Odds of CLARITY Act passing fall to 16% after key Democrats reject GOP's 'final' offer

cryptonews.ruPublished on 2026-09-15Last updated on 2026-09-15

Abstract

The odds of the CLARITY Act passing this year fell sharply to 16% on Polymarket after key Senate Democrats rejected the "final" Republican proposal on cryptocurrency market regulation. Initially, traders had raised the odds to 35% on a revised GOP offer with expanded ethics provisions, but confidence waned as Democrats raised objections. Senator Mark Warner called the revised ethics language "far from sufficient," and Democrats began preparing a counter-proposal. Republicans need 60 votes to advance the bill, and a failed procedural vote on Tuesday could stall the legislation, which aims to divide oversight between the SEC and CFTC. Key Democrats, including Senators Raphael Warnock and Ruben Gallego, remained unconvinced, arguing the ethics provisions did not adequately address corruption risks. Senator Cynthia Lummis countered that Democrats had "nothing more to offer," as President Trump had agreed to significant ethics terms. Further opposition came from a coalition of 18 state attorneys general, the Indian Gaming Association—which seeks protections for tribal gaming laws—and banking groups arguing the text leaves loopholes for stablecoin rewards. Crypto industry advocates, like the Blockchain Association's Kristin Smith, urged passage for clear rules and consumer protection.

According to Polymarket, the odds of the CLARITY Act passing this year plunged again on Monday after a spike the previous day: key Democrats in the Senate reportedly said the Republican Party's final offer on the cryptocurrency bill did not convince them.

Polymarket traders initially took the recently revised Republican offer with enhanced ethics provisions as a positive signal, raising the odds to 35%. However, as doubts about the revised text grew, their confidence waned, and on Monday, the odds fell back to 16%.

U.S. Senator Mark Warner, one of the Democrats involved in the negotiations, reportedly stated that the revised ethics provision was "far from sufficient," and negotiating Democrats began preparing a counter-offer on Monday.

Republicans need 60 votes to advance the bill, and failure on Tuesday could stall the legislation, which would define how the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission divide oversight of the U.S. cryptocurrency market.

Key Democrats remain unconvinced by ethics proposal

Brendan Pedersen from Punchbowl News reported that Senator Raphael Warnock stated: Democrats should not advance legislation that does not address opportunities for corruption happening "in real-time."

Pedersen reported that Senator Ruben Gallego stated: the latest ethics proposal "falls short," and that he plans to work on a counter-proposal. Separately, Pedersen reported that staff of Senator Elizabeth Warren on the Senate Banking Committee circulated talking points stating that the proposed enforcement mechanism by state attorneys general could be overridden by White House ethics officials.

Later, Democrats sent their counter-offer to Republican negotiators, Politico reported, citing three people familiar with the situation.

Not all Democrats oppose advancing the bill for a floor vote. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand privately urged colleagues to support the procedural motion, Politico reported.

Republican Senator Cynthia Lummis stated that President Donald Trump had agreed to two substantial ethics provisions and that Democrats have "nothing more to offer."

The resistance adds to opposition from a coalition of 18 state attorneys general and heightens uncertainty about whether Republicans can gather the votes needed to advance the bill.

Banking and tribal groups challenge latest text

The National Indian Gaming Association, an organization representing tribal gaming interests, called on member tribes to pressure senators to vote against the bill, stating that the proposed DeFi changes do not address Native American concerns about prediction markets.

The association called for the inclusion of explicit language affirming that federal commodity legislation does not supersede tribal or state gaming laws, including the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.

Related: Revised CLARITY Act Targets 'Non-Decentralized' DeFi Operators

Eight banking trade groups also stated that the revised text does not close loopholes allowing the payment of rewards on stablecoins that function similarly to deposit interest. According to the groups, the proposed regulatory "circuit breaker" only activates after significant deposit outflows from community banks have already occurred.

Crypto industry representatives have urged senators to advance the bill. In a statement released Monday, Blockchain Association CEO Summer Mersinger stated that the industry had made significant concessions to help build bipartisan support and called on every senator to vote for the bill.

She argued that the bill would establish clear rules, protect consumers, and deter illegal activity, while also preventing the offshoring of crypto jobs, developers, and innovation.

