Vitalik: We Shouldn't Oppose AI, But Create Sanctuaries

marsbitPublished on 2026-05-17Last updated on 2026-05-17

Abstract

Summary: In a podcast, Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin discusses the human response to advancing AI. He argues the core risk isn't AI's intelligence, but humanity's passive reliance on centralized systems and AI, which erodes privacy and personal agency. His solution is not to fight AI, but to build "sanctuary technologies"—tools like Ethereum that offer safe, optional spaces where individuals can retain sovereignty and freedom of choice without being forced into a single system. Buterin reflects on his shift from an "autopilot" mode in his youth to actively "piloting" his life and work. He stresses the importance of maintaining "manual mode" activities—like learning actively and performing tasks without AI assistance—to prevent mental atrophy and preserve independent thought. For builders, his advice is to prioritize technologies that protect human agency, avoid outsourcing all strategic thinking, and actively engage in serendipitous, real-world interactions. He repositions Ethereum/crypto not as a fix for legacy systems like the dollar, but as a parallel, voluntary option. In an era of increasing centralization, the freedom to opt-in or opt-out becomes invaluable. The key takeaway is that the AI era demands greater human proactivity; the scarcest resource will remain actively thinking, sovereign individuals.

Author: Saito

Just finished listening to this episode of Vitalik's podcast with a16z, and the amount of information was mind-blowing.

He founded Ethereum at 19 and is now in his early 30s, having transitioned from living on "autopilot" to "actively piloting."

The core topic of this episode is the question we are most anxious about today: AI is getting stronger, so what should humans do?

Vitalik's answer is not to "oppose AI," but to create sanctuary technologies. These are technologies that protect us without stripping away our privacy and agency (sovereignty).

Today, I'll break down the hardest counter-intuitive points, practical advice, and Ethereum's new positioning from this episode.

The Biggest Risk in the AI Era Isn't That AI Is Too Smart, But That Humans Are Too Passive

Vitalik bluntly stated that the world today is less secure and less peaceful than it was 10 to 15 years ago.

Many people are pursuing a kind of "safety": handing everything over to "Uncle in the Sky," meaning big companies, super AIs, centralized systems, letting them make decisions for us, manage risks, and provide protection.

But the cost of this safety is that we lose privacy and lose agency.

Vitalik calls this kind of safety disempowering safety, safety that increasingly weakens people.

This is also where he reinterprets the mission of crypto / Ethereum. The significance of Ethereum is not to "fix the dollar," not to repair the existing financial system, but to create a new option. You are free to choose whether to use it or not.

This is what a true sanctuary is: both safe and allowing you to retain sovereignty.

Sanctuary Technologies: Small Spaces Preserving Human Freedom

Sanctuary Technologies is a term coined by Vitalik himself, and "庇护所技术" (bì hù suǒ jì shù, sanctuary technology) is a fitting translation.

It's not about turning the whole world into a safe house, nor is it about ruling everyone with a larger system. What it truly aims to do is: give you a safe, small space where you can think, coordinate, and create freely without being completely controlled by external forces.

It has several core characteristics: it is not totalizing, it does not attempt to rule the entire world; it preserves privacy and agency; everyone can freely enter and exit, it is not mandatory.

Ethereum is a typical sanctuary tech. It doesn't try to fix the existing financial system; it gives you a parallel option. Use it if you want, don't if you don't.

This will become increasingly important in the AI era. Because as big companies and super AIs become stronger, what humans truly need is not another system that "arranges everything for you," but a space that preserves your right to choose.

From Autopilot to Active Pilot: Vitalik's Personal Growth

Vitalik reflected that when he founded Ethereum at 19, he was largely in an autopilot state.

Many decisions were made by going with the flow: dropping out, writing the whitepaper, being denied a visa by Ripple, which instead became a turning point in his life. Back then, he was more like being pushed along by the world.

But now he is increasingly realizing: the world changes too fast, no one is coming to save you, you must be the pilot yourself.

He gave a few very relatable examples. Ten years ago, people could go days without contacting friends; now, not replying to a message for a day causes anxiety. Ten years ago, you could actually get "lost" while walking; now, with phone navigation, cities have become a series of "teleportation points."

These changes remind us: the world "dies and is reborn" every 5 to 10 years. If you keep living by the old script, you'll fall behind quickly.

So what's truly important in the AI era is not passively waiting for technology to take you somewhere, but actively deciding how you will use technology.

