为何 Tom Lee 的以太坊价值理论存在根本性谬误？

比推Published on 2025-09-25Last updated on 2025-09-25

作者：Andrew Kang，Mechanism 合伙人

编译：AididiaoJP，Foresight News

原标题：买了 242 万枚 ETH 的 Tom Lee 根本不懂以太坊？

Tom Lee 的 ETH 理论是我这段时间从知名分析师那里看到的、由金融文盲论点组合而成最愚蠢的理论之一。让我们来逐一剖析。Tom Lee 的理论基于以下几点：

  • 稳定币与 RWA 的采用

  • 数字石油的类比

  • 机构将购买并质押 ETH，在保障网络的安全性的同时进行资产代币化，并作为运营资本。

  • ETH 的价值将等同于所有金融基础设施公司的价值之和

  • 技术分析

这个论点大致是这样的，稳定币和代币化资产的活动正在增加，这应该会推动交易量增长，从而推动 ETH 的手续费和收入的增加。表面上看这有道理，但如果你花几分钟时间并费一脑细胞核对数据，你会发现事实并非如此。

每日 ETH 交易手续费（美元）

自 2020 年以来，代币化资产价值和稳定币交易量增长了 100 到 1000 倍。Tom Lee 论点从根本上误解了价值积累的方式，可能会让你认为手续费会按比例增长，但实际上它们几乎与 2020 年的水平相同。

原因有以下几点：

  • 以太坊网络升级使得交易更高效

  • 稳定币和代币化资产活动流向了其他公链

  • 代币化低周转率的资产不会产生太多手续费。代币化的价值与 ETH 的收入不成正比。某人可以代币化一种 1 亿美元的债券，如果它每两年交易一次，那能为 ETH 产生多少手续费？0.10 美元？一笔 USDT 交易可能产生的手续费都比这多。

你可以代币化价值万亿美元的资产，但如果这些资产不频繁流动，那么它可能只给 ETH 增加 10 万美元的价值。

区块链的交易量和产生的手续费会增长吗？是的但大部分手续费将被那些拥有更强业务拓展团队的其他公链区块链捕获。在将传统金融交易引入链上方面，其他竞争者看到了机会并正在积极抢占市场。Solana、Arbitrum 和 Tempo 正在获得早期的大部分重大胜利。甚至 Tether 也在支持两个新的 Tether 链，Plasma 和 Stable，两者都旨在将 USDT 交易量转移到它们自己的链上。

石油是一种商品。经通胀调整后的实际石油价格在一个多世纪以来一直在同一区间内交易，伴有周期性的冲高回落。我同意汤姆的观点，即 ETH 可以被视为一种商品，但这并不是直接看涨，也无法确定汤姆在这里想表达什么！

机构将购买并质押 ETH

大型银行和其他金融机构已经在他们的资产负债表上购买 ETH 了吗？没有。

他们有宣布任何这样做的计划吗？也没有。

银行会因为持续支付能源费用而囤积汽油吗？不会，这根本不重要，他们只是在需要时支付费用。

银行会购买他们使用的资产托管机构的股票吗？不会。

得了吧，这再次体现了对价值积累的根本误解，纯属妄想。

我实际上非常喜欢技术分析，并且相信客观看待时它可能非常有价值。不幸的是，Tom Lee 似乎在通过技术分析随意画线来支持他的偏见。

客观看这张图表，最明显的观察结果是以太坊处于长时间的震荡区间。与原油价格在过去三十年里也在宽幅区间内交易并无太大不同。我们不仅处于区间内，而且最近触及了区间顶部，未能突破阻力位。如果说有什么不同的话，以太坊的技术面是看跌的。我不会排除其可能在更长时间内处于 1,000 美元至 4,800 美元区间震荡的可能性。一个资产之前有过抛物线式的上涨，并不意味着它会无限期地持续下去。

原油价格

ETH/BTC 长期图表也被误解了。它确实处于一个长期区间内，但过去几年主要由下跌趋势主导，最近在长期支撑位出现反弹。下跌趋势的驱动因素是以太坊的叙事已经饱和，且基本面无法证明估值增长的合理性，这些基本面并未改变。

以太坊的估值主要来源于金融文盲。这确实可以创造相当大的市值，看看 XRP 就知道了。但由金融文盲推导出的估值并非无限的。更广泛的宏观流动性使 ETH 市值得以维持，但除非发生重大的组织变革，否则它很可能注定会无限期地表现不佳。

Twitter：https://twitter.com/BitpushNewsCN

比推 TG 交流群：https://t.me/BitPushCommunity

比推 TG 订阅： https://t.me/bitpush

原文链接:https://foresightnews.pro/article/detail/90552
说明: 比推所有文章只代表作者观点，不构成投资建议
Tom Lee以太坊
相关新闻

