Author: Will Canny
Compiled by: TechFlow
TechFlow Introduction: After the Clarity Act failed to pass in the Senate, the regulatory baton has passed to the SEC and CFTC. Frontline practitioners see a window for acceleration in tokenization, M&A, and buybacks, while lawyers warn that without Congressional legislation, rules can be overturned at any time by politics and litigation. Bitwise's Hougan goes further, stating that this failure actually thickens the regulatory moat for established exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken.

- Actions by the SEC and CFTC are expected to expand regulated on-chain trading and institutional access.
- Legal experts anticipate progress will be incremental, with gaps that must still be filled by Congress.
- Executives see opportunities for DeFi, but mature exchanges may retain their competitive edge.
The failure of the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act to advance in the Senate has pushed the next phase of U.S. crypto regulation into the hands of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC): more trading and investment may move on-chain, but a core question remains unresolved—how much real certainty can regulatory agencies provide without Congress?
Interviews with executives and legal experts show general agreement that regulation will continue to move forward. The disagreement lies in whether agency actions can form a durable foundation or will merely leave a set of rules vulnerable to political and legal shifts, forcing businesses to constantly adapt.
Lev Breydo, Assistant Professor at William & Mary Law School, noted that Clarity exposed divisions within the industry, from ethical provisions to competition with community banks over yield.
He said, "What initially looked like a united front against Gensler later revealed that definitions themselves would create winners and losers."
Despite the setback, agencies are moving swiftly to fill regulatory gaps.
The SEC's five-year "Innovation Exemption," launched on September 17, allows qualified trading venues to trade tokenized U.S. equities via blockchain liquidity pools while the SEC works on permanent rules.
The CFTC followed on October 5, soliciting comments on rules for leveraged retail crypto trading and a new registration category for crypto markets. This initiates a lengthy public comment and rulemaking process, not immediate enforcement.
Meanwhile, the SEC's proposed custody framework from October 1 will allow state trust companies to custody client crypto assets and, under certain conditions, permit advisers and funds to hold assets themselves.
Looking ahead to 2027, Breydo expects the SEC to focus on finalizing issuance and custody rules and building upon the tokenized equity exemption. He sees the agencies' joint interpretative statement in March as a crucial foundation: it replaced earlier guidance and allows for coordination within the existing legal framework.
But a key gap remains: comprehensive federal regulation for plain, unleveraged spot trading, especially beyond the CFTC's anti-fraud and anti-manipulation powers. Filling this gap was a central goal of the Clarity Act.
Faster Activity, Sooner Arrival
For some executives, the legislative setback may ironically lead to quicker business opportunities.
Paul McCaffery, Head of Digital Assets at investment bank KBW, said, "The SEC and CFTC are already proactively providing the regulatory clarity the market needs, which is unlocking a wave of M&A across digital assets, traditional financial services, and fintech."
Matt Hougan, Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise, stated he sees the agency path as more favorable in the near term compared to legislation requiring years of subsequent rulemaking. He also anticipates more protocols adopting token buybacks, particularly buy-and-burn models—SEC clarifications, in his view, boost investor confidence.
Developers are watching whether regulation will distinguish between writing software and operating financial intermediaries. Cathy Yoon, Chief Legal Officer at Solana-focused R&D firm Temporal, said she hopes the SEC will recognize developers as software creators without turning their work into a securities business.
"The SEC staff being willing to state this explicitly is itself a victory," Yoon said, while noting that staff FAQs are not SEC rules.
Michael Lie, Global Head of Digital Assets at market maker Flow Traders, believes comprehensive regulation is inevitable as finance moves toward 24/7 trading. He is watching the Innovation Exemption and changes to transfer-agent rules, noting that European and Asian regimes are already progressing.
Test of Durability
Legal experts expect progress to come in stages, with implementation being the hardest part.
"The biggest gap is implementation," said Derek Lowrey, Head of Legal at Newton Labs (formerly Magic Labs). Without legislation, regulating trading venues, intermediaries, DeFi, and spot markets remains more difficult, he said. However, existing AML, sanctions, and record-keeping obligations provide a foundation for compliance teams to build upon.
Kevin Kreuser, General Counsel at domain tokenization company D3, said tokenized real-world assets particularly need clearer jurisdictional boundaries.
"Agency action is welcome, but it cannot provide the same long-term certainty as legislation," he said.
Jim Petrila, Chief Legal Officer at Dromos Labs, developer of Aerodrome and Velodrome, is more optimistic: the growing liquidity and tokenized securities on public blockchains could make turning back impractical within two years.
"For DeFi, the signals are bullish," he said.
However, the benefits may not be evenly distributed. Hougan believes the failure of Clarity preserves a regulatory moat for incumbents like Coinbase (COIN), Kraken, and others, delaying competition that could have driven down costs. The emerging picture is one where experimentation may happen faster, but questions about who can compete and how durable the new rules are remain unanswered.
Only Congress, Breydo said, can provide a comprehensive framework with statutory durability.






