‘Wrong approach’ – Crypto lobby rejects Wall Street’s tighter DeFi rules for tokenized securities

ambcrypto2026-04-08 tarihinde yayınlandı2026-04-08 tarihinde güncellendi

Özet

The Blockchain Association (BA) has strongly opposed a proposal from Citadel Securities and traditional finance (SIFMA) calling for stricter regulation of DeFi protocols that handle tokenized securities. In a letter to the SEC, the BA argued that applying existing securities laws, which are designed for intermediaries, to neutral decentralized infrastructure is the "wrong approach." While affirming that tokenized securities are still securities, the BA emphasized that the SEC should consider how modern blockchain technology works before regulating, rather than automatically classifying DeFi infrastructure as exchanges or brokers. This pushback aligns with earlier criticism from the DeFi Education Fund (DEF). Citadel and SIFMA, however, maintain that all platforms handling tokenized securities must be under regulatory oversight to ensure a level playing field and investor protection, regardless of whether they are custodial or decentralized. The outcome hinges on the SEC's decision, which could potentially be challenged in court if it is not codified by the CLARITY Act.

The DeFi sector is doubling down on its pushback against the Citadel-led call for barring decentralized protocols from blanket regulatory exemption.

In a letter to the U.S SEC on Monday, the Blockchain Association (BA) termed Citadel’s proposed regulation of DeFi protocols handling tokenized assets as a “wrong approach.”

The BA is an advocacy and an umbrella group with key industry members, including Coinbase. In the letter, the BA rebutted,

Securities laws regulate intermediaries. They do not automatically turn neutral infrastructure into an exchange, broker, or dealer simply because that infrastructure is part of a tokenized market.

The lobby group added that the DeFi sector is not after a “free pass.” However, it asked the SEC to consider how the underlying tech works before regulating any DeFi protocol.

The digital asset industry is not asking for a free pass. Tokenized securities are still securities. The question is whether the SEC will apply the law in a way that reflects how modern infrastructure actually works.

Tokenized securities are an on-chain version of traditional securities, but traded via blockchain rails.

Citadel wants everyone to play by the rules

Intriguingly, the BA’s request for the SEC to consider how “modern blockchain infrastructure design” works is what Citadel and SIFMA (broader TradFi group) are against. For the TradFi players, the SEC must ensure a level playing field through a “neutral technology” framework.

For them, the issue is not whether a DeFi venue is custodial (controlled by the developer) or not. What’s crucial, they added, is that every platform handling tokenized securities must be under oversight just like traditional intermediaries.

According to critics of the proposed innovation exemption, investor protections in the DeFi world, which is full of scams and rug pulls, can only be ensured by regulations.

Last week, another crypto lobby, the DeFi Education Fund (DEF), castigated SIFMA and Citadel’s call for regulation of AMMs (automated market makers), which are deemed decentralized platforms by experts.

It remains to be seen which route the SEC will take and whether the disgruntled side will sue the agency for its decision on the innovation exemption.

Even so, if the agency’s rulemaking or guidelines related to DeFi exemptions aren’t codified via the CLARITY Act, then they could still be disputed in court. For instance, Roman Storm, the developer behind Tornado Cash with no control over the crypto mixer, is still facing a retrial.

Final Summary

Blockchain Association has joined DeFi Education Fund to fend off Citadel and Wall Street’s push for regulations of decentralized protocols.
The DeFi lobby groups pleaded with the SEC to consider the neutral nature of decentralized protocols before attempting to regulate them.

İlgili Sorular

QWhat is the main argument of the Blockchain Association (BA) against Citadel's proposed DeFi regulations?

AThe Blockchain Association argues that Citadel's proposed regulation is a 'wrong approach,' stating that securities laws regulate intermediaries and should not automatically turn neutral infrastructure into an exchange, broker, or dealer simply because it is part of a tokenized market.

QAccording to the article, what do Citadel and SIFMA believe is crucial for platforms handling tokenized securities?

ACitadel and SIFMA believe that every platform handling tokenized securities must be under regulatory oversight, just like traditional intermediaries, to ensure a level playing field through a 'neutral technology' framework.

QWhat specific request did the Blockchain Association make to the SEC regarding DeFi regulation?

AThe Blockchain Association asked the SEC to consider how the underlying technology of 'modern blockchain infrastructure design' works before regulating any DeFi protocol, rather than granting a blanket exemption or applying rules without understanding the tech.

QWhich other crypto lobby group has also opposed Citadel and SIFMA's call for DeFi regulation?

AThe DeFi Education Fund (DEF) has also opposed Citadel and SIFMA's call for regulation, specifically criticizing their push to regulate automated market makers (AMMs).

QWhat potential legal outcome is mentioned if the SEC's rulemaking on DeFi exemptions isn't codified via the CLARITY Act?

AIf the SEC's rulemaking or guidelines related to DeFi exemptions aren't codified via the CLARITY Act, they could still be disputed in court, as seen in the case of Roman Storm, the developer behind Tornado Cash, who is facing a retrial.

