Badai Kontroversi Melanda Forum Governance Aave Terkait Biaya CoW Swap

cointelegraphPublished on 2025-12-14Last updated on 2025-12-14

Abstract

Perselisihan memanas antara Aave DAO dan Aave Labs terkait pembagian biaya dari integrasi dengan CoW Swap. Anggota DAO anonim EzR3aL mengungkapkan bahwa biaya swap aset kripto senilai sekitar $200.000 per minggu (mencapai $10 juta/tahun) dialirkan ke alamat pribadi Aave Labs, bukan ke kas DAO. Aave Labs membantah dengan menyatakan bahwa pengembangan antarmuka aplikasi adalah wewenang mereka, sedangkan perubahan protokol tetap menjadi kewenangan DAO. Tanggapan ini justru memicu kritik lebih lanjut dari anggota komunitas yang menegaskan bahwa DAO telah mendanai pengembangan teknologi adapter awal sehingga berhak atas pendapatan tersebut. Founder Aave-Chan Initiative Marc Zeller menyebut tindakan Aave Labs "sangat mengkhawatirkan" dan tidak dapat diterima. Konflik ini menyoroti kompleksitas tata kelola organisasi otonom terdesentralisasi (DAO).

Perselisihan antara organisasi otonom terdesentralisasi (DAO) Aave, yang mengatur protokol keuangan terdesentralisasi (DeFi) Aave, dan Aave Labs, perusahaan pengembangan utama produk Aave, mengenai biaya dari integrasi yang baru diumumkan dengan agregator pertukaran terdesentralisasi CoW Swap, terus memanas.

Masalah ini diangkat oleh anggota Aave DAO yang menggunakan nama samaran EzR3aL, yang mengatakan bahwa biaya yang dihasilkan dari pertukaran aset kripto menggunakan CoW Swap dialirkan ke alamat onchain yang berbeda, bukan ke kas organisasi otonom terdesentralisasi Aave.

Sebaliknya, biaya tersebut dialirkan ke alamat pribadi yang dikendalikan oleh Aave Labs. EzR3aL mengajukan beberapa pertanyaan, termasuk mengapa DAO tidak dikonsultasikan sebelum biaya dialihkan, dan berargumen bahwa biaya tersebut seharusnya menjadi milik DAO.

Postingan forum governance yang memicu perdebatan. Sumber: Aave Governance

“Entitas lain, bukan Aave DAO, menerima setidaknya $200.000 per minggu dalam bentuk Ether,” kata EzR3aL, menambahkan bahwa ini setara dengan $10 juta pendapatan potensial tahunan yang tidak diberikan kepada DAO.

Aave Labs menanggapi bahwa komponen front-end untuk situs web dan antarmuka aplikasi selalu menjadi wewenang sah Aave Labs.

Terkait: Aave meluncurkan aplikasi tabungan ritel dengan APY hingga 9% untuk bersaing dengan bank

Perubahan tingkat protokol, seperti kebijakan suku bunga dan persetujuan perubahan kode kontrak pintar, selalu tunduk pada pengawasan DAO, kata Aave Labs.

Aave Labs juga mengklaim bahwa merekalah entitas yang mendanai pengembangan “adapter,” baris kode yang memungkinkan pertukaran dan integrasi lainnya bekerja.

Total nilai yang terkunci dalam protokol Aave dan gambaran keuangan platform DeFi. Sumber: DeFiLlama

Namun, tanggapan tersebut tidak banyak meredakan ketegangan, dengan beberapa anggota DAO mengatakan bahwa Aave DAO-lah yang mendanai pengembangan teknologi adapter asli; oleh karena itu, pendapatan dari integrasi seharusnya mengalir kembali ke DAO.

Marc Zeller, pendiri Aave-Chan Initiative, sebuah platform delegasi yang melayani komunitas governance Aave, mengatakan keputusan untuk mengalirkan biaya secara eksklusif ke Aave Labs “sangat mengkhawatirkan.”

“Aave Labs, dalam mengejar monetisasi mereka sendiri, mengalihkan volume pengguna Aave ke pesaing. Ini tidak dapat diterima,” kata Zeller.

Cointelegraph menghubungi Aave Labs tetapi tidak mendapatkan tanggapan segera pada waktu publikasi.

Konflik ini menyoroti kompleksitas menjalankan DAO, yang merupakan bentuk tata kelola dan organisasi baru yang memiliki keunggulan dibandingkan struktur bisnis tradisional tetapi juga membawa tantangan uniknya sendiri.

Majalah: Satu hal yang dimiliki bersama oleh 6 hub kripto global ini...

Trending Cryptos

Related Questions

QApa yang memicu perselisihan di forum governance Aave?

