Vitalik Buterin Condemns Criminalization of Code, Speaks Out for Tornado Cash Developer

marsbitОпубликовано 2026-01-12Обновлено 2026-01-12

Введение

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has publicly defended Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm, who was convicted in August on charges of conspiracy to commit unlawful money transmission and faces up to five years in prison. Buterin argued that the case criminalizes software development itself rather than addressing direct financial harm, emphasizing the importance of privacy tools as essential defenses against systemic data exploitation. He disclosed personal use of Storm’s software for charitable and technical purposes, praising its reliability compared to commercial alternatives. Storm’s legal defense has received substantial support, with over $6.39 million raised in 2025, including donations from Buterin, the Ethereum Foundation, and other crypto entities. This case is part of a broader global crackdown on privacy-focused developers. Tornado Cash co-founder Alexey Pertsev was sentenced to 64 months in prison in the Netherlands, while Samourai Wallet founders received multi-year sentences in the U.S. for similar charges. Advocacy groups are pushing for legislative protections for software developers, amid high-level political attention, including a potential case review by former President Donald Trump.

Original Author: Brian Danga

Original Compilation: Block Unicorn

Summary

  • Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin issued an open letter on Friday in support of Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm. Storm was convicted in August on charges of conspiracy to commit unlawful money transmission and faces up to five years in prison.
  • Storm's defense fund has received support from backers including Vitalik and the Ethereum Foundation, totaling over $6.3 million (as of 2025). Meanwhile, global enforcement against privacy-focused crypto tools is intensifying.

Vitalik's Open Letter

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin issued an open letter on Friday in support of Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm. Storm was convicted in August on charges of conspiracy to commit unlawful money transmission and is currently awaiting sentencing in a U.S. court.

Storm was indicted by the U.S. Department of Justice in August 2023 and remains on bail, with the judge ruling he poses no flight risk, though he still faces up to five years in prison.

Vitalik positioned the core of this prosecution as targeting software development itself, rather than direct economic harm. Storm is a co-founder of Tornado Cash, a non-custodial cryptocurrency mixer that U.S. authorities say was used to launder over $1 billion in illicit funds. In August of this year, a jury found Storm guilty of unlawfully transferring funds but failed to reach a consensus on other money laundering and sanctions charges.

Vitalik positioned privacy tools like Tornado Cash as necessary defenses against systemic data exploitation, noting that he had used Roman's software to purchase technical tools and support human rights charities, with this data not being recorded in corporate or government databases.

"I have supported Roman Storm's work from the beginning because I firmly believe in the importance of privacy, and I am an active user of privacy tools, including those developed by Roman," Vitalik wrote. "Unlike some, who use these causes as a pretext for profit, developing software with flashy advertisements but fundamentally flawed underlying code, Roman's applications remain functional years after he stopped development—this alone, in my view, makes him more respectable than many so-called 'consumer tech' products in the world today."

As Privacy Tools Face Increasing Legal Pressure, Industry Support Is Growing

Vitalik's letter places Storm's case within a broader argument that data protection should be seen as fundamental infrastructure, not a niche political issue. He wrote that in recent decades, the ability to control personal information was a default state, describing modern privacy tools as attempts to preserve protections that existed before the emergence of widespread digital surveillance.

In the letter, Vitalik stated that these protections are neither novel nor extreme, describing them as safeguards historically applied to personal communication, physical movement, and financial activities.

Vitalik's support extends beyond testimony. In December 2024, he donated 50 Ethereum (ETH) to Storm's legal defense fund, worth approximately $170,000 at the time. The non-profit Ethereum Foundation donated $500,000 to the fund in June of last year and pledged to match $750,000 in community donations. In October 2025, the Ethereum Foundation and Keyring jointly launched a legal defense fund specifically for Tornado Cash developers.

The scope of support has extended beyond the Ethereum ecosystem. According to the fund's official website, in 2025 alone, Storm's defense fund raised over $6.39 million. Blockchain privacy researcher Federico Carrone stated that he donated $500,000 to Storm's defense fund, adding to the $50,000 previously pledged by his venture studio LambdaClass, further increasing the total. The Solana Policy Institute stated in August 2025 that it had donated $500,000 to support Storm and Tornado Cash co-founder Alexey Pertsev.

