"Legal" Ponzi Scheme? Uncovering Gemini Exchange and Its Founders' Circular Lending

Author|Protos Staff

Compiled| WuBlockchain

TL;DR: Key Points from Gemini's 10-K Report and Internal Lending Cycle

·Shuffling Funds Between Hands: Founders' WCF lent crypto assets to Gemini, which then collateralized them with third parties to obtain USD loans, forming an internal circular lending scheme.

·Cheap Acquisition of Control: During the IPO, founders' debt was converted into super-voting shares at a 20% discount. Retail investors bought in at high prices, while the founders secured 94.7% voting control.

<极简主义风格，只翻译核心内容，去除冗余解释>

·Sword of Damocles

Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss lent thousands of Bitcoin ($BTC) and Ethereum ($ETH) to their own crypto exchange Gemini through their private investment firm Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF). Gemini then used these crypto assets as collateral with On September 15, 2025, the exchange went public at $28 per share and converted $695.6 million of WCF debt into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount, giving the twins direct control of 94.7% of Gemini's voting power.

Attached X platform post:

This is all a circular Ponzi scheme:

Borrow BTC from related party WCF; collateralize that BTC with lenders to get USD loans (involving Galaxy, bond issuance, NYDIG).

Deloitte issued an unqualified audit opinion: no Key Audit Matters (KAM), and said nothing about related parties, liquidity, going concern...

How is any of this legal?

Here is the basic flow of funds. The twins' WCF lent BTC and ETH to Gemini under open-term agreements.

Gemini then used these borrowed crypto assets as collateral with third-party lenders. Galaxy Digital provided a $116.5 million loan at 11–12% interest with a 145–155% collateral ratio. NYDIG provided $75 million via a repurchase agreement at 8.5%.

Gemini used this USD capital for operations and regulatory requirements.

The exchange is now listed on Nasdaq under the ticker GEMI.

It also repaid $238.5 million under the Ripple warehouse credit facility, though $154 million in Ripple debt remained outstanding at year-end.

However, the twins' own debt was not repaid in cash.

A and B shares differ only in voting rights and distribution. Otherwise, they have identical par value, dividend rights, and B shares are convertible to A shares on a one-to-one basis.

Retail paid $28, Winklevoss paid only $22.40

This discount is the core of how this circular operation harms ordinary shareholders.

WCF lent crypto to Gemini. Then,Gemini collateralized these borrowed assets to secure more loans. Specifically, Galaxy and NYDIG lent USD to Gemini for its operations.

Then, Gemini issued equity to WCF at a discount during the same IPO where retail paid 20% more.

Further reading: Sources say Winklevoss twins pulled $280 million out before Genesis collapse

In 2025, Gemini paid WCF $24.2 million in lending fees.

Despite being public, the co-founders retain overwhelming voting control.

Additionally, per crypto researcher Emmett Gallic citing Arkham Intelligence data, WCF held about 8,757 BTC in Gemini Custody addresses.

Deloitte Issues Unqualified Audit Opinion

The twins could shake the foundations of this exchange they control with a simple written notice.

Gemini's secondary market price has crashed 88% from its IPO price. "Gemini Space Station" is its legal name,寓意火箭升空, but it's now ironic. It opened at $37.01 on its first IPO day.

It's now just $4.42 per share.

Gemini set its IPO price at $28 on September 11, 2025. It opened at $37.01 the next day, briefly hit a high of $45.89, then began its decline. After hitting a 52-week low of $3.91 on Monday, it closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026, down 88% from its opening price.

Market cap has collapsed from over $3.8 billion to about $520 million. Citigroup, Cantor, Truist, and Evercore have all downgraded the stock to "Sell".

