Coinbase faces more severe consequences from CLARITY Act failure — Saxo

cryptonews.ruPublished on 2026-09-17Last updated on 2026-09-17

Abstract

Saxo Bank notes that the failure of the U.S. Senate to advance the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act (CLARITY Act) has more severe implications for Coinbase than for other crypto-related firms. According to Saxo strategist Ruben Dalfovo, clearer market rules directly impact Coinbase's core trading business by affecting registration requirements, tradable assets, and market participants. In contrast, companies like Circle and MicroStrategy face different primary business drivers, such as stablecoin adoption and Bitcoin holdings. Following a key procedural vote where the bill failed to garner the 60 votes needed to proceed, shares of Coinbase, Circle, and MicroStrategy fell between 5-10%. The legislative setback, driven by unresolved ethics provision disagreements, significantly narrows the path for the bill's passage this year, given the limited congressional calendar ahead of the midterm elections and the scheduled adjournment in December.

Although bitcoin and crypto-related stocks plummeted after the U.S. Senate failed to advance the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, or CLARITY Act, Saxo Bank believes that for exchanges like Coinbase, the stakes are higher than for most other companies, as clearer regulations could directly impact their trading business.

In a note published on Wednesday, Saxo strategist Ruben Dalfovo stated that Coinbase (COIN) is the most exposed to the developments around CLARITY, as market structure rules could determine registration requirements, the assets that can be traded, and the scope of participants in U.S. crypto markets.

"Coinbase is the most dependent on clearer market rules, as trading and participation in the crypto market directly affect its business," wrote Dalfovo.

According to Dalfovo, stablecoin issuer Circle (CRCL) and bitcoin-holding company Strategy (MSTR) are exposed to other factors. Circle's business is more closely tied to the distribution of its USDC stablecoin and revenue from reserves, while Strategy's performance primarily depends on its owned BTC and its financing structure.

As Cointelegraph reported late Tuesday, shares of all three companies fell 5–10% following a procedural vote in the Senate, despite differences in how the bill could affect their businesses.

The sell-off continued early Wednesday: according to Yahoo Finance, shares of Coinbase, Circle, and Strategy were down 2–6%.

Related: Democrats rejected Republicans' 'final' CLARITY offer, countering with their own draft: Politico

The Path to Passage Narrows for CLARITY

On Tuesday, the CLARITY Act failed a key procedural vote: senators voted 49–50 against a motion to limit debate on a proposal to proceed to consider the bill, falling significantly short of the required 60 votes. This vote would have restricted further discussion and allowed the Senate to move to consider the bill on the floor.

Ethics provisions remained a major sticking point, despite last-minute concessions aimed at addressing concerns about the crypto interests of public officials.

This setback significantly narrows the prospects for advancing the bill this year. The Senate has a limited legislative calendar around the November 3 midterm elections; it plans to adjourn on December 18, leaving lawmakers with a relatively small window to resume work on the bill before the end of the current congressional session.

Related: Crypto Biz: AI took a backseat as bitcoin started moving higher

end-content

Related Questions

QWhich company does Saxo Bank believe faces the most significant consequences from the failure of the CLARITY Act, and why?

ASaxo Bank believes Coinbase (COIN) faces the most significant consequences. This is because clearer market rules directly impact its core trading business by potentially determining registration requirements, tradable assets, and the range of participants in U.S. crypto markets.

QWhat was the result of the key procedural vote on the CLARITY Act in the U.S. Senate, and why was it significant?

AThe key procedural vote failed with a 49-50 result against limiting debate on the bill. This was significant because it fell short of the 60 votes required to proceed, significantly narrowing the bill's path to passage by preventing it from moving to a full Senate floor vote.

QAccording to the article, what are the primary factors influencing Circle's (CRCL) business and MicroStrategy's (MSTR) performance, respectively?

AAccording to the article, Circle's business is more tied to the distribution of its USDC stablecoin and income from reserves. MicroStrategy's performance primarily depends on the price of the Bitcoin it holds and its financing structure.

QWhat was the immediate market reaction for Coinbase, Circle, and MicroStrategy stocks after the Senate procedural vote?

AAfter the Senate procedural vote, stocks of all three companies—Coinbase, Circle, and MicroStrategy—fell by 5–10%. The sell-off continued the next morning, with shares dropping an additional 2–6%.