This wave of support comes as crackdowns on privacy tool developers intensify globally. Storm's co-founder Alexey Pertsev was sentenced to 64 months in prison by a Dutch court in 2024 for money laundering, related to $1.2 billion in transactions between July 2019 and August 2022.

In the U.S., the co-founders of Samourai Wallet were arrested in April 2024 on money laundering charges. Prosecutors alleged that the wallet's mixer processed over $2 billion in illicit funds between 2015 and 2024. Co-founder Keonne Rodriguez was sentenced to five years in prison in November 2025, while William Lonergan Hill was sentenced to four years.

Meanwhile, advocacy groups are pushing for legislative safeguards. In August 2025, over 110 cryptocurrency organizations jointly sent a letter to Senate committee leaders, stating that they could not support key market structure legislation without clear protections for software developers. This followed a statement from a senior Department of Justice official that "writing code" is not a crime.

As previously reported, U.S. President Donald Trump, when asked in an Oval Office meeting in December 2025 whether he would pardon Samourai Wallet's Keonne Rodriguez, indicated he might review such cases, saying, "I've heard about it, and I will look into it."

Связанные с этим вопросы

QWhat is the core argument that Vitalik Buterin makes in his public letter regarding the prosecution of Tornado Cash developer Roman Storm?

AVitalik Buterin argues that the prosecution targets the act of software development itself rather than any direct financial harm caused. He positions privacy tools like Tornado Cash as essential defenses against systemic exploitation of data and necessary for protecting fundamental rights.

QWhat specific legal outcome does Roman Storm face following his conviction?

ARoman Storm was convicted of conspiracy to commit unlawful money transmission in August and faces a maximum sentence of five years in prison. He is currently out on bail, with the judge determining he is not a flight risk.

QHow much financial support has been raised for Roman Storm's legal defense fund as of 2025, and which major organizations have contributed?

AAs of 2025, over $6.39 million has been raised for Roman Storm's legal defense fund. Major contributors include the Ethereum Foundation, which donated $500,000 and pledged to match $750,000 in community donations, Vitalik Buterin (50 ETH, ~$170,000 at the time), the Solana Policy Institute ($500,000), and Federico Carrone's LambdaClass ($50,000).

QBesides the case against Roman Storm in the US, what other legal actions have been taken against developers of privacy tools globally?

AGlobally, Tornado Cash co-founder Alexey Pertsev was sentenced to 64 months in prison by a Dutch court in 2024 for money laundering. In the US, the co-founders of Samourai Wallet were arrested in April 2024; Keonne Rodriguez was sentenced to five years in prison and William Lonergan Hill to four years in November 2025.

QWhat broader movement in the cryptocurrency industry is mentioned in relation to the legal pressures on software developers?

AThe article mentions an advocacy movement where over 110 crypto organizations sent a letter to Senate committee leaders in August 2025, stating they could not support key market structure legislation without clear protections for software developers. This followed a statement from a senior DOJ official that 'writing code' is not a crime.

Похожее

AI Agent Completely Transforms Web3 Gaming: From the Rugpull Bakery Bot Controversy to the New 2026 Agent Paradigm

This article explores how the AI Agent paradigm is fundamentally transforming Web3 gaming, moving from a disruptive force to a core, legitimized element. It begins with the controversy in the competitive baking game Rugpull Bakery, where automated scripts caused fairness issues. Instead of banning them, the developers integrated AI Agents into the official gameplay by providing technical documentation (skill.md, agent.json), marking a shift towards "Agentic Gaming." The piece outlines three primary implementation models for AI Agents in Web3 games by 2026: 1. **Autonomous Competitors & Economic Entities:** AI Agents act as independent players with unique strategies. Examples include TEN Protocol's poker agents, AI Arena's trainable NFT fighters, and Satoshi Strike Force's "Digital Athletes" trained on player data. The Somnia blockchain is highlighted as a dedicated "Agentic L1" infrastructure supporting this model at scale. 2. **Modular Infrastructure & Programmable Environments:** This model, exemplified by EVE Frontier, allows AI Agents to program game world logic itself. Using "Smart Assemblies" (e.g., Smart Turrets, Smart Gates), Agents can modify shared economic and physical rules on-chain, creating dynamic, player/AI-built worlds. The ERC-8183 standard further enables these automated entities to hire other AI services for complex tasks. 3. **Hybrid Companions & Dynamic Adaptation:** Here, AI serves as a collaborative partner. In Parallel Colony, highly autonomous AI Avatars work alongside human players who provide high-level guidance. Illuvium plans to use AI to make NPCs dynamic and responsive, creating personalized, emergent narratives for each player. The conclusion posits that Web3 gaming has reached a "post-human" inflection point. Blockchains' transparency and programmability, combined with new standards and infrastructure like Somnia, make integrating and governing AI Agents not just viable but essential. The future lies in a symbiotic digital order where players transition from manual laborers to commanders and partners of algorithmic intelligence.

