Clarity Bill Fails to Pass Senate: On-Chain Trading May Accelerate, Moat Remains for Coinbase & Others

marsbitPublished on 2026-10-12Last updated on 2026-10-12

Abstract

After the failure of the "Digital Asset Market Clarity Act" in the Senate, the next phase of U.S. crypto regulation now rests with the SEC and CFTC. This shift is expected to accelerate the movement of more trading and investment activities on-chain, but a core issue remains unresolved: without Congressional action, can regulatory agencies provide lasting certainty? Interviews with executives and legal experts reveal a consensus that regulatory progress will continue, but debate persists over whether agency actions can establish a durable foundation or will merely create rules vulnerable to political shifts and legal challenges. Following the legislative setback, regulators are moving quickly. The SEC introduced a five-year "Innovation Exemption" for trading tokenized stocks via blockchain and proposed a custody framework allowing certain entities to hold client crypto assets. The CFTC has also begun soliciting feedback on rules for leveraged retail crypto trading. Some industry leaders view this administrative path as potentially unlocking business opportunities—such as M&A and token buybacks—more swiftly than a lengthy legislative process would. Developers are also watching for clearer distinctions between software development and operating a financial intermediary. However, legal experts caution about significant gaps, particularly in comprehensive federal oversight for non-leveraged spot trading. While agency actions provide a basis for progress, they lack the long-ter...

Author: Will Canny

Compiled by: TechFlow

TechFlow Introduction: After the Clarity Act failed to pass in the Senate, the regulatory baton has passed to the SEC and CFTC. Frontline practitioners see a window for acceleration in tokenization, M&A, and buybacks, while lawyers warn that without Congressional legislation, rules can be overturned at any time by politics and litigation. Bitwise's Hougan goes further, stating that this failure actually thickens the regulatory moat for established exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken.

- Actions by the SEC and CFTC are expected to expand regulated on-chain trading and institutional access.

- Legal experts anticipate progress will be incremental, with gaps that must still be filled by Congress.

- Executives see opportunities for DeFi, but mature exchanges may retain their competitive edge.

The failure of the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act to advance in the Senate has pushed the next phase of U.S. crypto regulation into the hands of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC): more trading and investment may move on-chain, but a core question remains unresolved—how much real certainty can regulatory agencies provide without Congress?

Interviews with executives and legal experts show general agreement that regulation will continue to move forward. The disagreement lies in whether agency actions can form a durable foundation or will merely leave a set of rules vulnerable to political and legal shifts, forcing businesses to constantly adapt.

Lev Breydo, Assistant Professor at William & Mary Law School, noted that Clarity exposed divisions within the industry, from ethical provisions to competition with community banks over yield.

He said, "What initially looked like a united front against Gensler later revealed that definitions themselves would create winners and losers."

Despite the setback, agencies are moving swiftly to fill regulatory gaps.

The SEC's five-year "Innovation Exemption," launched on September 17, allows qualified trading venues to trade tokenized U.S. equities via blockchain liquidity pools while the SEC works on permanent rules.

The CFTC followed on October 5, soliciting comments on rules for leveraged retail crypto trading and a new registration category for crypto markets. This initiates a lengthy public comment and rulemaking process, not immediate enforcement.

Meanwhile, the SEC's proposed custody framework from October 1 will allow state trust companies to custody client crypto assets and, under certain conditions, permit advisers and funds to hold assets themselves.

Looking ahead to 2027, Breydo expects the SEC to focus on finalizing issuance and custody rules and building upon the tokenized equity exemption. He sees the agencies' joint interpretative statement in March as a crucial foundation: it replaced earlier guidance and allows for coordination within the existing legal framework.

But a key gap remains: comprehensive federal regulation for plain, unleveraged spot trading, especially beyond the CFTC's anti-fraud and anti-manipulation powers. Filling this gap was a central goal of the Clarity Act.

Faster Activity, Sooner Arrival

For some executives, the legislative setback may ironically lead to quicker business opportunities.

Paul McCaffery, Head of Digital Assets at investment bank KBW, said, "The SEC and CFTC are already proactively providing the regulatory clarity the market needs, which is unlocking a wave of M&A across digital assets, traditional financial services, and fintech."

Matt Hougan, Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise, stated he sees the agency path as more favorable in the near term compared to legislation requiring years of subsequent rulemaking. He also anticipates more protocols adopting token buybacks, particularly buy-and-burn models—SEC clarifications, in his view, boost investor confidence.

