"Legal" Ponzi Scheme? Uncovering Gemini Exchange and Its Founders' Circular Lending

Author|Protos Staff

Compiled| WuBlockchain

TL;DR: Key Points from Gemini's 10-K Report and Internal Lending Cycle

·Shuffling Funds Between Hands: Founders' WCF lent crypto assets to Gemini, which then collateralized them with third parties to obtain USD loans, forming an internal circular lending scheme.

·Cheap Acquisition of Control: During the IPO, founders' debt was converted into super-voting shares at a 20% discount. Retail investors bought in at high prices, while the founders secured 94.7% voting control.

<极简主义风格，只翻译核心内容，去除冗余解释>

·Sword of Damocles

Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss lent thousands of Bitcoin ($BTC) and Ethereum ($ETH) to their own crypto exchange Gemini through their private investment firm Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF). Gemini then used these crypto assets as collateral with On September 15, 2025, the exchange went public at $28 per share and converted $695.6 million of WCF debt into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount, giving the twins direct control of 94.7% of Gemini's voting power.

Attached X platform post:

This is all a circular Ponzi scheme:

Borrow BTC from related party WCF; collateralize that BTC with lenders to get USD loans (involving Galaxy, bond issuance, NYDIG).

Deloitte issued an unqualified audit opinion: no Key Audit Matters (KAM), and said nothing about related parties, liquidity, going concern...

How is any of this legal?

Here is the basic flow of funds. The twins' WCF lent BTC and ETH to Gemini under open-term agreements.

Gemini then used these borrowed crypto assets as collateral with third-party lenders. Galaxy Digital provided a $116.5 million loan at 11–12% interest with a 145–155% collateral ratio. NYDIG provided $75 million via a repurchase agreement at 8.5%.

Gemini used this USD capital for operations and regulatory requirements.

The exchange is now listed on Nasdaq under the ticker GEMI.

It also repaid $238.5 million under the Ripple warehouse credit facility, though $154 million in Ripple debt remained outstanding at year-end.

However, the twins' own debt was not repaid in cash.

A and B shares differ only in voting rights and distribution. Otherwise, they have identical par value, dividend rights, and B shares are convertible to A shares on a one-to-one basis.

Retail paid $28, Winklevoss paid only $22.40

This discount is the core of how this circular operation harms ordinary shareholders.

WCF lent crypto to Gemini. Then,Gemini collateralized these borrowed assets to secure more loans. Specifically, Galaxy and NYDIG lent USD to Gemini for its operations.

Then, Gemini issued equity to WCF at a discount during the same IPO where retail paid 20% more.

Further reading: Sources say Winklevoss twins pulled $280 million out before Genesis collapse

In 2025, Gemini paid WCF $24.2 million in lending fees.

Despite being public, the co-founders retain overwhelming voting control.

Additionally, per crypto researcher Emmett Gallic citing Arkham Intelligence data, WCF held about 8,757 BTC in Gemini Custody addresses.

Deloitte Issues Unqualified Audit Opinion

The twins could shake the foundations of this exchange they control with a simple written notice.

Gemini's secondary market price has crashed 88% from its IPO price. "Gemini Space Station" is its legal name,寓意火箭升空, but it's now ironic. It opened at $37.01 on its first IPO day.

It's now just $4.42 per share.

Gemini set its IPO price at $28 on September 11, 2025. It opened at $37.01 the next day, briefly hit a high of $45.89, then began its decline. After hitting a 52-week low of $3.91 on Monday, it closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026, down 88% from its opening price.

Market cap has collapsed from over $3.8 billion to about $520 million. Citigroup, Cantor, Truist, and Evercore have all downgraded the stock to "Sell".

{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"FAQPage","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"What is the core mechanism of the alleged 'circular operation' between Gemini and its founders' WCF?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF) loaned crypto assets to Gemini. Gemini then used these borrowed assets as collateral to secure dollar loans from third-party lenders like Galaxy Digital and NYDIG. This created an internal circular lending loop where funds moved between the founders' entity and their own exchange."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How did the Winklevoss twins consolidate control of Gemini during its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"During the IPO, $695.6 million of debt owed to WCF was converted into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount to the $28 IPO price paid by retail investors ($22.40 per share). This gave the founders 94.7% of the voting power in the company."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What major financial liability does Gemini still owe to WCF, and what risk does it pose?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"As of December 31, 2025, Gemini still owed WCF 4,619 BTC (valued at approximately $400 million at the time). This loan is repayable on demand, posing a significant liquidity risk to the exchange if the founders were to suddenly call it in."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How has Gemini's stock performance fared since its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Gemini's stock has plummeted 88% from its IPO price of $28 and its first-day opening price of $37.01. It hit a 52-week low of $3.91 and closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026. Its market capitalization crashed from over $3.8 billion to approximately $520 million."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What was the role of the auditing firm Deloitte in this situation, according to the article?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Deloitte issued an unqualified (clean) audit opinion for Gemini. The article questions this, noting the audit report did not highlight any Key Audit Matters (KAMs) or raise concerns about related-party transactions, liquidity, or the company's going concern status despite the significant risks outlined."}}]}