Trending Cryptos

ctr
CitreaCTR
wstusdt
wrapped stUSDTWSTUSDT
apr
CapricornAPR
ctx
Cryptex FinanceCTX
audio
AudiusAUDIO
comp
CompoundCOMP
mantra
MantraMANTRA
waxl
AxelarWAXL
bill
Billions NetworkBILL
pyth
PYTH (Pyth)PYTH
rune
THORChainRUNE
brev
BrevisBREV
cake
PancakeSwapCAKE
dos
DAPPOSDOS
jst
JUSTJST

Related Reads

Claude's Watermark Has Been Cracked, Gaining 11k Stars, But Installation Is Refused

The article discusses the controversy surrounding Anthropic's implementation of a hidden watermark in all text generated by its AI, Claude. This policy, based on Google DeepMind's SynthID-Text technique, embeds a statistical signature by making inconsequential word choices. The watermark applies globally, even to human-written text lightly edited by Claude, sparking user backlash over issues of ownership and the creation of an "AI content second-class citizen" status. In response, an open-source tool called "watermarks-remover" (originally "remove-claude-marks") was released on GitHub, quickly gaining 11k stars. It works on three levels: removing invisible Unicode characters, using an agent to rewrite text and break statistical patterns, and stripping metadata from various file formats. Notably, Claude itself refused to install this removal tool as an Agent Skill, a task ultimately completed by another AI model, GLM 5.2. The article points out the irony that the removal code may have been written by Claude. The piece frames this as an ongoing battle between watermarking for traceability against misinformation and the desire for unmarked, owned content from paying users. It questions the practicality of mandatory technical markings when AI-generated text becomes indistinguishable from human writing, suggesting the open-source community's rapid development of countermeasures will continually outpace regulatory efforts.

marsbit24m ago

Claude's Watermark Has Been Cracked, Gaining 11k Stars, But Installation Is Refused

marsbit24m ago

SafePal Leaks Data of Nearly 40,000 Hardware Wallet Buyers: Private Keys Intact, Yet Danger Moves Closer to the Physical

Hardware wallet manufacturer SafePal has disclosed a data breach affecting approximately 39,798 customers who placed orders between March 2025 and April 2026. The leak exposed personal information including names, email addresses, phone numbers, physical delivery addresses, and purchase records. The company confirmed that private keys, recovery phrases, wallet passwords, and financial details were not compromised, as the cold storage systems operate in an isolated environment separate from the e-commerce servers. However, the breach poses significant risks beyond digital theft. Attackers now possess a high-value list of confirmed hardware wallet owners, effectively marking them as likely holders of substantial cryptocurrency. This enables highly targeted social engineering attacks, such as phishing emails referencing real order details, fake hardware deliveries, or phone scams impersonating SafePal support. The company has already identified and taken down over 30 related phishing sites. A critical aspect of the incident is the delayed disclosure timeline. SafePal acknowledged receiving initial user reports of phishing attempts in May but treated them as isolated. A full investigation began in July, with a public announcement not made until August, leaving users exposed for approximately three months. Furthermore, a configuration error prevented a data-purge routine from deleting old order information as intended, potentially increasing the scope of the leaked data. The incident highlights a structural paradox in the hardware wallet industry: while the devices are designed to secure private keys offline, the necessary e-commerce process collects sensitive personal data that, if leaked, makes the user a target. This mirrors a similar breach suffered by Ledger in 2020. Affected users are advised to be extremely vigilant. They should verify if they are impacted via SafePal's dedicated page, treat all unsolicited communications (emails, calls, physical mail) referencing SafePal as suspicious, and never share recovery phrases. Users who may have entered sensitive information on a phishing site must create a new wallet immediately. The breach underscores that in cryptocurrency security, the most vulnerable link is often the human user, not the cryptographic technology.

marsbit45m ago

SafePal Leaks Data of Nearly 40,000 Hardware Wallet Buyers: Private Keys Intact, Yet Danger Moves Closer to the Physical