The Stronger AI Gets, The More Humans Must Keep "Manual Mode"

Vitalik specifically emphasized: active learning is 10 times more effective than passive learning, even if you spend the same amount of time.

From a young age, he would force himself to do many things manually, like not using a calculator in chemistry class or not using navigation while walking. The goal wasn't to be anti-technology, but to keep his brain engaged.

The stronger AI gets, the more we should deliberately retain some "manual mode."

Sometimes deliberately not using AI to write code, sometimes deliberately walking without navigation, sometimes deliberately not letting a chatbot think through problems for you.

This isn't nostalgia, nor is it rejecting efficiency; it's to prevent brain atrophy and maintain one's own agency.

AI can help us do many things, but if all thinking, judgment, and exploration are outsourced, people will slowly become passengers in the system. Vitalik's reminder is: you can use AI, but don't let yourself become completely dependent on it.

Practical Advice for Builders

In this episode, the inspiration Vitalik gives to ordinary builders is very direct.

First, force yourself to do things manually. Even if AI can help you, occasionally do things yourself to ensure your brain doesn't get rusty.

Second, active learning. Don't just let AI give you answers; deduce, verify, and do things yourself.

Third, build sanctuary technologies. Whether you're building open-source tools, decentralized protocols, or a personal knowledge base, prioritize one thing: does it help people retain sovereignty?

Fourth, don't outsource all your brainpower. AI can help you with execution, but strategy, direction, and values must be controlled by you.

Fifth, maintain serendipity. Participate more in offline events, talk more with real people, don't leave all discoveries to algorithm recommendations.

These points all essentially point to the same core: the AI era isn't about using tools less, but about using tools more actively.

Ethereum's New Positioning: Not Fixing the Old World, But Creating New Options

Vitalik is also clear about crypto's positioning.

Crypto can't solve all of the dollar's problems, and it doesn't need to pretend it can solve all problems. But it can create something new without those shortcomings.

Everyone can freely choose to use it or not.

This is crypto's greatest strength: it doesn't force you; it gives you choice.

In an era where AI power is increasingly concentrated, this will become increasingly precious. Because as more and more systems try to make decisions for you, filter information for you, and judge risks for you, a parallel option that is non-coercive and allows free entry and exit becomes very important in itself.

The value of Ethereum / crypto is not "beating the old world," but giving you a new world you can freely choose.

The Most Counter-Intuitive Lines from This Episode

The biggest risk in the AI era is not AI replacing humans, but humans willingly turning themselves into passengers.

A sanctuary isn't about making the whole world safe, but giving you a safe, small space where you can still retain freedom.

Active learning is 10 times more effective than passive learning, even with the same time spent.

The world dies and is reborn every 5 to 10 years; we must be our own pilot.

Inspiration for Ordinary People

The stronger AI gets, the more proactive humans must be.

Don't outsource all your thinking to models. Do more manual things to keep your brain engaged. Participate in building tools that preserve human sovereignty, whether open-source, decentralized, or personal knowledge management systems.

Remember: technology ultimately serves humans, it does not replace humans.

Vitalik concluded by saying that we humans are the brightest stars. AI can be strong, but what truly drives the world forward are still active, agentic people.

Summary in One Sentence

With his 10 years of personal experience, Vitalik tells us: The AI era is not an era to lie back, but an era that requires humans to actively pilot more than ever.

Don't outsource your brain to models. Do more manual things, build sanctuary technologies, preserve your privacy and agency.

My biggest takeaway after listening to this episode is: Before, we feared AI taking our jobs; now it seems AI is actually upgrading people from "executors" to "designers."

What's truly scarce has never been computing power, but people willing to think actively and preserve their sovereignty.

Related Questions

QAccording to Vitalik, what is the main approach we should take towards AI, and what is the core concept behind it?

AThe main approach is not to fight against AI, but to create 'Sanctuary Technologies'. The core concept is to build safe spaces that protect humans without stripping away their privacy and agency (sovereignty).

QWhat does Vitalik mean by 'disempowering safety', and why is it a risk in the AI era?

A'Disempowering safety' refers to the kind of security gained by handing over decision-making, risk management, and protection to big companies, super AIs, or centralized systems. The risk is that while it offers safety, the cost is the loss of human privacy and agency, making people increasingly passive.