Похожее

If You’re Waiting For The Bitcoin Bottom, This Pundit Says You Should Be Looking At This Quarter

Bitcoin is currently testing the $60,000 support level, with market sentiment in "extreme fear." Crypto analyst Ardi points to a historical pattern where Bitcoin has bottomed in the fourth quarter during previous bear market cycles (e.g., November 2014, December 2018, November 2022). Given that it's only the second quarter of 2026, this suggests the current correction may not yet be over. The current correction is 245 days old, shorter than previous cycles. Other analysts like Benjamin Cowen, Ali Martinez, and CryptoQuant also align on a late 2026 bottom (around October-December), citing cycle durations and technical indicators. BTC is currently trading near $63,000, down over 6% in 24 hours and at risk of breaking below $60,000 due to ongoing ETF outflows.

bitcoinist46 мин. назад

bitcoinist46 мин. назад

Should You Buy SpaceX Stock at $1.7 Trillion? Here's What the Market Is Worried About

SpaceX is preparing for a massive IPO aiming to raise around $75 billion at a valuation of approximately $1.75 trillion. While its achievements in reusable rockets and the profitable Starlink satellite internet service are clear, the market is concerned about the aggressive valuation. Key issues include: the current $1.75 trillion valuation, which is about 94 times 2025 revenue, seems to price in not just existing businesses but also unproven future ventures like AI infrastructure and orbital data centers. Financially, while Starlink is profitable, the AI division, bolstered by the acquisition of xAI, is incurring massive losses and consuming the majority of capital expenditures. This acquisition also introduced complex related-party financing arrangements and debt onto SpaceX's balance sheet. Furthermore, corporate governance poses a challenge. SpaceX's dual-class share structure ensures founder Elon Musk retains absolute control, limiting ordinary shareholders' influence over high-risk, long-term strategic decisions. The future success of ambitious projects like the Starship rocket—critical for lowering costs and enabling new services—remains a significant variable for the valuation. In summary, the market's apprehension (FUD) centers not on doubting SpaceX's past technological triumphs but on questioning how much premium public investors should pay for a future that combines proven profits with highly speculative and capital-intensive new ventures, all under a governance structure that offers limited shareholder oversight.

marsbit56 мин. назад

marsbit56 мин. назад

Breaking the DeFi Cascading Liquidation Curse: Vitalik Proposes a New Solution

Vitalik Buterin has proposed a new DeFi design to eliminate the automatic liquidation mechanism that causes market instability during sharp downturns. The current system, used by protocols like Aave, triggers forced sales when collateral value falls below a threshold, often exacerbating price drops and creating systemic selling pressure. Buterin's alternative model is based on splitting an asset like ETH into two synthetic option-like tokens, P and N, pegged to a price index. Their combined value always equals one ETH. Instead of sudden liquidation, a position's value gradually drifts from its target peg if the market moves. Users must proactively rebalance their holdings to maintain their desired exposure, transferring the management burden from the protocol to the user or automated tools. A key advantage is the reduced reliance on real-time oracles. Pricing decisions are deferred until contract expiry, allowing for more robust, fault-tolerant oracle designs. This removes a clear liquidation threshold that speculators can target for manipulation or MEV extraction. However, significant challenges remain. Frequent rebalancing could incur high slippage and transaction costs, necessitating new liquidity provider models. The design is better suited for hedging instruments than for stablecoins requiring a rigid 1:1 peg. While not an immediate replacement for existing systems, the proposal challenges the foundational assumption that instantaneous forced liquidation is an unavoidable necessity in DeFi, opening the door for fundamentally different risk management architectures.

marsbit1 ч. назад

marsbit1 ч. назад

The End of Single-Factor Cryptography

The article "The End of Single-Factor Crypto" posits a fundamental shift in the cryptocurrency ecosystem. It argues the era where crypto asset valuations were predominantly driven by, and correlated with, Bitcoin's price is ending. The space is bifurcating into two distinct economies: endogenous and exogenous. The endogenous economy represents traditional crypto, where token and project values are directly tied to crypto market prices. The emerging exogenous economy comprises projects and businesses that may utilize blockchain technology or tokens but derive their fundamental value from external, non-crypto factors like consumer demand, subscription revenue, or real-world utility. Examples include AI inference platforms like Venice, fintech lenders using blockchain for efficiency, and stablecoin/payment infrastructure companies acquired by giants like Mastercard and Stripe. This shift means investment analysis must change. For exogenous assets, evaluating traditional business fundamentals—such as revenue streams, unit economics, and competitive moats—becomes more critical than tracking Bitcoin charts. While endogenous assets like Bitcoin remain relevant, the growth of the exogenous category is driven by measurable demand independent of crypto price cycles, paving the way for a new, more diversified market phase. Consequently, crypto is evolving from a single-factor, reflexive asset class into a multifaceted ecosystem with varied drivers and investment theses.

