Author: Huohuo, The Block
On October 9th, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) released two documents with opposing directions on the same day. One proposal aims to include event contracts for sports, politics, culture, weather, etc., found in prediction markets, within the definition of a swap, while another interim final rule explicitly excludes licensed sports betting and casino games from the definition of a swap.
In plain terms, a swap is a contract where payments are determined by an outcome. Under U.S. derivatives law, once a certain type of contract is classified as a swap, it typically falls under the exclusive regulatory oversight of the CFTC, preempting state gambling licenses and state taxes. This is federal preemption.
Therefore, the core issue of contention is: who writes the rules for the same NFL game? If placed at a Vegas counter or in the DraftKings app, it is state-regulated gambling; if turned into an event contract and placed on a federally registered exchange like Kalshi, the CFTC argues it is a swap.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig is the only sitting commissioner among the five-member commission. He stated directly that Americans use event contracts to hedge, speculate, and obtain information, and these products fall within the category of commodity derivatives under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Casino-style products, however, are not derivatives.
The trading volume is the backdrop for this round of actions. The CFTC reported that event contract volume on U.S. registered exchanges (DCMs) reached approximately $1.5 billion in August, with about $1.2 billion related to sports. Market estimates are much larger. For example, Kalshi and Polymarket combined traded roughly $85.6 billion over a weekend in October, with sports contracts being the primary driver of this surge in volume.

Trading volume for registered sports contracts far exceeds that for politics and weather
One inclusion, one exclusion: Two directions being written into the swap definition
The proposal answers what counts as a swap, while the interim final rule answers what does not. The latter uses two tests to define the boundary. Only wagers offered by licensed state or tribal gaming operators and that are not matched on a multilateral exchange platform are excluded. Both conditions must be met to be considered a casino-style wager.
Combining these two boundaries essentially splits sports betting in half—one half remains with the states, the other is handed over to the federal government. The same sports bet, if placed at a counter in Las Vegas, is gambling; if placed on a federally registered exchange like Kalshi, it becomes a swap.

The same game is being cut into two types of regulation
Similar questions appear in the court brief filed by the American Gaming Association: if a sports bet is considered a swap, should bets placed at Las Vegas counters also have to be on a DCM?
TD Cowen policy analyst Jaret Seiberg offers another interpretation. States have repeatedly argued in lawsuits that the CFTC's definition of event contracts as swaps is too broad, potentially making wagers at state and tribal casinos federally illegal.
The interim final rule, by first carving out casino games, is precisely meant to dismantle this line of attack in court. Seiberg's judgment is that this move is mainly to improve the CFTC's legal position; whether it will be effective is another matter.
If this classification fails to hold up in court, states could potentially use the casino line to pull event contracts back under state law.
The NFL and 39 States: Who should set the rules for the same game?
A clear judicial split has already formed. New Jersey has petitioned the Supreme Court over its jurisdictional dispute with Kalshi. The NFL and 39 states plus Washington, D.C., have filed amicus briefs supporting New Jersey.
The NFL argues that sports event contracts create new risk for gambling, rather than hedging existing risk like a swap, and points out that the CFTC does not prohibit easily manipulated betting lines, nor does it cover lines related to player injuries, referees, or enforce a minimum age of 21. On the first Sunday of this season, prediction markets traded approximately $3.3 billion, with $1.8 billion related to football.
U.S. federal appeals courts are divided into circuits. Different circuit courts can issue contradictory rulings on the same legal question. When such a circuit split occurs, the Supreme Court is more likely to intervene. Three federal appellate circuits have already reached opposite conclusions this year:
Third Circuit (April this year): Held that sports contracts on DCMs are swaps and can preempt state law.
Sixth Circuit (September) and Ninth Circuit (August): Reached the opposite conclusion, holding that these contracts are not swaps and state law applies.

Three circuits hold completely opposite views on swap classification
With the three circuits at odds, the same contract could receive contradictory classifications in different jurisdictions. This is precisely why New Jersey wants to bring the issue to the Supreme Court. Kalshi's response deadline is November 9th, and the Supreme Court has not yet decided whether to hear the case.
Rules Not Yet in Effect; Variables Lie with Courts and Commissioner Seats
As of now, neither document has been published in the Federal Register. The comment period for the proposal begins from the publication date and lasts 30 days. The interim final rule also only takes effect upon publication. Calling them "already entered into consultation" or "already in effect" at this stage is inaccurate.
A more critical variable lies with the courts. New Jersey's petition has placed the split between the Third Circuit and the Sixth/Ninth Circuits before the nine Supreme Court justices. There is no news yet on whether they will hear the case. Administrative rules can strengthen arguments for the Third Circuit's template, but the ultimate authority to interpret the law rests with the judges.
Selig is the only sitting commissioner among the five-member commission. Pushing rules forward under a short-staffed commission may be legally tenable, but the oversight is thin. Once the commission is fully staffed, or if the courts do not adopt this definition, today's protective measures could be rewritten.
In this round of contention, the regulated parties themselves have remained quiet; Kalshi and Polymarket have yet to make any public, on-the-record statements.