Developers are watching whether regulation will distinguish between writing software and operating financial intermediaries. Cathy Yoon, Chief Legal Officer at Solana-focused R&D firm Temporal, said she hopes the SEC will recognize developers as software creators without turning their work into a securities business.

"The SEC staff being willing to state this explicitly is itself a victory," Yoon said, while noting that staff FAQs are not SEC rules.

Michael Lie, Global Head of Digital Assets at market maker Flow Traders, believes comprehensive regulation is inevitable as finance moves toward 24/7 trading. He is watching the Innovation Exemption and changes to transfer-agent rules, noting that European and Asian regimes are already progressing.

Test of Durability

Legal experts expect progress to come in stages, with implementation being the hardest part.

"The biggest gap is implementation," said Derek Lowrey, Head of Legal at Newton Labs (formerly Magic Labs). Without legislation, regulating trading venues, intermediaries, DeFi, and spot markets remains more difficult, he said. However, existing AML, sanctions, and record-keeping obligations provide a foundation for compliance teams to build upon.

Kevin Kreuser, General Counsel at domain tokenization company D3, said tokenized real-world assets particularly need clearer jurisdictional boundaries.

"Agency action is welcome, but it cannot provide the same long-term certainty as legislation," he said.

Jim Petrila, Chief Legal Officer at Dromos Labs, developer of Aerodrome and Velodrome, is more optimistic: the growing liquidity and tokenized securities on public blockchains could make turning back impractical within two years.

"For DeFi, the signals are bullish," he said.

However, the benefits may not be evenly distributed. Hougan believes the failure of Clarity preserves a regulatory moat for incumbents like Coinbase (COIN), Kraken, and others, delaying competition that could have driven down costs. The emerging picture is one where experimentation may happen faster, but questions about who can compete and how durable the new rules are remain unanswered.

Only Congress, Breydo said, can provide a comprehensive framework with statutory durability.

Trending Cryptos

Related Questions

QWhat was the main reason for the failure of the Clarity Act in the Senate?

AThe article states that the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act failed to advance in the Senate, pushing the next phase of U.S. crypto regulation into the hands of the SEC and CFTC. It suggests this exposed internal industry divisions, turning what seemed like a united front against SEC Chairman Gary Gensler into a scenario where definitions created winners and losers.

QHow might the regulatory actions by the SEC and CFTC, as mentioned in the article, accelerate on-chain activity?

AThe article mentions several potential accelerants: SEC's 'innovation exemption' for trading tokenized U.S. stocks on blockchain liquidity pools, CFTC's rulemaking proposals for retail crypto trading, and SEC's proposed custody rules allowing certain firms to hold client crypto assets. Executives like Paul McCaffery believe this agency-led clarity could unlock a wave of M&A activity across digital assets and traditional finance.

QAccording to the article, what key regulatory gap remains despite the actions of the SEC and CFTC?

AA key gap mentioned is the lack of comprehensive federal regulation for ordinary, non-leveraged spot trading of digital assets, particularly aspects beyond the CFTC's anti-fraud and anti-manipulation authority. Filling this gap was a core goal of the failed Clarity Act.

QWhy does Bitwise's Matt Hougan believe the failure of the Clarity Act might benefit established exchanges like Coinbase?

AHougan argues that the failure of the Clarity Act preserves a 'regulatory moat' for incumbent exchanges like Coinbase and Kraken. He suggests that successful legislation could have lowered costs and increased competition, but the delay from the legislative setback allows these established players to maintain their competitive advantage for longer.

QWhat is the main concern expressed by legal experts regarding agency-led regulation instead of Congressional legislation?

ALegal experts like Kevin Kreuser and Lev Breydo express concern about the 'durability' and 'long-term certainty' of rules created by agencies like the SEC and CFTC. They argue that without Congressional legislation, these rules are more vulnerable to being overturned by political shifts, legal challenges, or changes in administration, lacking the statutory permanence that a law would provide.