APerselisihan dipicu oleh klaim dari anggota pseudonim Aave DAO, EzR3aL, bahwa biaya yang dihasilkan dari integrasi dengan CoW Swap dialirkan ke alamat pribadi yang dikendalikan Aave Labs, bukan ke treasury DAO.

QBerapa perkiraan pendapatan tahunan yang diklaim hilang dari Aave DAO?

AEzR3aL memperkirakan potensi pendapatan tahunan sebesar $10 juta (dalam Ether) tidak dialirkan ke treasury Aave DAO.

QBagaimana Aave Labs membenarkan penerimaan biaya tersebut?

AAave Labs menyatakan bahwa komponen front-end website dan antarmuka aplikasi selalu menjadi hak mereka, dan mereka yang mendanai pengembangan 'adapter' untuk integrasi tersebut.

QSiapa Marc Zeller dan apa tanggapannya mengenai insiden ini?

AMarc Zeller adalah pendiri Aave-Chan Initiative. Ia menyatakan keputusan mengalirkan biaya hanya ke Aave Labs 'sangat mengkhawatirkan' dan tidak dapat diterima karena mengalihkan volume pengguna ke kompetitor.

QApa yang ditunjukkan oleh konflik ini tentang tantangan menjalankan DAO?

AKonflik ini menyoroti kompleksitas tata kelola DAO, yang meski memiliki keunggulan dibanding struktur bisnis tradisional, juga membawa tantangan unik dalam hal transparansi dan alokasi pendapatan.

Related Reads

My Coding Betting Dashboard is Profiting, but Polymarket is Truly Not a Good Place for 'Arbitrage'

The author built a custom monitoring dashboard for Polymarket, a prediction market platform, and tested it with $1,600, achieving over 30% returns. However, the core argument is that Polymarket is not a good venue for traditional arbitrage. The dashboard has two main sections: a "Portfolio Dashboard" for tracking active positions with key metrics like total capital, P&L, and a risk-control module using a tier system (T1, T2, T3), and an "Opportunity Watchlist" for monitoring markets. The article details a critical structural trap in binary markets: a bet with a high perceived probability of success still carries a 100% loss risk if wrong. The author's T1/T2/T3 system is designed to manage this by limiting position sizes based on conviction and time horizon, emphasizing that high confidence should not equal high concentration. A key insight is the danger of "pseudo-diversification"—betting on different markets driven by the same underlying variable. The author concludes that Polymarket offers few true low-risk, arbitrage opportunities. It is instead a high-risk environment where wins can create a false sense of mastery, leading to large losses. The platform is better viewed as a training ground for honing judgment through disciplined, framework-driven betting rather than a reliable income source. The tools help transform intuition into structured, rule-based decisions to mitigate the risk of catastrophic errors.

marsbit17m ago

My Coding Betting Dashboard is Profiting, but Polymarket is Truly Not a Good Place for 'Arbitrage'

marsbit17m ago

WeChat AI Card Hands-On Guide: Has the AI Shopping Era Arrived?

**"WeChat AI Card" Practical Test Guide: Has the Era of AI Shopping Arrived?** WeChat has officially launched the "AI Exclusive Card," a feature integrated into its Workbuddy AI assistant. This card is designed to handle payments for AI-initiated purchases. Our hands-on test reveals it's not yet a tool for fully autonomous AI shopping, but rather a controlled payment layer for AI agents. The AI Card functions as an isolated sub-wallet within WeChat Pay. Users must bind the card and transfer funds into it from their main wallet. Crucially, every transaction requires explicit user confirmation via smartphone scan; AI cannot spend autonomously. Currently accessible through the Workbuddy agent, the card targets specific digital consumption scenarios: purchasing paid content (reports, data), calling paid APIs/tools, and subscribing to services. Its design prioritizes security and control by separating funds and mandating approval for each payment. We tested a real-world scenario: ordering bubble tea via Workbuddy using a "Meituan Life Assistant" skill. The process encountered multiple hurdles: high "skill" usage costs (exceeding daily free credits), and most importantly, while a payment was successfully initiated, the AI purchased an incorrect product (a mismatched group-buy coupon instead of the desired drink). This highlights the current limitation: the **AI Card only solves the payment step**. The broader challenge lies in the **AI agent's execution chain**—accurately understanding intent, navigating third-party platforms, selecting the right product, and ensuring proper fulfillment. The payment succeeded, but the purchase failed to meet the user's need. In conclusion, the WeChat AI Exclusive Card is a cautious, early-step experiment in AI commerce. It provides a secure, user-controlled payment method for agent interactions but is not yet capable of reliable, end-to-end complex purchases. For now, it's best used for low-value, low-risk digital services with careful user verification at each step. The vision of AI handling complete shopping tasks remains a work in progress.

marsbit2h ago

WeChat AI Card Hands-On Guide: Has the AI Shopping Era Arrived?