marsbit1 ч. назад

marsbit1 ч. назад

Morning Post | Bitmine Plans to Raise $300 Million Through Preferred Stock Issuance; Polymarket Accuses Kalshi of Commercial Espionage

ChainCatcher's Daily Crypto Brief: Key developments from the past 24 hours include significant funding moves, regulatory actions, and market predictions. Bitmine announced a $300 million preferred stock fundraising. Polymarket accused rival prediction platform Kalshi of corporate espionage, citing numerous suspicious coincidences in product launches, a claim Kalshi strongly denied. The U.S. Department of Justice, in a joint "Disruption Week" anti-fraud operation with companies like Coinbase and Meta, froze over $3.8 million in cryptocurrency linked to scams. In infrastructure news, Macau completed its integration with the multi-central bank digital currency bridge, mBridge, aiming to build efficient cross-border payment channels. Cosmos Labs acquired the block explorer Mintscan. Market-wise, Geoffrey Kendrick, Standard Chartered's Head of Digital Assets Research, stated Bitcoin is nearing a bottom around $63,000, maintaining a year-end target of $100,000. He noted stability in U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF holdings. Ahead of SpaceX's anticipated IPO, internal insiders at Rocket Lab (RKLB) sold over $18.41 million in stock. In tokenization, Goldman Sachs partnered with Apex and Archax to launch a tokenized real estate fund. The meme token tracker GMGN reported the top trending tokens: on Ethereum, HEX, SHIB, LINK, PEPE, mUSD; on Solana, TROLL, swarms, WORLDCUP, neet, Buttcoin; and on Base, PEPE, toby, ODDS, ELSA, SKI.

链捕手1 ч. назад

链捕手1 ч. назад

Популярные статьи

Как купить S

Добро пожаловать на HTX.com! Мы сделали приобретение Sonic (S) простым и удобным. Следуйте нашему пошаговому руководству и отправляйтесь в свое крипто-путешествие.Шаг 1: Создайте аккаунт на HTXИспользуйте свой адрес электронной почты или номер телефона, чтобы зарегистрироваться и бесплатно создать аккаунт на HTX. Пройдите удобную регистрацию и откройте для себя весь функционал.Создать аккаунтШаг 2: Перейдите в Купить криптовалюту и выберите свой способ оплатыКредитная/Дебетовая Карта: Используйте свою карту Visa или Mastercard для мгновенной покупки Sonic (S).Баланс: Используйте средства с баланса вашего аккаунта HTX для простой торговли.Третьи Лица: Мы добавили популярные способы оплаты, такие как Google Pay и Apple Pay, для повышения удобства.P2P: Торгуйте напрямую с другими пользователями на HTX.Внебиржевая Торговля (OTC): Мы предлагаем индивидуальные услуги и конкурентоспособные обменные курсы для трейдеров.Шаг 3: Хранение Sonic (S)После приобретения вами Sonic (S) храните их в своем аккаунте на HTX. В качестве альтернативы вы можете отправить их куда-либо с помощью перевода в блокчейне или использовать для торговли с другими криптовалютами.Шаг 4: Торговля Sonic (S)С легкостью торгуйте Sonic (S) на спотовом рынке HTX. Просто зайдите в свой аккаунт, выберите торговую пару, совершайте сделки и следите за ними в режиме реального времени. Мы предлагаем удобный интерфейс как для начинающих, так и для опытных трейдеров.

1.4k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.01.15Обновлено 2026.06.02

Sonic: Обновления под руководством Андре Кронье – новая звезда Layer-1 на фоне спада рынка

Он решает проблемы масштабируемости, совместимости между блокчейнами и стимулов для разработчиков с помощью технологических инноваций.

2.3k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.04.09Обновлено 2025.04.09

HTX Learn: Пройдите обучение по "Sonic" и разделите 1000 USDT

HTX Learn — ваш проводник в мир перспективных проектов, и мы запускаем специальное мероприятие "Учитесь и Зарабатывайте", посвящённое этим проектам. Наше новое направление .

1.8k просмотров всегоОпубликовано 2025.04.10Обновлено 2025.04.10