The Ethereum Doomsday Scenario: Inside The Bank Of Italy’s Crisis Simulation

bitcoinistОпубликовано 2026-01-13Обновлено 2026-01-13

Введение

The Bank of Italy published a technical analysis exploring the potential consequences if Ethereum's value were to fall to zero and remain there. The paper frames this as a stress test on infrastructure, not just asset prices. It warns that if ETH loses its value, the economic incentive for validators—who are paid in ETH—would disappear. This could lead validators to exit the network, severely slowing or even stopping transaction settlement. The paper further cautions that other assets on the chain, such as tokenized securities or stablecoins, could become difficult to move or face security risks. While the scenario is not presented as likely, the analysis highlights how market risk can transform into infrastructure risk, especially since there is no formal mechanism to orderly shut down a permissionless blockchain.

The Bank of Italy ran a technical analysis that asks a stark question: What happens if Ethereum (ETH) falls to zero and stays there?

The recently released paper is authored by Claudia Biancotti for the Bank’s Markets, Infrastructures, Payment Systems series. It is listed as Number 74 and runs 11 pages.

Bank Of Italy Issues Technical Analysis

According to the Bank, permissionless blockchains like Ethereum act as settlement systems for a wide range of tokens and contracts. The institution treats the question as a stress test on infrastructure rather than only on asset prices.

The note warns that if a native token loses most of its market value and the drop remains persistent, the economic incentives that keep validators running could vanish. Validators might exit, the paper says, and that could make settlement slow or stop.

Source: Bank of Italy

What The Paper Found

Based on reports in the Bank’s paper, the chain of effects is simple and worrying. Validators are paid in ETH. If ETH has next to no value, that payment no longer motivates operators.

As a result, transaction settlement could slow dramatically or, in extreme cases, halt. The paper also highlights that other assets using the chain — for example, tokenized securities or fully backed stablecoins — could become hard to move or could face security problems if the network’s defenses weaken.

Ethereum: Context And Reaction

Italy’s broader regulators have recently stepped up their look at crypto risks. Reports show the Economy Ministry ordered a review of safeguards, and the Bank of Italy’s paper fits into that wider push to quantify risks tied to new payment systems.

Reuters and other outlets covered the regulator-level review in December and January as authorities pressed firms to meet emerging rules.

Potential System Risks

The authors do not claim the scenario is likely. Instead, the exercise is framed as a way to show how market risk can turn into infrastructure risk. The paper points out there is no formal mechanism to “shut down” a permissionless chain in an orderly way.

Any mitigation would rely on voluntary action by validators, major staking firms, or protocol changes proposed and adopted by the community. That uncertainty is the main policy concern.

The Bank of Italy’s note is a technical, measured look at a worst-case scenario. It uses concrete data to argue that a collapse in Ethereum market value would not only hit holders but could also impair the functioning of systems that now run on Ethereum.

Featured image from Gemini, chart from TradingView

Связанные с этим вопросы

QWhat is the main question explored in the Bank of Italy's technical analysis paper?

AThe paper explores the question of what would happen if Ethereum (ETH) were to fall to zero and stay there, treating it as a stress test on financial infrastructure.

QAccording to the paper, what is the primary risk if the value of ETH becomes nearly worthless?

AThe primary risk is that the economic incentives for validators would vanish, which could cause them to exit the network, leading to dramatically slowed or even halted transaction settlement.

QBeyond the native ETH asset, what other types of assets on the Ethereum chain could be affected in this doomsday scenario?

AOther assets like tokenized securities or fully backed stablecoins could become hard to move or could face security problems if the network's defenses weaken due to validator exit.

QHow does the Bank of Italy frame the likelihood of this 'Ethereum falling to zero' scenario actually happening?

AThe authors do not claim the scenario is likely. Instead, they frame the exercise as a way to show how market risk can transform into infrastructure risk.

QWhat is identified as the main policy concern stemming from this analysis?

AThe main policy concern is the uncertainty, as there is no formal mechanism to 'shut down' a permissionless blockchain in an orderly way, and any mitigation would rely on voluntary action from validators, staking firms, or the community.

