"Legal" Ponzi Scheme? Uncovering Gemini Exchange and Its Founders' Circular Lending

Author|Protos Staff

Compiled| WuBlockchain

TL;DR: Key Points from Gemini's 10-K Report and Internal Lending Cycle

·Shuffling Funds Between Hands: Founders' WCF lent crypto assets to Gemini, which then collateralized them with third parties to obtain USD loans, forming an internal circular lending scheme.

·Cheap Acquisition of Control: During the IPO, founders' debt was converted into super-voting shares at a 20% discount. Retail investors bought in at high prices, while the founders secured 94.7% voting control.

<极简主义风格，只翻译核心内容，去除冗余解释>

·Sword of Damocles

Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss lent thousands of Bitcoin ($BTC) and Ethereum ($ETH) to their own crypto exchange Gemini through their private investment firm Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF). Gemini then used these crypto assets as collateral with On September 15, 2025, the exchange went public at $28 per share and converted $695.6 million of WCF debt into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount, giving the twins direct control of 94.7% of Gemini's voting power.

Attached X platform post:

This is all a circular Ponzi scheme:

Borrow BTC from related party WCF; collateralize that BTC with lenders to get USD loans (involving Galaxy, bond issuance, NYDIG).

Deloitte issued an unqualified audit opinion: no Key Audit Matters (KAM), and said nothing about related parties, liquidity, going concern...

How is any of this legal?

Here is the basic flow of funds. The twins' WCF lent BTC and ETH to Gemini under open-term agreements.

Gemini then used these borrowed crypto assets as collateral with third-party lenders. Galaxy Digital provided a $116.5 million loan at 11–12% interest with a 145–155% collateral ratio. NYDIG provided $75 million via a repurchase agreement at 8.5%.

Gemini used this USD capital for operations and regulatory requirements.

The exchange is now listed on Nasdaq under the ticker GEMI.

It also repaid $238.5 million under the Ripple warehouse credit facility, though $154 million in Ripple debt remained outstanding at year-end.

However, the twins' own debt was not repaid in cash.

A and B shares differ only in voting rights and distribution. Otherwise, they have identical par value, dividend rights, and B shares are convertible to A shares on a one-to-one basis.

Retail paid $28, Winklevoss paid only $22.40

This discount is the core of how this circular operation harms ordinary shareholders.

WCF lent crypto to Gemini. Then,Gemini collateralized these borrowed assets to secure more loans. Specifically, Galaxy and NYDIG lent USD to Gemini for its operations.

Then, Gemini issued equity to WCF at a discount during the same IPO where retail paid 20% more.

Further reading: Sources say Winklevoss twins pulled $280 million out before Genesis collapse

In 2025, Gemini paid WCF $24.2 million in lending fees.

Despite being public, the co-founders retain overwhelming voting control.

Additionally, per crypto researcher Emmett Gallic citing Arkham Intelligence data, WCF held about 8,757 BTC in Gemini Custody addresses.

Deloitte Issues Unqualified Audit Opinion

The twins could shake the foundations of this exchange they control with a simple written notice.

Gemini's secondary market price has crashed 88% from its IPO price. "Gemini Space Station" is its legal name,寓意火箭升空, but it's now ironic. It opened at $37.01 on its first IPO day.

It's now just $4.42 per share.

Gemini set its IPO price at $28 on September 11, 2025. It opened at $37.01 the next day, briefly hit a high of $45.89, then began its decline. After hitting a 52-week low of $3.91 on Monday, it closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026, down 88% from its opening price.

Market cap has collapsed from over $3.8 billion to about $520 million. Citigroup, Cantor, Truist, and Evercore have all downgraded the stock to "Sell".

{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"FAQPage","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"What is the core mechanism of the alleged 'circular operation' between Gemini and its founders' WCF?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF) loaned crypto assets to Gemini. Gemini then used these borrowed assets as collateral to secure dollar loans from third-party lenders like Galaxy Digital and NYDIG. This created an internal circular lending loop where funds moved between the founders' entity and their own exchange."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How did the Winklevoss twins consolidate control of Gemini during its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"During the IPO, $695.6 million of debt owed to WCF was converted into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount to the $28 IPO price paid by retail investors ($22.40 per share). This gave the founders 94.7% of the voting power in the company."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What major financial liability does Gemini still owe to WCF, and what risk does it pose?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"As of December 31, 2025, Gemini still owed WCF 4,619 BTC (valued at approximately $400 million at the time). This loan is repayable on demand, posing a significant liquidity risk to the exchange if the founders were to suddenly call it in."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How has Gemini's stock performance fared since its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Gemini's stock has plummeted 88% from its IPO price of $28 and its first-day opening price of $37.01. It hit a 52-week low of $3.91 and closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026. Its market capitalization crashed from over $3.8 billion to approximately $520 million."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What was the role of the auditing firm Deloitte in this situation, according to the article?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Deloitte issued an unqualified (clean) audit opinion for Gemini. The article questions this, noting the audit report did not highlight any Key Audit Matters (KAMs) or raise concerns about related-party transactions, liquidity, or the company's going concern status despite the significant risks outlined."}}]}