{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"FAQPage","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"What is the core mechanism of the alleged 'circular operation' between Gemini and its founders' WCF?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Winklevoss Capital Fund (WCF) loaned crypto assets to Gemini. Gemini then used these borrowed assets as collateral to secure dollar loans from third-party lenders like Galaxy Digital and NYDIG. This created an internal circular lending loop where funds moved between the founders' entity and their own exchange."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How did the Winklevoss twins consolidate control of Gemini during its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"During the IPO, $695.6 million of debt owed to WCF was converted into super-voting Class B shares at a 20% discount to the $28 IPO price paid by retail investors ($22.40 per share). This gave the founders 94.7% of the voting power in the company."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What major financial liability does Gemini still owe to WCF, and what risk does it pose?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"As of December 31, 2025, Gemini still owed WCF 4,619 BTC (valued at approximately $400 million at the time). This loan is repayable on demand, posing a significant liquidity risk to the exchange if the founders were to suddenly call it in."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How has Gemini's stock performance fared since its IPO?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Gemini's stock has plummeted 88% from its IPO price of $28 and its first-day opening price of $37.01. It hit a 52-week low of $3.91 and closed at $4.42 on March 31, 2026. Its market capitalization crashed from over $3.8 billion to approximately $520 million."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What was the role of the auditing firm Deloitte in this situation, according to the article?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"Deloitte issued an unqualified (clean) audit opinion for Gemini. The article questions this, noting the audit report did not highlight any Key Audit Matters (KAMs) or raise concerns about related-party transactions, liquidity, or the company's going concern status despite the significant risks outlined."}}]}

Related Reads

Bitcoin Falls Sharply Behind Micron Technology As Investors Favor Semiconductor Exposure

Bitcoin is struggling to break the $63,000 level, having dropped sharply from its all-time high. It is now significantly underperforming compared to semiconductor stocks, particularly Micron Technology. Market analysis by Joao Wedson reveals Bitcoin has fallen over 95% against Micron, signaling a major investor rotation towards AI and semiconductor infrastructure assets. While this divergence could profoundly impact crypto markets, Wedson suggests cryptocurrency may eventually become a contrarian play. Meanwhile, Bitcoin's price decline is linked to large stakeholders ("whales") selling over 24,600 BTC last week, indicating market caution. Conversely, small-scale traders increased their holdings, potentially signaling a future buy opportunity.

bitcoinist2m ago

bitcoinist2m ago

Anthropic Cries Wolf: Is the AGI Threat Real, or Just an IPO Story?

Anthropic has published an article titled "When AI builds itself," discussing the emerging concept of "recursive self-improvement," where AI begins to actively participate in designing, training, testing, and optimizing its own subsequent versions. The company presents internal data showing that by May 2026, over 80% of code merged into its codebase was written by Claude, its AI model. Claude's capabilities have expanded to handling complex, open-ended engineering tasks, achieving a 76% success rate in such areas, and even contributing to research processes, such as optimizing code performance and conducting AI safety experiments. Anthropic outlines an evolution from human-driven development to AI-assisted workflows, culminating in the current stage where AI agents can autonomously write, run, and delegate code. The company cautions that the path toward a "closed loop," where AI continuously improves itself, is becoming visible. It calls for coordinated global mechanisms to potentially slow or pause frontier AI development to allow safety research and societal structures to catch up. However, the timing of this warning coincides with Anthropic's preparations for an IPO, framing the narrative not just as a safety concern but also as a demonstration of Claude's advanced capabilities and its integral role in accelerating Anthropic's own R&D—creating a potential "flywheel" effect for competitive advantage. This contrasts with OpenAI's recent, more policy-oriented discussion of the same risks, highlighting the competitive dynamics in the AI industry as companies position themselves in both the technological and regulatory landscape.

marsbit57m ago

marsbit57m ago

Coinbase Targets Crypto Crime, Freezing $3M Linked To Scam Operations

Coinbase froze over $3 million in cryptocurrency linked to Southeast Asian scam networks as part of a multi-agency "Disruption Week" campaign. The operation, coordinated by the DOJ's Scam Center Strike Force, involved companies like Meta, Microsoft, and Starlink, and disrupted over 1.4 million scam accounts. The DOJ noted that investment fraud, including "pig butchering" scams, is among the fastest-growing threats, with crypto-related scams causing billions in losses. This action follows other recent crackdowns targeting scam infrastructure globally. Coinbase highlighted that blockchain provides a permanent transaction record, aiding investigations and countering the narrative that crypto is solely a tool for crime.

bitcoinist1h ago

bitcoinist1h ago

BIT Research: ETF Purchases Have Slowed, Strategy (MicroStrategy) Has Slowed, What Else Can Drive Bitcoin's Rise?

