Gemini Stock Drops 24% Post-IPO Amid Profitability Woes

TheCryptoTimesPublished on 2025-09-16Last updated on 2025-09-16

Shares of crypto exchange Gemini (GEMI) have fallen nearly 24% since its initial public offering (IPO) last week, signaling a sharp reversal in early investor excitement and raising questions about its high valuation amid significant financial losses.

The stock, which trades on the Nasdaq exchange, closed down approximately 6% on Tuesday at $30.42. After its IPO priced at $28 per share last Friday, Gemini’s stock initially surged to a high of $45.89 on its first day of trading. However, the early gains have since evaporated, with the stock plunging more than 34% from its peak as market sentiment has cooled.

The drop seems to be related to investors’ worries that the company isn’t making enough money. Gemini filed for an initial public offering (IPO) and said it had a net loss of $283 million for the first half of 2025. This was after losing $159 million for the whole year of 2024. The exchange was worth $3.3 billion before trading, which is a big difference in results.

Analyst Highlights Valuation Challenge

Ed Engel, an analyst at Compass Point, highlighted the valuation challenge, noting that “GEMI is currently trading at 26 times its annualized first-half revenue,” a steep multiple for a loss-making company.

Gemini’s slump comes as competitors have seen mixed results over the past week; shares of Coinbase (COIN) remained flat and Robinhood (HOOD) fell 3%, while Circle (CRCL) saw its stock rise 13%.

Gemini Price ChartGemini Price Chart

Gemini Price Chart, SOURCE: Yahoo Finance

While Gemini successfully raised $425 million from its public offering, its subsequent market performance underscores the intense scrutiny that crypto-native firms face on Wall Street. The swift downturn suggests that investors are increasingly prioritizing a clear path to profitability over brand recognition and growth projections alone.

Gemini’s experience may serve as a cautionary tale for other crypto companies considering an IPO, indicating that public markets demand sustainable financial models, even from the most established digital asset brands.

Also read: SEC, Gemini Reach Tentative Settlement in Crypto Lending Case

Disclaimer

The Crypto Times publishes news, analysis, and educational content for informational purposes only. We do not offer financial, investment, legal, or trading advice of any kind. All content on our website is intended to be neutral and fact-based. Readers should always do their own research, consult with licensed professionals, and evaluate risks independently.

The Crypto Times does not endorse or recommend any specific cryptocurrencies, tokens, projects, financial products, or investment strategies. We do not accept legal liability for any financial losses incurred as a result of reliance on information published by us.


Mobile Only ImageMobile Only Image

Related Reads

Zcash ETF Moves One Step Closer: Wall Street to Pack Privacy Coin into Securities Accounts for the First Time

The Grayscale Zcash Trust has filed its fifth amended registration statement with the SEC, aiming to convert into the first U.S. spot ETF directly holding a privacy coin (ticker ZCSH). Key terms include a 2.5% annual fee, Bank of NY Mellon as administrator, and Coinbase for custody and brokerage. The trust held ~388,700 ZEC (~$155M) as of June 30; its AUM surged to ~$260M by August 21, driven by ZEC's price rally from $250 to over $800. The ETF represents a major identity shift for Zcash, a coin previously delisted by many exchanges and flagged by regulators for its anonymity. However, the ETF strips away Zcash's core privacy feature. To ensure compliance, all trust-held ZEC will be stored in transparent addresses, making transactions auditable and traceable. Zcash's optional privacy—unlike Monero's mandatory privacy—is the key compromise enabling this Wall Street entry. Market pricing reflects aggressive optimism for institutional access, but challenges remain. Only ~22% of circulating ZEC is in shielded pools; if ETF demand siphons transparent coins, Zcash's privacy narrative weakens. Competition from programmable privacy on Ethereum L2s could also dilute its value proposition. With prices already up over 200% in four months, the rally may have prematurely priced in the ETF approval, leaving limited safety margin. Grayscale's move highlights traditional finance's capacity to repackage regulatory-edge assets into compliant products, raising questions about the future boundaries of crypto ETF adoption.

marsbit36m ago

Zcash ETF Moves One Step Closer: Wall Street to Pack Privacy Coin into Securities Accounts for the First Time

marsbit36m ago

Trading

Spot
活动图片