QWhy does the article state the prospects for the CLARITY Act this year have 'significantly narrowed'?

AThe prospects have significantly narrowed due to the failed procedural vote, combined with the U.S. Senate's limited legislative calendar around the November midterm elections. The Senate is scheduled to adjourn on December 18, leaving a small window to revive the bill before the end of the current Congressional session.

Related Reads

ENS DAO Proposes Transferring Treasury Management Authority to Foundation Board, Community Retains Ultimate Veto Power

ENS DAO has initiated an on-chain vote on Social Proposal 7.5, which seeks to restructure governance of its core treasury by transferring authority over the Investment Policy Statement (IPS) to the ENS Foundation Board. Under the plan, policy amendment rights currently held by all token holders through on-chain voting would move to the Foundation Board, which would also take over the MetaGov working group's oversight of professional funds and fund managers. The proposal addresses long-standing pain points in decentralized treasury management, including slow token-voting response cycles and the high threshold for financial parameter review. As the protocol delegates management of scaled funds to Karpatkey, requiring full network governance for minor adjustments to asset allocation or risk exposure has caused voter fatigue and risked missing market windows. The shift aims to remove administrative bottlenecks in professional treasury operations. To ensure rigor, the new rules require the Board to solicit community input on the ENS governance forum at least 7 days before proposing amendments. Formal resolutions must receive at least 4 director votes in favor, with conflicted directors recused and remaining eligible directors deciding unanimously. Each amendment must include written rationale and be published within 14 days of passage. ENS DAO has built in checks and balances: the minimum treasury reserve duration and major withdrawals still require full token-holder approval, as does any change to IPS Section 3 governing amendment authority and Board duties. Crucially, ENS DAO retains a permanent override power to overturn any Board amendment via a social proposal, and external fund manager Karpatkey must continue monthly public financial reporting. The proposal reflects mature Web3 infrastructure exploring a balance between modern legal-entity governance and on-chain native democracy, offering a model for compliant, efficient decentralized treasury operations. As of the latest Snapshot data, Proposal 7.5 has 179,900 votes in favor with 100% support and no opposition or abstentions. The vote closes on November 22; if passed, the ENS Foundation will publish IPS v2.1 incorporating the revisions.

marsbit16m ago

ENS DAO Proposes Transferring Treasury Management Authority to Foundation Board, Community Retains Ultimate Veto Power

marsbit16m ago

Ethereum Upgrade Testing Exposes Hidden Risks: Transactions Show Success, but Payments May Fail

Ethereum's proposed Glamsterdam upgrade has exposed compatibility risks in smart contracts during testing on the Sepolia testnet. Simulations of Juicebox payment contracts showed that some transactions confirm successfully at the outer level while internal payments silently fail, causing fund distributions or fee payments to be skipped. The issue stems from changes to the underlying execution gas accounting logic, which affects existing contracts that rely on traditional exception handling. In NFT purchase tests, buyers received NFTs even when the internal payment failed due to gas exhaustion, leaving funds stranded in the payment project. In token distribution tests, cross-project payments were interrupted, so beneficiaries received the project's original tokens instead of the intended cross-project settlement. Cash redemption tests revealed that within a gas range of 679,622 to 817,622, users could redeem funds while the internal 2.5% protocol fee was not charged, effectively waiving the fee. Juicebox developer mejango linked the problem to tiered changes in opcode gas costs and contract error-handling mechanisms, specifically EIP-8037, which sharply raises the gas cost of state creation and new storage writes. Because internal payment subcalls exhaust gas before outer logic, and developers commonly use try/catch structures that isolate errors, the failed payments do not trigger a transaction rollback. On mainnet simulations, the same gas range produced only full transaction failures or complete payments, never silent internal skips. This contrast highlights the impact of gas pricing changes on already-deployed, non-upgradeable contracts, where gas reserves and error catching designed under the old model can turn into fund-leakage risks. The Ethereum Foundation has added the Juicebox report and PoC materials to its agenda and scheduled a special meeting on November 19 to discuss the scope of impact and possible responses. No final decision on adjusting proposal parameters has been made yet.

marsbit17m ago

Ethereum Upgrade Testing Exposes Hidden Risks: Transactions Show Success, but Payments May Fail

marsbit17m ago

Trading

Spot
活动图片