Related Reads

The Second Half of Macro Influencer Fu Peng's Career

Fu Peng, a prominent Chinese macroeconomist and former chief economist of Northeast Securities, has joined Hong Kong-based digital asset management firm Bitfire Group (formerly New Huo Group) as its chief economist. This move, announced in April 2026, triggered an 11% surge in Bitfire's stock price. Fu, known for his accessible macroeconomic commentary and large social media following, will focus on integrating digital assets into global asset allocation frameworks, particularly combining FICC (fixed income, currencies, and commodities) with cryptocurrencies for institutional clients. His career includes roles at Lehman Brothers and Solomon International, with significant influence gained through public communication. However, in late 2024, Fu faced temporary social media bans after a controversial private speech at HSBC on China's economic challenges, though he denied regulatory sanctions. He later left Northeast Securities citing health reasons. Bitfire, a licensed virtual asset manager serving high-net-worth clients, seeks to build trust and attract traditional capital through Fu’s expertise and credibility. The partnership represents a strategic shift for both: Fu enters the crypto sector after a traditional finance peak, while Bitfire aims to leverage his macro framework for institutional adoption. Outcomes remain uncertain regarding capital inflows and compatibility within corporate structure.

marsbit50m ago

marsbit50m ago

Stablecoins Don’t Meet Core Requirements Of Money, BIS Says

The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) General Manager, Pablo Hernández de Cos, stated that existing stablecoins fail to meet the core requirements of money, specifically "singleness" and "interoperability." Singleness refers to the need for different forms of money to be interchangeable at par value, which is ensured by central banks in traditional finance but not in decentralized stablecoins. Interoperability means seamless cross-platform transactions, which stablecoins currently lack due to fragmentation across multiple blockchains. These shortcomings limit stablecoins' network effects and widespread acceptance, keeping them a "niche" payment instrument. However, de Cos acknowledged their potential to improve cross-border payments, though he also warned of risks to financial stability and monetary policy. Despite a bearish crypto market, the stablecoin market cap has reached a new all-time high of over $320 billion.

bitcoinist52m ago

bitcoinist52m ago

What Does the Outcome of the Midterm Elections Mean for Trump and Crypto?

The article analyzes the potential impact of the upcoming US midterm elections on Trump and cryptocurrency policy. Historically, the president's party loses congressional seats in 90% of midterms since 1946, making a Republican loss in the House highly probable. Current predictions suggest Democrats may take the House while Republicans retain the Senate, resulting in a divided government. Despite potential losses, Trump could still advance crypto-friendly policies through executive orders, agency appointments (if the Senate is held), budget reconciliation, and veto power. However, major structural bills like the CLARITY Act or a comprehensive stablecoin law would likely stall without a Republican majority in both chambers. The crypto industry has invested heavily ($288 million) in the elections to push for favorable legislation before the midterm window closes in mid-2026. While Trump remains the most crypto-friendly US president to date, advancing key reforms may be delayed until after 2028 if the legislative window is missed. The overall pro-crypto shift in US politics is seen as irreversible, even if progress slows temporarily.

marsbit1h ago

marsbit1h ago

Cardano Leadership Structure Comes Under Scrutiny, Clouding Its Future – See Why

Cardano is recognized as one of the most decentralized blockchains, yet recent criticism highlights its lack of clear leadership. Analyst Cardano Yoda argues that despite the introduction of on-chain governance—which involves DReps (governance decision-makers) and Pentad (leadership and execution)—the network remains centralized in practice. While DReps control treasury spending, they lack coordination and strategic direction, relying instead on founding entities like IOG, the Cardano Foundation, and EMURGO. This creates fragmented leadership and accountability issues. Yoda suggests that DReps should evolve into a more coordinated body, possibly through a board or DAOs, to define strategy and improve governance effectiveness. Enhanced cooperation between DReps, founding entities, and Intersect is essential for Cardano’s future leadership clarity and operational unity.

bitcoinist3h ago

bitcoinist3h ago

Bitcoin Must Do This To Continue The Rally, Or It Will Be Over

A crypto analyst known as "Swarmik" has identified 17 key price levels where Bitcoin (BTC) could find support if selling pressure increases. The analysis suggests that BTC's overall outlook remains bullish, and any successful bounce from these levels could drive it back to all-time highs or beyond. The first critical support is at $70,931, followed by levels such as $68,931 (an "Imbalance Zone"), $66,638 (a "Reversal Line"), and $64,491 (a "Psychological Level"). Further down, Fibonacci retracements and other technical zones like "Fair Value Gap" and "Order Block" are highlighted. If the decline continues, lower supports include $51,612 ("Demand Zone") and $49,466 ("Supply Zone"). The analyst warns that a drop below $34,732 would invalidate the bullish structure, potentially ending the rally.

bitcoinist5h ago

bitcoinist5h ago

Hot Articles

In-Depth Research Report on Account Abstraction (AA): Generational Leap in Ethereum’s Account System & Landscape Reshaping in the Next Five Years

As a major evolution of Ethereum’s account system, AA is designed to address the fundamental security and experience bottlenecks of the “private key equals account” model in the EOA era.

3.3k Total ViewsPublished 2025.12.18Updated 2025.12.18

Hot Tokens Learning Week 7: Privacy Coins Rally in Rotation, with RIVER Standing Out as 2026’s Surprise Performer

The privacy + payments narrative has been the primary catalyst driving rotation and substantial price gains in privacy coins such as DASH and XMR.

16.3k Total ViewsPublished 2026.01.20Updated 2026.01.20

Hot Tokens Learning Week 8: ADA's Ouroboros Leios Mainnet Expected to Launch in 2026

ADA's Ouroboros Leios mainnet is expected to launch in 2026, and the hard fork to Protocol Version 11 is planned for Q1 2026.

40.0k Total ViewsPublished 2026.02.10Updated 2026.02.12