Похожее

Michael Saylor's Latest Article: Bitcoin Must Find Balance Between Uniqueness and Universal Value

Michael Saylor outlines four key Bitcoin ideologies shaping its future: * **Bitcoin Maximalists** see Bitcoin as the dominant digital monetary network and a breakthrough in economic empowerment, emphasizing its superior property rights and role as a sound money solution. * **Bitcoin Capitalists** focus on integration, believing Bitcoin must embed into the global economy—through institutions, capital markets, and financial products—to reach its full potential as digital capital. * **Bitcoin Technologists** advocate for continuous protocol improvements in scalability, privacy, and security to adapt to evolving needs and threats, while acknowledging the high bar for change. * **Bitcoin Fundamentalists** guard Bitcoin's core principles of self-custody, decentralization, and censorship resistance, warning against dilution from institutions or risky modifications. Saylor argues that a healthy Bitcoin ecosystem requires a balance of these perspectives. Bitcoin's path forward involves disciplined expansion: preserving its immutable core (Fundamentalist insight), recognizing its dominant status (Maximalist view), integrating with the global economy (Capitalist drive), and enabling careful innovation, primarily in higher layers (Technologist role). The challenge is to maintain Bitcoin's unique properties while making it useful for the world, ensuring it remains Bitcoin as it grows.

Foresight News12 мин. назад

Michael Saylor's Latest Article: Bitcoin Must Find Balance Between Uniqueness and Universal Value

Foresight News12 мин. назад

Reddit Weekly Hot Stock Watch: RKLB/LUNR/ASTS Plunge Collectively, Is the Space Sector Still Worth Considering?

Reddit's stock communities witnessed a concentrated surge in discussion around space stocks last week, with SPCE, RKLB, LUNR, and ASTS leading the chatter. This often signals an underlying catalyst for investor attention. However, despite being grouped as "space plays," these companies have vastly different fundamentals and recent performances. While SPCE (Virgin Galactic) saw a 22% single-day surge—potentially fueled by short covering and fallout from Blue Origin's rocket test anomaly—the other three stocks declined sharply. RKLB dropped 15%, LUNR fell 13%, and ASTS was down 7%. This divergence highlights they are not a monolithic sector. The downturn for RKLB, LUNR, and ASTS stemmed from multiple headwinds converging: Blue Origin's New Glenn rocket explosion (directly impacting ASTS's launch plans), anticipation of SpaceX's massive IPO drawing funds away from these "alternative" public space stocks, and insider selling at RKLB after significant rallies. A closer look reveals key differences: RKLB stands out with substantial, growing revenue ($113.9M in Q1) and a $2.2B backlog, though its high valuation (~80x Forward P/S) prices in success for its upcoming Neutron rocket. LUNR's reported revenue growth is largely acquisition-driven, with its core moon landing business facing a crucial test with the upcoming IM-3 mission. ASTS has a large potential market in space-based cellular connectivity but faces significant execution risk, especially after the Blue Origin launch setback. SPCE, despite high discussion volume, has minimal revenue and its recent spike appears driven more by sentiment than fundamentals. The analysis suggests it's premature to call a "buying opportunity" for the sector broadly. RKLB is considered the most fundamentally sound but may be more attractive at a lower price point ($96-$102). For the others, investors are advised to wait for specific catalysts: LUNR's IM-3 mission outcome, clarity on ASTS's revised launch timeline, and for SPCE, to avoid the speculative frenzy. The long-term space thesis remains, but short-term valuations have run ahead of fundamentals for most names.

marsbit27 мин. назад

Reddit Weekly Hot Stock Watch: RKLB/LUNR/ASTS Plunge Collectively, Is the Space Sector Still Worth Considering?

marsbit27 мин. назад

Why Does Crypto Always Build 'Casinos', But Rarely Creates 'Indispensable Products'?

