Fearing Bitcoin Theft, Some People Convert BTC into ETFs

Published on 2026-10-14Last updated on 2026-10-14

Abstract

Ledger distributor CryptoBilis's devices suspected of tampering, losses around $100 million, the 'self-custody of private keys' principle for hardware wallets shaken. CZ warns of supply chain risks; OneKey introduces anti-counterfeiting and bus encryption. On October 12, Ledger stated all confirmed cases originated from CryptoBilis. IBIT is being used as a substitute, but the key point is that BlackRock does not hold private keys; all 805,000 BTC are held cold by Coinbase Custody. Subscriptions and redemptions are handled via internal bookkeeping on Coinbase Prime, not on-chain transfers. Actual on-chain movement occurs only during daily end-of-day batch sweeps into cold storage. In August, BlackRock lowered the minimum for swapping Bitcoin for IBIT shares to $1 million. Choosing IBIT means exchanging self-custody risks for multiple layers of trust in Coinbase, BlackRock, brokerages, and trust regulation.

The supply chain attack on hardware wallet Ledger, which led to $100 million being stolen, is still causing a stir. Southeast Asian distributor CryptoBilis had issues and has now suspended all sales and shipments. Beyond concerns about Ledger's subsequent compensation, the community has started discussing the perennial question: how to better protect one's assets.

Hardware wallets were once the standard answer, as slogans like 'with the private keys in your own hands, the assets are truly yours' have long been a tenet of the cryptocurrency industry. However, repeated issues with hardware wallets have significantly shaken user confidence, forcing people to consider what other methods might alleviate this anxiety.

The simplest option is storing assets on exchanges. Major platforms theoretically have the ability to compensate, but the FTX incident is still likely to be brought up.

Others use offline devices, such as an iPhone, reset to factory settings. First, install the necessary apps, then turn on airplane mode and never connect to the internet again, also disabling Bluetooth and NFC. Signing transactions relies on scanning QR codes between two phones—a method that's been around for years, albeit somewhat cumbersome.

Recently, a new method has been proposed, which is quite interesting and hadn't appeared in previous years because the product only emerged in the last two years: buying ETFs, like BlackRock's IBIT.

Why IBIT Can Be Considered a Method for Storing Bitcoin

iShares official holdings data as of October 9 shows: IBIT holds 805,000 bitcoins, with a market value of approximately $66.7 billion, and a fund net asset value of about $66.3 billion.

Let's first look at the structure of IBIT.

This is a statutory trust. The custodian is Coinbase. Coinbase Custody Trust Company stores all the private keys for the trust's bitcoins in cold storage within the Vault Balance. The day-to-day operations of the fund are handled by the trustee, with the sponsor overseeing the overall operations. When redemptions or fee payments are required, the sponsor instructs the custodian to move bitcoin from the Vault Balance to the trading balance. BlackRock does not hold the private keys.

In this entire process, only Coinbase possesses the private keys. Choosing IBIT is, to a large extent, choosing to trust that Coinbase Custody won't have issues, that BlackRock will operate normally, that your broker will properly hold the shares, and in the trust and regulatory framework itself.

In other words, compared to trusting oneself, choosing IBIT means placing greater trust in the judgment of institutions managing astronomical sums of money. After all, they manage $15 trillion without incident.

Another point is liquidity. ETF liquidity is noticeably much lower.

Low liquidity can sometimes be an advantage

When you buy or sell IBIT in your brokerage account, the transaction is matched and executed in the stock market; nothing happens on the blockchain. Only when the fund's overall net holdings need to change will actual bitcoin movement occur. Share creation and redemption are handled via internal book-entry settlement at Coinbase Prime, not counted as on-chain transfers. Bitcoin actually moves on-chain only in the final step when the trust's trading balance is swept into the custodian's cold storage, executed as a batch process at the end of the day.

Even during strong bitcoin market conditions, transaction counts for ETF custody addresses are minimal. For instance, on June 2, 2025, 4,113 bitcoins, worth approximately $4.294 billion, were transferred. Split into multiple batches of around 300 bitcoins each, it amounted to just over a dozen transactions, completed in about two hours.

However, exchanges certainly don't operate at this frequency; tens of thousands of transactions per day are common.

Lower transaction frequency does indeed correlate with relatively higher security. This is an area where ETFs genuinely have an advantage.

So, whom do you choose to trust?

Related Reads

The Lighter Attack: How a Single API Key Drained Tens of Millions of Dollars?

On November 16, a security incident hit Lighter, a decentralized perpetual contract trading platform. Roughly $15.48 million in USDC was drained from two large market-maker accounts (#714710 and #714723), though Lighter officially confirmed only that a single trader's API key was compromised—not the protocol or smart contracts. The attacker reportedly exploited a leaked API key that lacked direct withdrawal permissions by chaining legitimate product features: closing the victim's trading positions to free margin, creating a 0% fee public pool funded with about $10,000 from an attacker-controlled account to secure ~99.99% of pool shares, then using the victim account's internal transfer permissions to move USDC into the pool in ~$1 million batches. Because internal transfers between accounts linked to the same L1 address may not require additional signatures, and such transfers may not have minted new shares for the victim, the attacker's dominant share position appreciated and could be redeemed for the victim's funds. On-chain records show about 10.39 million USDC withdrawn via withdrawPendingBalance, then swapped through CoW Protocol into ~5,764 ETH/WETH, with some funds later moved to Hyperliquid and converted to XMR. Lighter's LIT token fell over 12% in 24 hours. Lighter attributed the root cause to the affected account using unofficial SDK signing code that reused nonces, allowing private key recovery from public signature data; the official SDK was unaffected. The Guardian mechanism paused withdrawals, the security committee returned about $5 million USDC, and deposits/withdrawals have resumed. Lighter now requires wallet signatures for transfers to public pools, makes API key signatures non-public, and plans IP whitelists, API key permissions and limits, plus monitoring for nonce reuse.

marsbit34m ago

The Lighter Attack: How a Single API Key Drained Tens of Millions of Dollars?

marsbit34m ago

Trading

Spot
活动图片