Author: Nikhilesh De
Translation: TechFlow Deep Tide
Deep Tide Introduction: Are sports prediction contracts "gambling" or "swaps"? Last week, Dodd, Gensler, the NFL, and 39 states, among others, filed amicus briefs with the Supreme Court, mostly leaning towards state authority; the CFTC on Friday issued a temporary final rule and a new proposal aiming to clearly categorize event contracts related to sports, politics, etc., as swaps—Kalshi's deadline to respond has been extended to November 9.
Last week, multiple parties filed amicus briefs with the U.S. Supreme Court, urging it to hear a case: whether sports-based prediction market contracts qualify as swaps. Then on Friday, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued two proposals (one of which is now effective), stating its view on the matter.

Former Senator Chris Dodd, former Commodity Futures Trading Commission (and Securities and Exchange Commission) Chairman Gary Gensler, the National Football League (NFL), 39 states (and the District of Columbia), 145 tribal nations, and other parties filed amicus briefs with the Supreme Court, urging it to hear the case; many of them argued that sports-based prediction market products are not swaps and should not be regulated by the CFTC.
Why It Matters
This newsletter discussed the possibility of Supreme Court intervention in prediction markets a month ago. That assessment hasn't changed; a significant circuit split has now emerged: two appellate courts have ruled that sports-related prediction markets are actually gambling products to be regulated by states, while another appellate court ruled that they fall under the CFTC's purview.
Breakdown
Most of the amicus briefs filed last week urged the Supreme Court to side with the states, meaning to rule that at least sports-related prediction markets are actually gambling products, to be regulated at the state level rather than federally.
Former Senator Chris Dodd—whose name appears on the 2010 Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act at the heart of this debate—stated in his brief that the law was not intended to grant the CFTC power to override state governments and strip them of their ability to regulate gambling.
The brief disagreed with the Third Circuit Court of Appeals panel's 2-1 ruling that the CFTC has jurisdiction over swaps and prediction markets covering sports, arguing there is a distinction between derivatives as financial instruments and sports betting.
"Parlay tickets—which often bundle bets on different games, cities, and sports, on spreads or player performances—do not facilitate hedging or price discovery," the brief stated, citing a popular category of sports-related prediction markets. "Nor are they 'linked to' the type of 'potential financial, economic, or commercial consequences' that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) requires for a swap."
Dodd's brief then countered the CFTC's claim that it has "exclusive jurisdiction" over such products.
"The 'exclusive jurisdiction' granted to the CFTC by the Commodity Exchange Act is also not an express preemption clause that exempts every contract listed on a designated contract market (DCM) from otherwise applicable state and tribal law. It simply designates the CFTC as the federal regulator of covered financial instruments," his brief stated.
Former CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler, who played a key role in drafting the regulatory details implementing Dodd–Frank, similarly argued that the law did not grant the CFTC preemptive power over state gambling laws. He made a similar argument in a prior appellate case.
The NFL argued it has a vested interest in the outcome of this case given the importance of sports betting in—well, sports. The league criticized what it called the CFTC's "laissez-faire" approach on this issue and the broader inconsistency between how states regulate gambling companies and how the CFTC regulates designated contract markets (the type of license held by prediction market operators).
On Friday, the CFTC issued a temporary final rule and a separate proposal aimed at clarifying how it includes these products within the "swap" definition. The agency stated that casino-style gambling is not within its swap definition, but event contracts are still within its scope. The regulator also wants to formally include events related to sports, politics, culture, and weather within the event contracts counted as swaps.
Kalshi applied for and was granted an extension to file its response with the Supreme Court. Its deadline is now November 9, 2026.
This Week
- None of the congressional hearings we are tracking are scheduled this week.





