinbase but faces regulatory uncertainty, with ongoing legal challenges over whether prediction markets constitute unregistered gambling or fall under financial derivatives regulation.

marsbit12m ago

Robinhood's Revenue Structure Undergoes Dramatic Shift: Predictive Markets Revenue Surpasses Stock Trading

marsbit12m ago

How Yen Intervention Affects Bitcoin: QCP Capital Breaks Down the Risk Chain for the Crypto Market

Trading firm QCP Capital has analyzed the impact of the recent coordinated US-Japan currency intervention on Bitcoin and Ethereum. They conclude that US long-term Treasury yields and the Japanese yen's status are now as crucial for the crypto market as Federal Reserve policy. The intervention, the first joint action to support the yen since 1998, occurs amid significant pressure on the long end of the US Treasury yield curve, with 30-year yields recently hitting 2007 highs. QCP notes this rise isn't solely driven by inflation expectations, pointing to factors like real yields, supply from substantial US government and corporate borrowing, and shifting demand from major foreign holders like Japan. For crypto assets, the primary transmission channel is the yen carry trade. A sharp yen strengthening could force investors to unwind these leveraged positions, potentially causing spillover selling in risk assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum. However, QCP stresses this outcome isn't guaranteed given the still-wide US-Japan rate differential. The firm outlines two scenarios: short-term yen volatility could increase market-wide deleveraging and crypto volatility, while longer-term currency stability might ease pressure on Treasury liquidity. Ultimately, the intervention highlights that factors beyond the Fed—like Treasury borrowing plans and currency operations—are increasingly important for global liquidity and, consequently, crypto markets. From a data perspective, the intervention signals a broader shift where central banks favor gold over US Treasuries for strategic reserves. This places Bitcoin in a dual role: competing with gold as a hedge while remaining exposed to dollar liquidity via the yen carry trade. Future interventions may clarify whether crypto behaves more as "digital gold" or a risk asset within the dollar system.

cryptonews.ru41m ago

How Yen Intervention Affects Bitcoin: QCP Capital Breaks Down the Risk Chain for the Crypto Market

cryptonews.ru41m ago

Ripple invests in Zilo and Licuido to assist tokenized capital markets push

Ripple has made strategic investments in two UK-based companies, Zilo and Licuido, to expand its capabilities in tokenized capital markets. Zilo offers transfer agency solutions for wealth managers, while Licuido is a regulated tokenization provider. These investments aim to bring regulated services like transfer agency, issuance, and collateral mobility to Ripple's XRP Ledger (XRPL), addressing issues with idle collateral by allowing tokenized funds to be used as collateral from issuance. This follows the recent launch of Aviva Investors' tokenized fund share class on XRPL. Ripple also recently introduced its stablecoin platform, Ripple Mint. XRPL currently ranks as the 11th-largest blockchain for tokenized real-world assets (RWAs), with $368 million, while the total value of all tokenized assets recently reached $37.3 billion.

cointelegraph42m ago

Ripple invests in Zilo and Licuido to assist tokenized capital markets push

cointelegraph42m ago

Trading

Spot

Hot Articles

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of AI (AI) are presented below.

活动图片

Top Questions