İlgili Okumalar

New research says quantum computers won’t break Bitcoin mining — but here’s what could

New research challenges the widely held concern that quantum computers could overpower Bitcoin's mining system. The study, titled "Kardashev-scale Quantum Computing for Bitcoin Mining," concludes that while quantum algorithms like Grover’s could theoretically accelerate mining, real-world constraints—such as reversible hashing, error correction, and Bitcoin’s 10-minute block window—make such an attack impractical. A viable quantum mining operation would require millions of qubits and energy consumption comparable to a national power grid, approaching Kardashev Type II civilization levels. Instead, the more immediate quantum threat lies in cryptographic vulnerabilities: Shor’s algorithm could break the public-key cryptography securing Bitcoin wallets. This shifts the focus from mining competition to the need for quantum-resistant security upgrades.

ambcrypto7 dk önce

New research says quantum computers won’t break Bitcoin mining — but here’s what could

ambcrypto7 dk önce

Analysts Highlight Ozak AI as a Rare Opportunity Combining Low Entry Price With Long-Term Value Expansion

Analysts are highlighting Ozak AI ($OZ) as a compelling AI crypto presale opportunity, combining a low entry price with long-term growth potential. Currently in Phase 7 of its presale, the $OZ token is priced at $0.014, with over $6.6 million raised. The project is built on an AI-powered platform that merges predictive tools with a DePIN (Decentralized Physical Infrastructure Network) model, focusing on decentralized infrastructure and real-world utility rather than speculation. Key features include cross-chain functionality, staking, governance, and audited smart contracts. Strategic partnerships with firms like SINT, Hive Intel, Weblume, and Meganet support its ecosystem growth and scalability.

TheNewsCrypto12 dk önce

Analysts Highlight Ozak AI as a Rare Opportunity Combining Low Entry Price With Long-Term Value Expansion

TheNewsCrypto12 dk önce

Bitcoin Just Reached A Critical Point In The Cycle, And Here’s What To Watch Out For

Bitcoin is approaching a critical phase in its market cycle, as indicated by the Accumulation Distribution Cycle Index (ADCI). This macro-level tool, developed by @arch_physicist and used by Alphractal, categorizes Bitcoin’s market behavior into three ranges: accumulation (0-30), trending (30-70), and distribution (70-100). The ADCI suggests Bitcoin may be entering the distribution zone, where the risk of larger holders offloading supply increases. Unlike past cycles that ended with sharp tops and corrections, distribution in the current mature market may occur more slowly—marked by sideways movement, weakening rallies, and exhaustion in momentum. Investors should monitor structural signals like the index's climb alongside slowing price action, rather than short-term spikes, to gauge whether the cycle transition is underway.

bitcoinist37 dk önce

Bitcoin Just Reached A Critical Point In The Cycle, And Here’s What To Watch Out For

bitcoinist37 dk önce

Ray Dalio's New Article: The World Is Entering a War Cycle

Ray Dalio argues that the world is in the early stages of a prolonged "world war" that is unlikely to end soon. This conflict is not a single declared war but a combination of multiple regional hot wars (e.g., Russia-Ukraine, Israel-Gaza, US-Iran) and non-shooting wars (economic, technological, capital, and geopolitical influence wars). These interconnected conflicts are reshaping global order, driven by shifting alliances, resource competition, and the weaponization of critical trade routes like the Strait of Hormuz. Key powers are aligning into opposing blocs: China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea versus the US, Israel, Gulf states, Japan, and Australia. Dalio emphasizes that victory in such conflicts depends not on absolute strength but on which side can endure prolonged pain and resource depletion. He warns that the US, while powerful, is overextended globally and may struggle to manage multiple fronts simultaneously. The current phase resembles historical pre-war periods (e.g., 1913–1914, 1938–1939), where economic and military tensions escalate into broader conflicts. Dalio urges observers to look beyond short-term events and focus on structural shifts: rising debt, internal political pressures, and the erosion of the US-led multilateral order into a "might-makes-right" system. He assesses a >50% probability of at least one major conflict escalating within five years, including scenarios in Ukraine, Korea, or the South China Sea.

marsbit41 dk önce

Ray Dalio's New Article: The World Is Entering a War Cycle

marsbit41 dk önce

From Presale to Post-Listing, Ozak AI’s Growth Curve Indicates Strong Compounding Potential Over a 24–36 Month Horizon

Ozak AI, an emerging AI-based cryptocurrency, has raised over $6.6 million in its presale phase, demonstrating strong investor confidence. Currently in its 7th stage, the token is priced at $0.014—a 14x increase from its initial offering. Analysts project a potential listing price of $1 on major exchanges, with long-term targets reaching $3 by 2027 and $5 by 2028. The token’s advanced technology integrates AI and blockchain, featuring real-time data processing through the Ozak Streaming Network and secure data storage via encrypted vaults. Strategic partnerships with firms like Hive Intel and Echobit further strengthen its ecosystem. Ozak AI emphasizes long-term growth, with analysts highlighting significant compounding potential over a 24–36 month horizon.

TheNewsCrypto1 saat önce

From Presale to Post-Listing, Ozak AI’s Growth Curve Indicates Strong Compounding Potential Over a 24–36 Month Horizon

TheNewsCrypto1 saat önce

İşlemler

Spot

Futures