Market Refocus on Inflation and Rate Expectations Weighs on Bitcoin Currently, the market is in a phase of macro-repricing dominated by inflation and interest rate expectations. Bitcoin, which previously benefited from easy liquidity and low inflation, is seeing its core bullish drivers weaken. These drivers were market expectations for interest rate cuts and strong inflows from Bitcoin ETFs and institutions like MicroStrategy (referred to as "Strategy" in the text). The logic has shifted. Recent high inflation data (e.g., CPI hitting 3.8% in a May 2026 report) has caused the market to sharply reduce its rate cut expectations for 2025 and even price in potential hikes. This is a key constraint for Bitcoin, as it lacks cash flows and is highly sensitive to rate expectations. Concurrently, institutional capital flows have slowed significantly. Following the hot CPI data, Bitcoin ETFs saw accelerated outflows, with around $4.3 billion leaving over a period. MicroStrategy's ability to keep adding substantial Bitcoin to its balance sheet is also diminishing. Together, ETF and MicroStrategy holdings total roughly $110 billion, but their momentum as growth engines is cooling. In summary, Bitcoin's current pressure stems not from its own fundamentals but from a changing macro environment. As long as inflation stays elevated, Bitcoin is likely to remain in a consolidating phase. However, historically, inflation eventually peaks. Once it recedes and rate cut expectations rebuild, institutional capital could return, potentially fueling a new and more robust recovery phase for Bitcoin.

marsbit1h ago

marsbit1h ago

Earning 1000 Trillion in Half a Year, 'Pocketing' 20 Million per Capita: This Round of Wealth Creation in the Korean Stock Market is Unprecedented in Scale

The South Korean stock market is experiencing an unprecedented wealth surge in 2026, with household equity and fund asset values soaring by over 1,000 trillion KRW (~$730bn) year-to-date. This translates to an average per capita wealth increase of roughly 20 million KRW, fueled by a historic 109% rally in the KOSPI index. The boom is driven by three converging forces: an AI-driven semiconductor supercycle boosting giants like Samsung and SK Hynix; the government's "Value-Up" market reforms addressing long-standing corporate governance issues; and aggressive real estate regulations that have locked capital within financial markets, preventing profits from flowing back into property. This has triggered a wealth effect, boosting high-end consumption significantly. However, the gains are highly concentrated. The two semiconductor behemoths account for over half the index's value, but retail investors own relatively low stakes in them, systematically missing the biggest rallies. Wealth and consumption benefits are skewed towards luxury goods and imported cars, bypassing mainstream retail. Further risks stem from excessive leverage, with high trading volume in leveraged ETFs, and a market sentiment heavily reliant on the AI sector's fortunes and speculative rumors. While this cycle marks a potential shift from real estate to equities as a primary wealth generator for Koreans, its sustainability, amid structural imbalances and leverage, remains a critical test.

marsbit1h ago

marsbit1h ago

Hot Articles

Hot Tokens Learning Week 7: Privacy Coins Rally in Rotation, with RIVER Standing Out as 2026’s Surprise Performer

The privacy + payments narrative has been the primary catalyst driving rotation and substantial price gains in privacy coins such as DASH and XMR.

16.6k Total ViewsPublished 2026.01.20Updated 2026.01.20

Hot Tokens Learning Week 8: ADA's Ouroboros Leios Mainnet Expected to Launch in 2026

ADA's Ouroboros Leios mainnet is expected to launch in 2026, and the hard fork to Protocol Version 11 is planned for Q1 2026.

40.5k Total ViewsPublished 2026.02.10Updated 2026.02.12

Hot Tokens Learning Week 14: Glamsterdam Set to Be Ethereum's Most Closely Watched Upgrade in 2026

Ordinals/Runes continue to drive block fee revenue and developer activity, and are seen as the starting point for Bitcoin's "native asset issuance".

26.7k Total ViewsPublished 2026.04.29Updated 2026.04.29