marsbit45m ago

30 Years After Being Crushed by AI, People Have Fallen Back in Love with Chess

On May 11, 1997, IBM's "Deep Blue" defeated chess champion Garry Kasparov, marking the first time a machine triumphed in a top-level intellectual game. The narrative of human defeat by AI seemed cemented when AlphaGo beat Lee Sedol in Go in 2016, a game once considered AI's final frontier. Yet, nearly 30 years after AI's dominance began, chess is experiencing unprecedented popularity. Chess.com boasts over 250 million registered users and 10 million daily active players. Its CEO, Erik Allebest, attributes this resurgence to several waves: the pandemic, the Netflix series *The Queen's Gambit*, and viral AI chess bots like "Mittens" on social media. Crucially, each surge left a permanently higher user base. The key insight is that AI liberated the game. When machines unequivocally became the best, the pressure to "win" as the ultimate human was removed. Chess returned to its core: the intrinsic joy of play—the thrill of a tactical combo, the tension of a time scramble, the curiosity of post-game analysis. AI, now serving as an always-available coach and anti-cheat tool, became infrastructure that enhanced rather than killed the experience. In contrast, Go, deeply rooted in East Asian elite culture and often pursued for mastery and status, suffered a "collapse of meaning" at the professional level after AlphaGo. Players began mimicking AI moves, erasing distinctive styles and narrative. While some Go players gained fame as online personalities, it didn't translate to widespread engagement with the game itself. The divergence highlights a fundamental question in the age of AI: is the motivation for an activity about *winning* or *playing*? Activities where the process itself is the reward, like chess, can thrive when the pressure of being the best is gone. AI may rightly take over tasks done purely for outcome, but it cannot replace the human experience of simply enjoying the game.

marsbit59m ago

30 Years After Being Crushed by AI, People Have Fallen Back in Love with Chess

marsbit59m ago

Exiting Top Ten Shareholders of Kweichow Moutai, 'Long-term Capital' Portfolio Adjustments Revealed: National Social Security Fund Enters 12 New Stocks, Invests in Hard Tech Mthreads

With the ongoing release of semi-annual reports, the second-quarter investment moves of long-term institutional investors like the National Social Security Fund (NSSF) and insurance capital are becoming clear. Central Huijin Asset Management and China Securities Finance Corp., often referred to as the "national team," are no longer among the top ten shareholders of Kweichow Moutai. Data shows that as of August 14th, the NSSF held positions in 33 A-share companies, with a total portfolio value exceeding 11 billion yuan. It added 12 new stocks in Q2, spanning sectors like chemicals, food & beverage, and semiconductors. The NSSF maintains its stable investment style, favoring companies with solid performance and attractive valuations. Apart from exiting Moutai, Huijin and China Securities Finance also left the top ten shareholder lists of companies like Ping An Bank and Dahua Technology. Insurance capital heavily invested in 41 companies in Q2, with a total holding value over 26 billion yuan. They showed a continued preference for cyclical sectors like non-ferrous metals and chemicals, as well as high-dividend-yield stocks. Analysts note that these long-term funds act as market stabilizers and investment bellwethers. Their presence is reshaping the market ecology, steering focus towards fundamental corporate value and away from speculative trading. A notable move was the NSSF's new investment in Moore Threads, a loss-making but leading domestic GPU design company listed on the STAR Market, indicating interest in hard technology sectors. Looking ahead, analysts expect long-term capital to continue a dual-strategy: maintaining a foundation in high-dividend-value stocks while gradually increasing exposure to growth areas aligned with industrial upgrading, such as advanced manufacturing and tech self-sufficiency. The market's recovery is seen as gaining a firmer footing after recent adjustments.

marsbit1h ago

Exiting Top Ten Shareholders of Kweichow Moutai, 'Long-term Capital' Portfolio Adjustments Revealed: National Social Security Fund Enters 12 New Stocks, Invests in Hard Tech Mthreads

marsbit1h ago

Data of 54,000 wallet users leaked, Clarity odds just 10%: Hodler’s Digest, Aug. 16

Galaxy Digital has slashed the odds of the CLARITY Act passing in 2026 from 75% to just 10%, citing limited Senate session days. If it fails, the SEC and CFTC plan to issue their own crypto rules, though an SEC meeting was abruptly cancelled. High-profile meetings at the White House are planned to discuss the bill. Amid growing hack fears, crypto companies are urging AI labs to grant developers early access to advanced AI models for cybersecurity, following a $116M Coldcard wallet theft. Data breaches at Trezor and SafePal have exposed over 54,000 users' personal information. The CFTC is clashing with states over regulating prediction markets like Kalshi, ordering it to ignore a New York restraining order to maintain a national market, while a Washington state judge ruled against it. The Ethereum Foundation is revising its post-quantum plan, moving away from the Poseidon hash function, and scoping its next major upgrade, Hegotá, for next year. Tether received its first full clean audit opinion from KPMG, showing reserves exceeding liabilities by $6.814 billion. Marketwise, major cryptos saw weekly declines. Predictions include a possible Bitcoin bottom in October, while analysts dispute the feasibility of BTC reaching $1M by 2030. Glassnode notes Bitcoin is in its longest capitulation phase since FTX's collapse. Three men were charged for an alleged Bitcoin kidnapping plot in Missouri.

cointelegraph2h ago

Data of 54,000 wallet users leaked, Clarity odds just 10%: Hodler’s Digest, Aug. 16

cointelegraph2h ago

Trading

Spot

Hot Articles

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of ETH (ETH) are presented below.

活动图片

Top Questions