QBased on the article, what is the new purpose or positioning of Ethereum/crypto as explained by Vitalik?

AVitalik repositions Ethereum/crypto not as a tool to 'fix' or replace the old world (like the current financial system), but as a creator of a new, parallel option. Its power lies in offering people a voluntary choice—to use it or not—thereby providing a sanctuary where one can retain sovereignty.

QWhat are the practical suggestions Vitalik offers for builders and individuals in the AI era?

A1. Force yourself to do things manually sometimes to keep your brain active. 2. Engage in active learning (self-derivation, verification) rather than just accepting AI answers. 3. Build tools and technologies that help preserve human sovereignty (sanctuary technologies). 4. Don't outsource all strategic thinking and values to AI; maintain personal control over direction. 5. Keep serendipity alive through real-world interactions and not relying solely on algorithmic recommendations.

QWhat is the 'most counter-intuitive' point Vitalik makes about learning and human agency in relation to AI?

AHe states that 'active learning is 10 times more effective than passive learning, even if the time spent is the same.' This underscores the importance of maintaining manual, self-directed thinking and agency to prevent mental atrophy, especially as AI grows more powerful.

Related Reads

AI Trading Cools, South Korean Stocks Plunge 1.8%, Spot Gold Rises 1%, Bitcoin Dives

A sell-off in AI-related stocks, triggered by Broadcom's disappointing earnings forecast, sent shockwaves through global markets. South Korea's KOSPI led Asia's decline, plunging 1.8% as the risks from concentrated chip stock gains and surging leveraged investments came to the fore. The tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 futures fell 0.5% following Broadcom's 14% after-hours plunge, which signaled a slower-than-expected transition to AI clients. This pullback extended Wall Street's weakness, halting the S&P 500's nine-day rally amid hawkish Fed signals and renewed Middle East tensions. South Korean authorities convened an emergency meeting, pledging "immediate measures" against market volatility and warning of record-high stock margin debt. The adjustment rippled across assets: Bitcoin fell to around $64,000, its lowest since February, while safe-haven gold rose 1% on bargain hunting. Oil prices dipped on Middle East ceasefire news. Market analysts noted the sell-off was driven by profit-taking after massive gains, particularly in chip stocks like Samsung and SK Hynix, which now dominate the KOSPI. Wall Street banks are divided on Korea's outlook, with Goldman Sachs raising its target while Citigroup and others warn of overvaluation and a potential bubble. Bridgewater's Ray Dalio noted that great technological shifts often create bubbles. Meanwhile, Fed officials' hints at potential future rate hikes added to the cautious mood ahead of key U.S. jobs data.

华尔街日报8m ago

AI Trading Cools, South Korean Stocks Plunge 1.8%, Spot Gold Rises 1%, Bitcoin Dives

华尔街日报8m ago

Seeking Alpha's Hot Article: Why Might the U.S. Stock Market Crash in June?

In a recent Seeking Alpha article, financial professor and analyst Damir Tokic argues that the US stock market may be poised for a significant crash in June 2026. The core thesis centers on a "mega-bubble" in equities, particularly within the technology sector, which has driven the S&P 500 to near-record valuations, with a Shiller P/E ratio exceeding 40—a level comparable to the 2000 dot-com bubble. Tokic identifies two primary catalysts for a potential collapse. First, he points to unsustainable market exuberance fueled by what he terms the "Trump Stimulus"—massive AI capital expenditure by tech giants, which he believes is politically driven and cannot last. Second, and more urgently, he highlights the escalating Iran war as a critical threat. The ongoing closure of the Strait of Hormuz has created a severe global energy supply crunch. Strategic petroleum reserves are projected to hit critically low operational levels by June, potentially causing oil prices to spike above $200 per barrel and triggering a severe, supply-driven inflationary shock. This scenario, Tokic warns, would force the Federal Reserve's hand. Despite currently maintaining a dovish bias, the Fed would likely be compelled to officially pivot to a hawkish stance at its June FOMC meeting to combat soaring inflation and bond yields. He contends that such a shift—or even a failure to act, which would destroy Fed credibility—could be the trigger that punctures the market bubble. The resulting downturn, he concludes, could rival the bear markets of 2000 and 2008, advising investors to prepare for a major correction.

marsbit30m ago

Seeking Alpha's Hot Article: Why Might the U.S. Stock Market Crash in June?