The article explores why cryptocurrency has primarily fostered speculation rather than essential, "sticky" consumer products. It introduces the concept of "sofalarity"—the point where a platform's convenience becomes so ingrained that leaving feels unthinkable. While Big Tech creates this lock-in through ecosystem control and data harvesting, crypto lacks equivalent everyday utility. Its appeal hinges on the variable rewards of price volatility, akin to gambling, which drives engagement but not dependency. The author argues crypto's core promise—fixing opaque backend systems like correspondent banking—solves problems most people never see or feel, failing to deliver a tangible "aha moment" of improved daily life. This need for explanation hinders mass adoption. Meanwhile, platforms like Google and Meta monetize vast behavioral data, a treasure trove crypto's transparent ledgers (recording only financial transactions) cannot match for predictive insight. The piece further questions whether crypto's potential lies in consumer super-apps or, more plausibly, in becoming enterprise-grade infrastructure—modern settlement rails. It concludes with a critical look at Real-World Asset (RWA) tokenization, suggesting it may merely digitize and accelerate corporate extraction (e.g., in housing or healthcare) rather than democratize access, as the technology itself is a neutral tool. True disruption, the author implies, requires building sovereign systems outside exploitative platforms.

marsbit28 мин. назад

Why Does Crypto Always Build 'Casinos', But Rarely Creates 'Indispensable Products'?

marsbit28 мин. назад

Торговля

Спот
Фьючерсы

Популярные статьи

Как купить S

Добро пожаловать на HTX.com! Мы сделали приобретение Sonic (S) простым и удобным. Следуйте нашему пошаговому руководству и отправляйтесь в свое крипто-путешествие.Шаг 1: Создайте аккаунт на HTXИспользуйте свой адрес электронной почты или номер телефона, чтобы зарегистрироваться и бесплатно создать аккаунт на HTX. Пройдите удобную регистрацию и откройте для себя весь функционал.Создать аккаунтШаг 2: Перейдите в Купить криптовалюту и выберите свой способ оплатыКредитная/Дебетовая Карта: Используйте свою карту Visa или Mastercard для мгновенной покупки Sonic (S).Баланс: Используйте средства с баланса вашего аккаунта HTX для простой торговли.Третьи Лица: Мы добавили популярные способы оплаты, такие как Google Pay и Apple Pay, для повышения удобства.P2P: Торгуйте напрямую с другими пользователями на HTX.Внебиржевая Торговля (OTC): Мы предлагаем индивидуальные услуги и конкурентоспособные обменные курсы для трейдеров.Шаг 3: Хранение Sonic (S)После приобретения вами Sonic (S) храните их в своем аккаунте на HTX. В качестве альтернативы вы можете отправить их куда-либо с помощью перевода в блокчейне или использовать для торговли с другими криптовалютами.Шаг 4: Торговля Sonic (S)С легкостью торгуйте Sonic (S) на спотовом рынке HTX. Просто зайдите в свой аккаунт, выберите торговую пару, совершайте сделки и следите за ними в режиме реального времени. Мы предлагаем удобный интерфейс как для начинающих, так и для опытных трейдеров.

1.4k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.01.15Обновлено 2026.06.02

Как купить S

Sonic: Обновления под руководством Андре Кронье – новая звезда Layer-1 на фоне спада рынка

Он решает проблемы масштабируемости, совместимости между блокчейнами и стимулов для разработчиков с помощью технологических инноваций.

2.3k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.04.09Обновлено 2025.04.09

Sonic: Обновления под руководством Андре Кронье – новая звезда Layer-1 на фоне спада рынка

HTX Learn: Пройдите обучение по "Sonic" и разделите 1000 USDT

HTX Learn — ваш проводник в мир перспективных проектов, и мы запускаем специальное мероприятие "Учитесь и Зарабатывайте", посвящённое этим проектам. Наше новое направление .

1.8k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.04.10Обновлено 2025.04.10

HTX Learn: Пройдите обучение по "Sonic" и разделите 1000 USDT

Обсуждения

Добро пожаловать в Сообщество HTX. Здесь вы сможете быть в курсе последних новостей о развитии платформы и получить доступ к профессиональной аналитической информации о рынке. Мнения пользователей о цене на S (S) представлены ниже.

活动图片