Behind the US Stock Market Crash and Rebound: Is Deleveraging Nearing Its End, or the Prelude to Medium- and Long-Term Risks?
U.S. stocks experienced extreme volatility over two trading days. On November 5, the market suffered its sharpest single-day selloff in 19 months, led by AI-related stocks, fueling social media rumors of hedge fund liquidations. The next day, however, chip stocks spearheaded a rebound: the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index rose 4.2%, AMD jumped 11%, and the Nasdaq gained 1.1%. Vanda Research showed retail investors turned net buyers in the final ten minutes of the previous session, purchasing over $100 million. A key factor was leveraged ETFs, which Nomura estimated needed to sell about $47 billion in equity exposure before the close on November 5—the second-largest single-day sale since records began in 2006. Once this passive selling concluded, short-term pressure eased, and dip buyers, short covering, and portfolio rebalancing combined to drive prices higher. JPMorgan noted the deleveraging cleared crowded trades, improving positioning. However, longer-term issues—policy expectations and doubts over AI capital spending returns—remain unresolved.
The "hedge fund blowup" narrative was exaggerated. Bloomberg reported Tiger Global's flagship fund lost about 8.5% in October, Walleye Capital fell 5.9%, and Lone Pine lost 8.8%. Yet business contraction does not equal liquidation. Importantly, hedge funds began deleveraging in October. Goldman Sachs data showed global fundamental equity long/short funds lost about 3.5% in October, with systematic strategies down 3.6%—the first time both exceeded 3% losses in the same month since 2016. In mid-October, Goldman's hedge fund clients net sold $20 billion in tech stocks in just two weeks, fully unwinding AI long positions built since early 2025. By end-October, net leverage fell to 73.4%, down 4.2 percentage points—the largest monthly drop since March. Morgan Stanley reported the largest active reduction in stock-picking hedge funds in over a decade. Performance varied widely: Coatue gained 0.2%, Citadel rose 1.7%, and Quantedge surged 7.2%.
Capital did not disappear but migrated. The first destination was U.S. Treasuries, with the 10-year yield falling to 4.84%, a September low. The second was the dollar, which regained safe-haven support. Meanwhile, oversold Korean won and Taiwan dollar drew attention; Bank of America noted their large current account surpluses would support long positions, and AI supply chain capital spending and export orders would not be canceled due to U.S. stock declines, providing underlying support over 6-12 months.
The rapid rebound raises the question: is this the end of the decline or just a temporary recovery? History offers parallels. In August 2007, quant fund deleveraging saw the sharpest drop concentrated in four days, but the process lasted until year-end. In March 2020, the S&P 500 fell about 34% over a month with violent single-day rebounds, only recovering by August. Current action resembles the first case: the most intense selling may be over, but full positioning rebalancing and risk appetite recovery are far from complete. Optimists like Tom Lee see the selloff as a short-term buying opportunity, while analyst Mark Minervini warns of a possible 10-15% SPY decline or a 20-25% Nasdaq drop resembling a cyclical bear market. The Nasdaq's 1.1% gain barely offsets the prior 5.52% drop. After two days of turbulence, U.S. stocks stand at a crossroads—short-term leverage clearing may be ending, but mid-term debates over industrial policy and AI investment returns are just entering deep waters.
marsbit1h ago