Global Chip Stocks Retreat Nearly 40% from Peak: Has the AI Bubble Burst?
Nvidia is set to report its fiscal Q3 2027 earnings after market close on November 17, but the call will be led by interim CEO and CFO Colette Kress, not Jensen Huang, who resigned as president, CEO, and board member effective November 12 following an apology letter to employees admitting infidelity and a board investigation into reports that he was a target of foreign intelligence activity. The report comes as investors question whether massive AI capital expenditures will pay off. On November 5, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index plunged 12.25%, its worst single-day drop since March 2020, with Nvidia falling 9.3% and losing about $447 billion in market value; Seoul's KOSPI triggered a circuit breaker the next day. Over the past month, Nvidia has shed nearly $1.4 trillion in market value from its early-October peak, the semiconductor index has pulled back nearly 40% from its June 22 peak of 14,634, Oracle is down over 30% year-to-date, and CoreWeave has retreated about 70% from its June 2025 high. Yet the broader market looks calm: the Nasdaq is only about 12% off its high, and the equal-weighted S&P 500 hit a record during the selloff week—the crash is concentrated in AI. The timeline shows early warnings in Korea in June, with memory stocks falling first; Goldman's AI memory basket is down 51% from its June peak, the largest drawdown since ChatGPT launched. The selloff layered by proximity to end cash flow: memory worst, then leveraged neoclouds like CoreWeave, then power, chips, and optics, while cash-rich cloud giants held up, with the seven giants still up about 9.6% year-to-date before the crash. Nvidia's roughly 14x P/E isn't necessarily cheap—its revenue is others' capex, low multiples on cyclicals often mark peak profits, and chip index declines historically lead semiconductor sales drops by 6-9 months, suggesting real estimate cuts may not appear until Q1 2027. Meanwhile, orders are full but stocks still fall: Lumentum says data center optics are sold out for years, SanDisk beat for six straight quarters yet is down over 60% from its high, and CoreWeave's Q3 beat and $132.5 billion backlog didn't stop a 32% year-to-date decline. Hyperscaler capex guidance for 2026 totals $720-745 billion, up nearly 80% from 2025, but the market's reaction has turned cold—Google fell 12.6% on October 29, its worst day ever. Free cash flow is turning negative: the five biggest players spent $556.9 billion in the first nine months versus $542.9 billion in operating cash flow, with four of the seven giants seeing negative FCF for the first time in a decade, funded by debt—US cloud companies issued about $225 billion in bonds in the first nine months, up 973.7% year-over-year. Oracle's CDS spread widened from about 58 basis points a year ago to 295, and CoreWeave's exceeded 1,000, with bond yields near 15%. The bond market is already pricing default risk while stocks debate bubbles. Politics adds a second layer: Democrats won both chambers in the November 3 midterms, and of 41 local data center ballot measures in 10 states, 40 went against data center construction. Texas, which holds 27% of planned US capacity, elected a governor promising a moratorium. Goldman estimates 45% of planned US data center capacity faces short-term pause risk. Buffers exist—the new Congress seats in January 2027, any restrictions face a presidential veto, and UBS estimates only about 30% of planned 2028 capacity would be affected. Demand hasn't broken; what broke is the belief that spending alone lifts stocks—AI is moving from storytelling to audit. Whether the pullback becomes a collapse depends on three readings: whether cloud giants' free cash flow turns positive, whether Oracle and CoreWeave credit spreads keep widening, and whether state-level data center restrictions take effect.
marsbit4h ago