Sell Bitcoin for gold? Not so fast, one analyst says

cointelegraphPublished on 2025-12-20Last updated on 2025-12-20

Abstract

Bitcoin advocate Matthew Kratter argues that Bitcoin (BTC) is a superior long-term store of value compared to gold, advising holders not to sell BTC for gold despite the latter's recent price surge. He highlights BTC’s advantages in scarcity, portability, verifiability, and divisibility, while criticizing gold’s steady annual supply growth of 1-2%, which leads to inflation over time. Kratter also points out gold’s practical limitations: high transport and insurance costs, difficulty in moving large quantities, and incompatibility with digital transactions. Tokenized gold products introduce counterparty risks such as over-issuance, refusal of redemption, or government confiscation. Despite ongoing debate between gold and Bitcoin proponents, Kratter asserts that gold cannot serve as a monetary base in a digital world.

The price of Bitcoin (BTC) will outperform gold in the long run, and BTC holders should not sell their coins to pour into gold during its meteoric run to prices above $4,000 per ounce, according to Bitcoin advocate, educator and market analyst Matthew Kratter.

BTC is a better store of value based on scarcity, portability, verifiability, divisibility, and other characteristics of money, Kratter said. He added:

“Gold supplies have increased somewhere between 1-2% annually for decades, if not for centuries. Now, this may not seem like a lot, but it leads inevitably to gold supplies doubling every 47 years.”
The price action of gold, shown as traditional price candles, and the price action of BTC in orange show a significant divergence in 2025. Source: TradingView

The steadily increasing supply of gold can be exacerbated by sudden discoveries of large, untapped gold deposits, which exist within the earth’s crust and in space, he said.

The influx of new gold into Europe from the Americas during the 16th century destroyed the Spanish and Portuguese empires due to the inflation from massive quantities of gold hitting the market suddenly, Kratter added.

Market analysts continue to debate whether gold or BTC is a better store of value and medium of exchange, with Bitcoiners arguing that BTC is a natural step in the evolution of money and gold bugs arguing that BTC is still too new and volatile to be a store of value.

Related: Peter Schiff fails to authenticate gold bar during onstage test with CZ

Gold suffers from ancient problems and cannot be the monetary base in a digital world

“It's very expensive to ship and ensure large amounts of gold, so it is a very poor way of settling trade imbalances,” Kratter said.

Moving even small quantities of gold through an airport or other “heavily surveilled” environments is a difficult task, and moving meaningful quantities of gold is “almost impossible,” according to Kratter.

Gold’s physical properties make it particularly unfit for online finance and sending value through the digital world, he added.

Spot Bitcoin vs physical gold characteristics. Source: Cointelegraph

Gold cannot be sent over the internet, and tokenized gold products, physical gold held by a financial custodian that is represented on a blockchain, introduce counterparty risk, Kratter said.

These risks include the issuer minting more gold tokens than physical gold in reserve, refusing to redeem the digital tokens for physical gold, or potential government confiscation of physical reserves, he said.

Magazine: Quantum attacking Bitcoin would be a waste of time: Kevin O’Leary

Related Questions

QAccording to Matthew Kratter, why should Bitcoin holders not sell their coins for gold despite gold's recent price surge?

ABecause Bitcoin will outperform gold in the long run and is a better store of value based on scarcity, portability, verifiability, divisibility, and other monetary characteristics.

QWhat historical example does Kratter use to illustrate the risk of a sudden increase in gold supply?

AHe cites the influx of new gold from the Americas into Europe during the 16th century, which destroyed the Spanish and Portuguese empires due to the inflation caused by massive quantities of gold suddenly hitting the market.

QWhat are the main physical limitations of gold that make it unsuitable for modern trade, as mentioned by the analyst?

AIt is very expensive to ship and insure large amounts of gold, making it a poor way to settle trade imbalances. Moving even small quantities through heavily surveilled areas like airports is difficult, and moving meaningful quantities is almost impossible.

QWhat problem does tokenized gold introduce, according to the article?

ATokenized gold introduces counterparty risk, which includes the issuer minting more tokens than the physical gold in reserve, refusing to redeem tokens for physical gold, or potential government confiscation of the physical reserves.

QWhat key difference in supply growth between Bitcoin and gold does Kratter highlight?

AGold supplies have increased by 1-2% annually for decades or centuries, leading to its supply doubling every 47 years, whereas Bitcoin has a fixed and predictable supply schedule.

Related Reads

Warsh Hearing Concludes: What Are the Notable Signals for the Crypto Industry?