marsbit4 мин. назад

AI Agent Completely Transforms Web3 Gaming: From the Rugpull Bakery Bot Controversy to the New 2026 Agent Paradigm

marsbit4 мин. назад

Saylor's Purchase of 1550 Bitcoin Is a Bad Trade

**Title: Saylor's Purchase of 1,550 Bitcoins Was a Bad Trade** The article critically analyzes Strategy's recent move of selling 32 bitcoins followed by a much larger purchase of 1,550 bitcoins. While appearing bullish, the author argues this trade is detrimental to MSTR shareholders. The core argument revolves around the concept of "breakeven modified Net Asset Value (mNAV)," a key metric for Strategy. To increase Bitcoin per share (BPS) for MSTR holders, Strategy must issue new shares at a premium high enough that the funds raised can buy more bitcoin than the bitcoin backing each existing share. Currently, this breakeven mNAV is estimated at 1.30. The recent trade failed on two counts: 1. The shares for the $181 million raise were issued at an mNAV *below* the 1.30 breakeven point. Selling "cheap" shares to buy bitcoin actually *reduces* BPS. 2. Only $101.3 million of the raised funds were used to buy bitcoin; the rest went to boost the company's dollar reserves. The breakeven mNAV calculation assumes *100%* of proceeds are used for bitcoin purchases. Diverting funds, even if mNAV were high, dilutes BPS. The result is an estimated 0.19% decrease in Bitcoin per share for MSTR holders. In exchange, Strategy merely extended its operational runway for its dollar reserves from ~6.3 months to 7 months. The author interprets this as Strategy prioritizing the survival and development of its STRC business over its stated core goal of increasing MSTR's BPS. This constitutes a gamble: if sacrificing MSTR value leads to improved market sentiment and a recovery in STRC's price (and thus mNAV), the whole system could work. If not, Strategy may be forced into a cycle of further diluting MSTR to stay afloat, potentially leading to deferred STRC dividends or corporate decline. The article concludes with a hope for price recovery for Bitcoin, MSTR, and STRC.

Foresight News15 мин. назад

Saylor's Purchase of 1550 Bitcoin Is a Bad Trade

Foresight News15 мин. назад

The AI Bear Market Lasting Two Days Is Over; Why Did Funds Buy Back Storage Stocks First?

After a severe two-day selloff in early June that erased over $1 trillion from U.S. chip stock market value, capital is flowing back first to the memory sector. The correction was not driven by a collapse in AI demand but rather a market reassessment of high expectations. Stocks like Broadcom faced selling pressure despite strong AI revenue guidance, signaling a shift in focus from who has an "AI story" to who can most rapidly translate AI demand into verifiable profits and earnings per share (EPS). Memory companies, such as Micron and SK Hynix, are leading the recovery because their EPS growth is more immediately verifiable. The AI server boom directly increases demand for high-bandwidth memory (HBM) and high-capacity server DRAM, tightening supply and driving up contract prices for conventional DRAM and NAND Flash. This price increase, coupled with a shift to higher-margin products, flows directly into near-term revenue and profitability, as evidenced in recent earnings reports. In contrast, other AI semiconductor segments like GPUs, ASICs, and optical modules, while central to the long-term AI infrastructure story, face longer and less certain paths to EPS validation. Their growth depends more on future product cycles, customer adoption timelines, and capital expenditure plans. The rebound in memory stocks highlights a market preference for assets with shorter, more transparent EPS conversion cycles following the recent de-risking phase. However, this does not negate the potential of other AI hardware segments should they provide clearer near-term order visibility. The episode has raised the validation bar for all AI-related investments.

marsbit15 мин. назад

The AI Bear Market Lasting Two Days Is Over; Why Did Funds Buy Back Storage Stocks First?

marsbit15 мин. назад

Торговля

Спот
Фьючерсы
活动图片