Related Reads

From Harshly Criticizing Stablecoins to Building an L1: Airwallex's Jack Zhang Isn't "Converting" — the Battle for the Settlement Layer Has Begun

In June 2025, Airwallex CEO Jack Zhang publicly questioned stablecoins, arguing that fiat conversion costs outweighed their cross-border payment benefits and that crypto had failed to solve real-world problems for 15 years. Yet just 17 months later, in November 2026, Zhang emerged as co-founder of Alta, a blockchain project that raised $80 million (a $47.5 million Series A led by Index Ventures plus a $32.5 million seed round). Rather than a change of heart, the move reflects commercial necessity: a battle over the stablecoin settlement layer is underway, and payment giants that stay out risk becoming mere interfaces atop someone else's chain. Alta is not a general-purpose public chain but a compliant Layer 1 built for banks and licensed payment institutions. Co-founder Loong Wang, previously of Ren Protocol, says existing chains like Ethereum and Solana cannot simultaneously meet institutional demands for privacy, compliance, integration with local financial systems, and liquidity. Alta uses recursive zero-knowledge proofs to enable on-chain compliance checks without exposing identities or transaction amounts, and builds in programmable compliance modules, native identity authorization, and anti-airdrop protections. Co-founder Catherine Porter previously led Meta's Libra (Diem) partnerships. Airwallex itself is Alta's key advantage: with $287 billion in annualized volume, $1.3 billion in revenue, 200 countries, and 90 currencies, it will channel enterprise clients onto the new chain. Zhang's apparent reversal is consistent: he criticized stablecoins as cheap remittance tools, but now bets on tokenized fiat settlement infrastructure. Competitive pressure comes from Stripe, which acquired Bridge for $1.1 billion, bought Privy, and incubated the Tempo chain (raising $500 million at a $50 billion valuation, with OpenAI, Shopify, Deutsche Bank, and Visa as partners). Circle's Arc, Fireblocks, and Canton Network are also competing. With stablecoin market cap exceeding $320 billion and 2025 on-chain volume surpassing $33 trillion, the real contest is over who controls minting, clearing, and fiat redemption. Success will depend less on technology than on three factors: genuine adoption by traditional financial institutions, compliance adaptation across jurisdictions, and efficient on- and off-ramps to real banking systems. The paradigm has shifted: instead of disrupting banks, fintech giants now aim to build infrastructure that lets traditional finance voluntarily move on-chain. Pragmatism, not ideology, now dominates the race.

marsbit1h ago

From Harshly Criticizing Stablecoins to Building an L1: Airwallex's Jack Zhang Isn't "Converting" — the Battle for the Settlement Layer Has Begun

marsbit1h ago

"Everyone is too conservative with AI!" Head of Claude Code: My approach is more ambitious

Felix Rieseberg, who leads Claude Code's desktop app, argues that most people use AI too conservatively and should set more ambitious goals. His central trick: set unreasonably aggressive targets and insist they're achievable—for example, instead of cutting website load time from 10 seconds to 5, aim for 0.2 seconds, and when the model protests, keep telling it the problem is solvable and to try again. He organizes ambition into four categories: speed (doing the same work faster), height (raising the abstraction level to focus on desired outcomes rather than individual tasks), depth (working like top experts, using their real tools, data, and methods), and breadth (drawing on ideas from other fields). For height, he suggests asking what you ultimately want to happen and what the goal behind the goal is—e.g., instead of fixing single crashes, require the app to never crash. For a quarterly business review, move from filling in a template to understanding what changed and why, identifying the most urgent decisions, and redesigning the review process itself. For depth, he advises insisting on the tools top professionals actually use (databases and statistical models rather than Markdown tables), setting "unreasonable" targets, challenging your own assumptions against raw data, hunting for new knowledge, and using external validation rather than letting the model grade itself. A useful prompt asks the model what top experts would do that you haven't requested, what raw materials and tools they'd use, and what besides the model and you could prove the result correct. For breadth, he recommends replacing nouns with verbs (not "make a PPT" but "in 30 minutes, convince busy people of an explanation and drive a decision under uncertainty"), assembling cross-disciplinary teams, and using multi-agent setups—while avoiding mere role-play in favor of adopting other fields' actual methods. He closes with self-efficacy research: people given clear, challenging goals outperform those told to do their best, and believing difficult things are possible—as with the four-minute mile—unlocks achievement. In an era of rapid capability gains, updating our beliefs about what's possible matters more than ever.

marsbit1h ago

"Everyone is too conservative with AI!" Head of Claude Code: My approach is more ambitious

marsbit1h ago

The Traditional Santa Rally: Will It Happen in US Stocks This Year?