The Senate Banking Committee held a confirmation hearing for Judy Shelton, a Federal Reserve nominee, who faced intense questioning regarding her ability to maintain the central bank's independence amid pressure from President Trump to lower interest rates. Shelton denied any pre-arranged commitments on rate cuts and emphasized her independence, though Democrats remained skeptical, citing contradictions with Trump's public statements. Shelton characterized post-pandemic inflation as a major policy failure and called for a "regime change" in the Fed’s approach, including reforms to inflation measurement and communication strategies. She criticized the current practice of Fed officials frequently signaling future rate moves and did not commit to maintaining post-meeting press conferences, suggesting potential reductions in transparency. Regarding crypto markets, Shelton’s extensive investments in digital asset companies—including Solana, DeFi, and blockchain infrastructure—were noted, though she has pledged to divest these holdings due to ethics rules. Her familiarity with the crypto industry and deregulatory leanings may signal a more open, though cautious, stance toward digital assets. However, concerns were raised about potential conflicts of interest, especially given Trump family involvement in crypto-financial ventures. The timing of her confirmation remains uncertain, pending a Justice Department investigation into current Chair Powell. Shelton’s potential leadership could lead to a more hawkish, productivity-focused Fed with tighter policy communication—factors that may significantly influence liquidity conditions and macro narratives for crypto markets.

marsbit8h ago

Warsh Hearing Concludes: What Are the Notable Signals for the Crypto Industry?

marsbit8h ago

Trading

Spot
Futures

Hot Articles

What is $BITCOIN

DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN): A Comprehensive Analysis Introduction to DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) is a blockchain-based project operating on the Solana network, which aims to combine the characteristics of traditional precious metals with the innovation of decentralized technologies. While it shares a name with Bitcoin, often referred to as “digital gold” due to its perception as a store of value, DIGITAL GOLD is a separate token designed to create a unique ecosystem within the Web3 landscape. Its goal is to position itself as a viable alternative digital asset, although specifics regarding its applications and functionalities are still developing. What is DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN)? DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) is a cryptocurrency token explicitly designed for use on the Solana blockchain. In contrast to Bitcoin, which provides a widely recognized value storage role, this token appears to focus on broader applications and characteristics. Notable aspects include: Blockchain Infrastructure: The token is built on the Solana blockchain, known for its capacity to handle high-speed and low-cost transactions. Supply Dynamics: DIGITAL GOLD has a maximum supply capped at 100 quadrillion tokens (100P $BITCOIN), although details regarding its circulating supply are currently undisclosed. Utility: While precise functionalities are not explicitly outlined, there are indications that the token could be utilized for various applications, potentially involving decentralized applications (dApps) or asset tokenization strategies. Who is the Creator of DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN)? At present, the identity of the creators and development team behind DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) remains unknown. This situation is typical among many innovative projects within the blockchain space, particularly those aligning with decentralized finance and meme coin phenomena. While such anonymity may foster a community-driven culture, it intensifies concerns about governance and accountability. Who are the Investors of DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN)? The available information indicates that DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) does not have any known institutional backers or prominent venture capital investments. The project seems to operate on a peer-to-peer model focused on community support and adoption rather than traditional funding routes. Its activity and liquidity are primarily situated on decentralized exchanges (DEXs), such as PumpSwap, rather than established centralized trading platforms, further highlighting its grassroots approach. How DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) Works The operational mechanics of DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) can be elaborated on based on its blockchain design and network attributes: Consensus Mechanism: By leveraging Solana’s unique proof-of-history (PoH) combined with a proof-of-stake (PoS) model, the project ensures efficient transaction validation contributing to the network's high performance. Tokenomics: While specific deflationary mechanisms have not been extensively detailed, the vast maximum token supply implies that it may cater to microtransactions or niche use cases that are still to be defined. Interoperability: There exists the potential for integration with Solana’s broader ecosystem, including various decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms. However, the details regarding specific integrations remain unspecified. Timeline of Key Events Here is a timeline that highlights significant milestones concerning DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN): 2023: The initial deployment of the token occurs on the Solana blockchain, marked by its contract address. 2024: DIGITAL GOLD gains visibility as it becomes available for trading on decentralized exchanges like PumpSwap, allowing users to trade it against SOL. 2025: The project witnesses sporadic trading activity and potential interest in community-led engagements, although no noteworthy partnerships or technical advancements have been documented as of yet. Critical Analysis Strengths Scalability: The underlying Solana infrastructure supports high transaction volumes, which could enhance the utility of $BITCOIN in various transaction scenarios. Accessibility: The potential low trading price per token could attract retail investors, facilitating wider participation due to fractional ownership opportunities. Risks Lack of Transparency: The absence of publicly known backers, developers, or an audit process may yield skepticism regarding the project's sustainability and trustworthiness. Market Volatility: The trading activity is heavily reliant on speculative behavior, which can result in significant price volatility and uncertainty for investors. Conclusion DIGITAL GOLD ($BITCOIN) emerges as an intriguing yet ambiguous project within the rapidly evolving Solana ecosystem. While it attempts to leverage the “digital gold” narrative, its departure from Bitcoin's established role as a store of value underscores the need for a clearer differentiation of its intended utility and governance structure. Future acceptance and adoption will likely depend on addressing the current opacity and defining its operational and economic strategies more explicitly. Note: This report encompasses synthesised information available as of October 2023, and developments may have transpired beyond the research period.

363 Total ViewsPublished 2025.05.13Updated 2025.05.13

What is $BITCOIN

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of BTC (BTC) are presented below.

活动图片