Why Isn't Bitcoin's Higher Ownership Rate Than Gold Among Americans Considered a Victory?

marsbitPublished on 2026-08-27Last updated on 2026-08-27

Abstract

Bitcoin adoption among American adults has surpassed gold holdings, with 18.6% of U.S. adults holding Bitcoin compared to 10.8% holding gold, according to a July study. The U.S. holds roughly 42% of the global Bitcoin supply, and a proposed bill could direct the Treasury to study accumulating Bitcoin as a reserve asset. Macro factors, including the U.S. Treasury's increased bond buyback program, weakened the dollar and boosted both gold and Bitcoin as alternative assets. The Bitcoin-to-gold price ratio is highlighted as a leading indicator. While Bitcoin's adoption rate is significant, its total market value remains far below gold's, indicating a shift in trajectory rather than a parity in institutional allocation. Key signals to watch include sustained dollar weakness, potential expansion of Treasury buybacks, and a continued rise in the Bitcoin-to-gold ratio, which would suggest capital rotation from gold to Bitcoin.

Written by: Ashrith Rao

Compiled by: Chopper, Foresight News

The ownership rate of Bitcoin among American adults has surpassed that of gold. At the same time, a repurchase announcement from the U.S. Treasury Department has drawn the U.S. dollar, gold, and Bitcoin into the same trading scenario.

In the United States, the ownership rate of Bitcoin now exceeds that of gold. River Financial's July research found that 49.6 million American adults (18.6% of the population) currently hold Bitcoin, while 28.8 million (10.8%) hold gold. This gap of nearly 21 million people reveals more than just a shift in retail preference; it signals something deeper.

The Changes Behind the Numbers

According to River's data, Bitcoin's ownership rate in the U.S. increased from 14.3% to 18.6% in just over six months. This adoption speed is quite remarkable for an asset still known for its high volatility. Collectively, Americans hold approximately 42% of the global Bitcoin supply; U.S.-listed companies account for as much as 92.7% of Bitcoin held by listed companies worldwide, totaling about 1.24 million BTC. The U.S. government itself holds 328,372 BTC (primarily obtained through asset seizures), valued at over $26 billion based on CoinGecko's price.

This Bitcoin reserve has become a reference point for reserve legislation. The 'American Reserve Modernization Act,' introduced in Congress in May of this year, would direct the Treasury to study accumulating Bitcoin in a budget-neutral manner. Previous reports suggested the bill aimed to accumulate up to 1 million BTC within five years, but The Block's related report removed that specific figure, replacing it with a directive to conduct a study. Therefore, the 1 million figure should be understood as an earlier proposal, not the current objective of the bill.

Wall Street's stance has also shifted. This year, several major U.S. asset management firms have opened access to Bitcoin ETFs for their financial advisors, bringing the asset to financial planners who previously had little reason to mention it to clients.

The Macro Context

These ownership statistics build upon a larger move. On August 19th, the U.S. Treasury Department announced it would double its liquidity support repurchase for long-term government bonds, raising the single-operation cap from $2 billion to at least $4 billion, with the execution period running from September 9th to November 4th. The market reacted immediately: the U.S. Dollar Index fell by about 0.9%, dropping to its lowest level since May 29th; gold rose by about 2%, reaching around $4,480 per ounce.

A policy aimed at lowering long-end yields to support bond market liquidity also weakens the relative appeal of the U.S. dollar. Both gold and Bitcoin are seen as alternatives to the dollar. This is precisely why they both rose after the announcement, despite often being portrayed as rivals, not allies.

The Bitcoin-to-Gold Ratio

Matt Cole, CEO of Strive, has pointed out that the Bitcoin-to-Gold ratio is a leading indicator worth watching. In The Block's related report, Cole noted that Bitcoin's price relative to gold bottomed in February 2026, roughly five months earlier than its bottom in U.S. dollar terms in July. He believes a similar lag occurred at the peak of the previous cycle: Bitcoin-to-Gold peaked in December 2024, but the U.S. dollar price didn't peak until October 2025.

If this pattern holds, Bitcoin's simultaneous breakout against both gold and the U.S. dollar within the same week is a signal worth tracking, not a coincidence.

Structural Tailwinds

Two forces are contributing most of the thrust to Bitcoin's current move. The first is the U.S. dollar: the Treasury's repurchase plan signals tolerance for a weaker currency, and a Dollar Index breaking below the May low would remove a headwind that Bitcoin hasn't yet faced in this cycle.

The second is Artificial Intelligence. As intelligence becomes cheaper and more ubiquitous, the advantages that previously came from scarce insight or software capabilities are commoditized faster, pushing capital toward assets that cannot be replicated—Bitcoin, gold, and silver are among them.