marsbit2h ago

Deconstructing Notion's Growth: From a Note-taking Tool to 100 Million Users—How Notion Built a Triple Growth Flywheel Through Product, Templates, and Community

Notion's growth from a niche note-taking tool to a platform with 100 million users is powered by three interconnected flywheels: Product-Led Growth (PLG), a Template Economy, and Community-Driven Growth. First, Notion's PLG strategy relies on a highly flexible, "plastic" product that users can adapt to countless personal and team workflows. Its freemium model lowers the barrier to entry, while features like page sharing and collaboration drive organic, usage-based viral growth as users naturally invite others. Second, the Template Economy solves the "blank page" problem. Templates, created by both Notion and its community, transform abstract product capabilities into concrete, copyable solutions for specific scenarios (e.g., project management, content calendars). This dramatically lowers activation costs for new users and fuels SEO-driven discovery. Third, a vibrant Community acts as a distributed growth engine. Users and official Ambassadors create tutorials, share use cases, and host local events. This community not only educates users but also fosters a sense of identity around pursuing "better ways of working," strengthening loyalty and enabling global, low-cost expansion. Together, these flywheels create a self-reinforcing ecosystem: a great product attracts users who create templates and community content, which in turn attracts more users and deepens engagement. This system allowed Notion to scale from individuals to teams and enterprises through a bottom-up adoption path. Looking ahead, AI integration promises to accelerate these flywheels further by making templates smarter and the platform a potential AI-native work operating system. Ultimately, Notion's defensible advantage is not just its features, but this deeply entrenched network of user assets, creators, and community trust.

marsbit2h ago

Deconstructing Notion's Growth: From a Note-taking Tool to 100 Million Users—How Notion Built a Triple Growth Flywheel Through Product, Templates, and Community

marsbit2h ago

$10 Billion, Qualcomm to Acquire Chip Legend Jim Keller's Company

Global mobile chip giant Qualcomm is in advanced talks to acquire AI chip startup Tenstorrent in a deal valued between $8-10 billion, according to media reports. This potential acquisition would be one of the largest in the AI chip sector in recent years. Tenstorrent, led by legendary chip architect Jim Keller, has gained prominence for its RISC-V architecture and AI accelerator designs. The move highlights Qualcomm's strategic push to diversify beyond its core smartphone chip business. As the smartphone market matures, Qualcomm is aggressively targeting growth in automotive, data center, and cloud AI. Acquiring Tenstorrent would allow Qualcomm to rapidly enter the high-end AI computing market, bypassing lengthy in-house development cycles. Tenstorrent's cost-effective system architecture, which avoids expensive HBM memory and relies on standard Ethernet for clustering, offers a potential alternative to Nvidia's costly solutions. Furthermore, Tenstorrent's high-performance RISC-V CPU technology and its focus on the automotive and edge computing segments align with Qualcomm's strategic goals, including its "Snapdragon Digital Chassis" platform. Despite the strategic rationale, the high valuation has sparked some investor caution. The successful integration of Tenstorrent's open-source culture and independent team into Qualcomm's organization, along with the commercialization of its technology, remains a key challenge.

marsbit3h ago

$10 Billion, Qualcomm to Acquire Chip Legend Jim Keller's Company

marsbit3h ago

Trading

Spot
Futures

Hot Articles

How to Buy AAVE

Welcome to HTX.com! We've made purchasing Aave Protocol (AAVE) simple and convenient. Follow our step-by-step guide to embark on your crypto journey.Step 1: Create Your HTX AccountUse your email or phone number to sign up for a free account on HTX. Experience a hassle-free registration journey and unlock all features.Get My AccountStep 2: Go to Buy Crypto and Choose Your Payment MethodCredit/Debit Card: Use your Visa or Mastercard to buy Aave Protocol (AAVE) instantly.Balance: Use funds from your HTX account balance to trade seamlessly.Third Parties: We've added popular payment methods such as Google Pay and Apple Pay to enhance convenience.P2P: Trade directly with other users on HTX.Over-the-Counter (OTC): We offer tailor-made services and competitive exchange rates for traders.Step 3: Store Your Aave Protocol (AAVE)After purchasing your Aave Protocol (AAVE), store it in your HTX account. Alternatively, you can send it elsewhere via blockchain transfer or use it to trade other cryptocurrencies.Step 4: Trade Aave Protocol (AAVE)Easily trade Aave Protocol (AAVE) on HTX's spot market. Simply access your account, select your trading pair, execute your trades, and monitor in real-time. We offer a user-friendly experience for both beginners and seasoned traders.

5.5k Total ViewsPublished 2024.03.29Updated 2026.06.02

How to Buy AAVE

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of AAVE (AAVE) are presented below.

活动图片