marsbit30m ago

AI PC Battle: Bet on the Toll Booth, Not the Camp

**Title:** The AI PC Battle: Don't Bet on Sides, Bet on the Tollbooth **Summary:** The AI PC competition is moving beyond simple "x86 vs. Arm" narratives. The core investment thesis should focus on identifying which players can sustain margins, cash flow, and pricing power throughout the upgrade cycle, rather than backing a particular architecture. The opportunity is analyzed in three layers: 1. **The Advanced Foundry Tollbooth:** TSMC is positioned to collect "tolls" regardless of which chip designer wins, due to its dominant ~70% share in advanced semiconductor manufacturing, which is essential for high-end AI PC chips. 2. **Compute & Platform Spillover:** AMD represents an offensive in the x86 CPU+GPU space, while NVIDIA leverages its GPU and CUDA software stack dominance. Both benefit from the demand for increased local AI compute. 3. **Architecture Diffusion & Turnaround Plays:** ARM and Intel offer potential for significant upside (elasticity), but investments here require stricter discipline due to higher execution risks and competitive challenges. The industry is transitioning from concept to shipment validation. While short-term forecasts for AI PC adoption have been revised down slightly due to tariffs and procurement delays, the long-term trend towards AI becoming a standard PC feature remains intact. The key driver for upgrade cycles will be whether compelling enterprise applications (e.g., privacy-sensitive computing, low-latency inference) emerge beyond consumer-focused features like meeting summarization. Investment strategy should prioritize companies with platform-level advantages and recurring revenue streams. TSMC offers high certainty as the foundational tollbooth. AMD presents a strong offensive play within the established ecosystem. ARM and Intel are higher-risk, higher-potential-reward turnaround bets. The report cautions against chasing short-term hype and emphasizes a disciplined, long-term approach focused on buying ecosystem strength and cash-flow certainty after market enthusiasm subsides. **Key Risks:** Underwhelming AI PC applications slowing upgrade cycles; slow improvement in Windows on Arm compatibility; macro/tariff impacts on PC demand; potential advanced node supply-demand mismatches affecting TSMC; high overall AI sector valuations making stocks vulnerable to a risk-off shift in markets.

marsbit45m ago

AI PC Battle: Bet on the Toll Booth, Not the Camp

marsbit45m ago

Ten-Thousand-Word Analysis: From $10 to $290, MRVL Wins the Entire AI Era by 'Not Making GPUs'

Marvell Technology's stock price surged from under $10 in 2016 to a record $290 in June 2026, fueled not by making GPUs, but by dominating AI infrastructure connectivity. This analysis argues the market misvalues MRVL as merely a smaller Broadcom in custom AI chips, overlooking its true, unique position. Marvell's core strength lies in enabling high-speed data flow for AI clusters through three interconnected businesses. First, it holds a commanding ~70% market share in high-speed optical DSPs (essential for data center light modules), a deep-moat business with accelerating growth. Second, its custom AI chip design business serves hyperscalers like AWS, Microsoft, and Google, with a significant revenue pipeline despite lower margins. Third, stable cash flows come from Ethernet switch chips and enterprise storage controllers. Together, they form a full-stack "AI data movement" platform. CEO Matt Murphy's transformative leadership since 2016, involving strategic divestments, key acquisitions (like Inphi for optical DSPs), and securing long-term agreements with major cloud providers, repositioned the company. A pivotal $2 billion strategic investment from NVIDIA in 2026 underscored Marvell's critical role in the AI ecosystem, particularly through collaborations like NVLink Fusion. While Marvell faces risks—including client concentration (losing the Amazon Trainium3 design), lower-margin business mix, competitive threats, insider selling, and complex supply chains—its fundamentals remain strong. The optical interconnect moat is widening with the acquisition of Celestial AI (photonics fabric), and financial metrics show accelerating revenue growth and operating leverage. With a PEG ratio suggesting undervaluation relative to its growth, the thesis is that the market undervalues Marvell's monopolistic position in AI "plumbing" while overemphasizing its competitive custom chip segment. The story transcends investing, symbolizing how in any complex system—from the internet to AI—the value of "connection" ultimately surpasses that of individual "nodes."

marsbit1h ago

Ten-Thousand-Word Analysis: From $10 to $290, MRVL Wins the Entire AI Era by 'Not Making GPUs'

marsbit1h ago

Trading

Spot
Futures

Hot Articles

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of AI (AI) are presented below.

活动图片