Bitcoin's selling point is that it combines the fixed supply of gold with features that gold lacks in the digital economy—instant settlement, global transferability, and native compatibility with digital financial infrastructure.

Ownership Rate Does Not Equal Value

The ownership numbers are certainly eye-catching, but they are just the tip of the iceberg. Gold's market capitalization still far exceeds Bitcoin's, so leading in ownership share does not mean Bitcoin has closed the value gap in institutional allocation; these are two different measures. What has truly changed is Bitcoin's trajectory. The government's 328,372 BTC and U.S. corporate holdings of 1.24 million BTC both indicate Bitcoin is evolving from a story of retail speculation toward a role closer to a reserve asset for sovereign states and corporations—a role that gold has occupied for a long time.

The following three things could indicate whether the events of August 19th mark a genuine turning point, not a one-off reaction. First, whether the U.S. Dollar Index holds below the May low, confirming this is fundamental weakness, not a temporary pullback. Second, whether the Treasury's repurchase plan is extended or expanded; if so, Bitcoin reaching $100,000 or higher by year-end becomes a more realistic possibility. Third, whether the Bitcoin-to-Gold ratio continues to climb, indicating capital rotation from gold into Bitcoin. Macro conditions are moving in Bitcoin's favor, but whether capital follows remains an open question.

Related Questions

QAccording to the article, what is the current Bitcoin holding rate among American adults and how does it compare to gold?

AAccording to River Financial's July research, 18.6% of American adults (approximately 49.6 million people) hold Bitcoin, while 10.8% (approximately 28.8 million people) hold gold. Bitcoin's holding rate is significantly higher.

QWhat specific policy announcement by the US Treasury is discussed in the article, and what was its immediate impact on the markets?

AOn August 19th, the US Treasury announced it would double the size of its liquidity support repurchases for long-term government bonds, raising the cap from $2 billion to at least $4 billion per operation. The immediate market reaction saw the US Dollar Index fall by about 0.9% to its lowest level since May 29th, while gold rose by about 2% to approximately $4,480 per ounce.

QWhat role does the Bitcoin-to-Gold ratio play as an indicator, according to Matt Cole as cited in the article?

AStrive CEO Matt Cole suggests the Bitcoin-to-Gold ratio is a leading indicator. The article states that Bitcoin's price against gold bottomed in February 2026, roughly five months before its bottom in US dollar terms. This same lag was observed at the previous cycle's peak, indicating the ratio might provide an early signal for Bitcoin's price movement in USD.

QThe article mentions two major structural tailwinds for Bitcoin. What are they?

AThe two major structural tailwinds mentioned are: 1) A weakening US Dollar, potentially signaled by the Treasury's actions, which removes a headwind for Bitcoin. 2) The rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI), which commoditizes intellectual advantages and pushes capital towards assets that cannot be replicated, such as Bitcoin and gold.

QAccording to the article, why does Bitcoin's higher holding rate compared to gold not equate to victory, and what three developments would indicate a true turning point?

AThe higher holding rate does not equate to victory because gold's total market capitalization still far exceeds Bitcoin's, meaning the gap in institutional allocation value remains large. Three developments that would indicate a true turning point are: 1) The US Dollar Index holding below its May lows, confirming fundamental weakness. 2) An extension or expansion of the Treasury's repurchase plan, increasing the likelihood of Bitcoin reaching $100k+. 3) A sustained climb in the Bitcoin-to-Gold ratio, signaling capital rotation from gold into Bitcoin.

Related Reads

Belgium requests EU registrars' data on cryptocurrency wallets as part of piracy investigation

Belgian authorities are intensifying efforts against digital piracy by compelling European domain registrars to disclose comprehensive data on suspected piracy website operators. Acting on orders from the Brussels Enterprise Court, the Belgian Department for Online Infringements has issued broad directives that go beyond typical domain blocking. The orders demand that registrars, including Hosting Concepts, Hostinger, and Key Systems, reveal extensive identifying information. The required data encompasses full names, physical addresses, phone numbers, financial details like IBANs and credit card data, as well as cryptocurrency wallet addresses and transaction hashes. Registrars must also provide up to 12 months of connection logs, device information, and associated IP addresses. While specifics about the rights holders and target websites are redacted, the court's reference to protecting the "sports economy" suggests a focus on illegal sports streaming networks. The court order includes strict non-disclosure provisions, prohibiting the registrars from notifying the account holders or the public about the investigation. Authorities cite the EU's Digital Services Act, which allows for exemptions from standard user notification requirements during criminal probes. Although the measures are said to apply to any service provider accessible in Belgium, legal experts note the cross-border enforcement against entities based outside the country remains untested under this legal framework.

cryptonews.ru15m ago

Belgium requests EU registrars' data on cryptocurrency wallets as part of piracy investigation

cryptonews.ru15m ago

Trading

Spot
活动图片