US stocks have suffered a sharp selloff, but technical and positioning conditions are repairing, with Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan all signaling a potential year-end rally. Goldman strategist Cosimo Codacci-Pisanelli argues that aggressive deleveraging (the most intense in a decade), valuation multiples back near 35-year averages (MSCI world forward P/E at 15.6x), upward EPS revisions, and seasonal factors create conditions for a year-end short squeeze. Morgan Stanley data shows hedge funds are now underweight AI for the first time since 2023, with the longest deleveraging streak in over 15 years; JPMorgan calls poor sentiment a bullish signal. However, the report flags a paradox: when all three banks call the same trade, the contrarian "year-end squeeze" becomes a crowded consensus trade. Worse, inflation pressure is building faster than during the pandemic: global manufacturing import price inflation is running at about 24% annualized, and the share of import categories with annualized gains above 5% has jumped to 25-40% across major economies. Firms are absorbing costs via margin compression, but upstream pressures typically pass through to consumers in 6-12 months, meaning the bill arrives in Q1. January is historically the month with the most price resets, and Goldman has added a third Fed hike to its forecast. A reflexive loop means a rally that loosens financial conditions removes the rationale for central bank caution, effectively borrowing from future returns. Goldman recommends long front-end inflation as a portfolio hedge, and notes the best rule for 2026 is to short every consensus trade.

marsbit2h ago

The Traditional Santa Rally: Will It Happen in US Stocks This Year?

marsbit2h ago

Claude Deciphers Gödel's Cryptic Manuscripts: 80-Year-Old Notes Shake the Mathematics World

In 1978, logician Kurt Gödel left behind thousands of pages of unpublished notes written in Gabelsberger shorthand, a nearly extinct German stenography system understood by only a handful of people. In 2017, Finnish logician Jan von Plato, upon reaching mandatory retirement age, set out to decode 16 workbooks comprising 1,009 pages that Gödel wrote after settling in Princeton in 1940. After years of manually transcribing the shorthand into modern English, his team could barely digest one page per week—until computer scientists suggested using Claude. Fed the transcripts, von Plato's own books, and modern literature, Claude produced a 650-page interpretation within days, later expanding to 1,084 pages. The AI identified 663 theorem-like results, around 440 of which were confirmed as new theorems through formal verification—suggesting Gödel proved nearly one theorem every two days in the early 1940s. Claude also revealed that Gödel came within a hair of proving the independence of the Axiom of Choice two decades before Paul Cohen's 1963 forcing method earned him a Fields Medal; Gödel had constructed an equivalent framework but made an error in a key definition of "finite support," a result later verified in Coq and praised by Gödel expert Akihiro Kanamori. The notes also contain results rediscovered only in the 1970s–80s, 14 unexplored research topics, and physics work including early use of the Lüders rule (proposed in 1951) and serious study of time-travel via his rotating "Gödel universe." Gödel died in 1978 of starvation caused by paranoia.

marsbit2h ago

Claude Deciphers Gödel's Cryptic Manuscripts: 80-Year-Old Notes Shake the Mathematics World

marsbit2h ago

Trading

Spot

Hot Articles

How to Buy BILL

Welcome to HTX.com! We've made purchasing Billions Network (BILL) simple and convenient. Follow our step-by-step guide to embark on your crypto journey.Step 1: Create Your HTX AccountUse your email or phone number to sign up for a free account on HTX. Experience a hassle-free registration journey and unlock all features.Get My AccountStep 2: Go to Buy Crypto and Choose Your Payment MethodCredit/Debit Card: Use your Visa or Mastercard to buy Billions Network (BILL) instantly.Balance: Use funds from your HTX account balance to trade seamlessly.Third Parties: We've added popular payment methods such as Google Pay and Apple Pay to enhance convenience.P2P: Trade directly with other users on HTX.Over-the-Counter (OTC): We offer tailor-made services and competitive exchange rates for traders.Step 3: Store Your Billions Network (BILL)After purchasing your Billions Network (BILL), store it in your HTX account. Alternatively, you can send it elsewhere via blockchain transfer or use it to trade other cryptocurrencies.Step 4: Trade Billions Network (BILL)Easily trade Billions Network (BILL) on HTX's spot market. Simply access your account, select your trading pair, execute your trades, and monitor in real-time. We offer a user-friendly experience for both beginners and seasoned traders.

6.6k Total ViewsPublished 2026.05.07Updated 2026.06.02

How to Buy BILL

Discussions

Welcome to the HTX Community. Here, you can stay informed about the latest platform developments and gain access to professional market insights. Users' opinions on the price of BILL (BILL) are presented below.

活动图片