Magazine: Why are the biggest AI companies suddenly calling to slow down?

end-content

Related Questions

QWhat happened to the odds of the CLARITY Act passing according to Polymarket after key Democrats rejected the Republican proposal?

AThe odds of the CLARITY Act passing this year, according to Polymarket, dropped sharply again to 16% after key Democrats in the Senate stated that the Republican party's final proposal for the cryptocurrency bill did not convince them.

QWhy are key Democrats reportedly not convinced by the latest Republican proposal for the CLARITY Act?

AKey Democrats, like Senator Mark Warner, stated that the revised ethics provision in the proposal was 'far from sufficient'. Other concerns included that it didn't eliminate opportunities for real-time corruption and left an enforcement mechanism that could be overruled by White House ethics officials.

QWhat is a major procedural hurdle the CLARITY Act must overcome in the Senate?

AThe Republicans need 60 votes to advance the bill. A failure on Tuesday (referenced in the article) could stall the legislation.

QWhich two groups raised concerns about the revised text of the CLARITY Act, and what were their main objections?

A1. The Indian Gaming Association objected, stating the proposed DeFi changes did not address Native American concerns about prediction markets and called for language protecting tribal and state gambling laws. 2. Eight banking trade groups argued the text failed to close loopholes allowing stablecoin rewards that function like deposit interest, and that a proposed regulatory 'circuit breaker' would activate too late.

QWhat is the main argument made by the Blockchain Association's CEO in favor of advancing the CLARITY Act?

ASummer Mersinger argued that the industry made significant concessions to build bipartisan support, and that the bill would establish clear rules, protect consumers, deter illicit activity, and prevent the offshoring of crypto jobs, developers, and innovation.

Related Reads

Strategy stock sheds 5% amid MSCI index removal, Bitcoin sell-off

Strategy (Michael Saylor's Bitcoin treasury company) fell 6.49% on Thursday to close at $114.41, after MSCI confirmed the company's removal from its global equity indexes, compounded by a broader crypto market sell-off. The removal takes effect after the Nov. 30 market close and could trigger selling by index-tracking funds; JPMorgan previously estimated roughly $2.8 billion in potential selling pressure. Ryan Kirkley, CEO of Global Settlement Network, said the decision could distinguish Bitcoin treasury companies from traditional operating businesses and limit indirect crypto exposure for passive investors, noting that index inclusion had given ordinary passive investors leveraged Bitcoin exposure they never chose. He added it raises questions about whether such companies should be classified alongside traditional operating businesses, arguing that buying and holding an asset isn't an operating business but rather a fund that doesn't follow fund rules. In its Aug. 31 response to MSCI's proposed rules, Strategy called the changes a pretext for targeting digital asset treasury companies and downplayed the impact, saying MSCI-linked funds held about 13 million of its shares, just 3.1% of basic shares outstanding. The decline coincided with a broader crypto sell-off, with Bitcoin near $71,340, down 4.3% in 24 hours, and total crypto market capitalization down 3% to about $2.49 trillion.

cointelegraph1h ago

Strategy stock sheds 5% amid MSCI index removal, Bitcoin sell-off

cointelegraph1h ago

US Justice Department, business groups and DeFi firms challenge Illinois crypto tax

The US Department of Justice, business and financial industry groups, and a coalition of DeFi firms have backed a legal challenge to Illinois' 0.2% digital asset tax, arguing it unfairly targets crypto transactions and could impose taxes even without profit. The Justice Department filed a statement of interest, while the US Chamber of Commerce and SIFMA submitted an amicus filing. A coalition including Andreessen Horowitz, Paradigm, Uniswap and Aave Labs also filed a brief. The law, enacted in June, taxes the value of digital assets exchanged, transferred or stored regardless of profit. The Digital Chamber sued Illinois officials in July, followed by a separate challenge from the Blockchain Association and Crypto Council for Innovation in August. Originally set for Jan. 1, 2027, the tax was delayed to July 1, 2027. Illinois projected $60 million in fiscal year 2027 revenue. SIFMA and the Chamber warned the tax would affect banks, broker-dealers, custodians and asset managers nationwide, exposing them to compliance costs and burdening customers—someone who loses money owes the same tax as someone who profits, and moving assets between accounts could trigger tax without a sale or gain. They argued it discriminates against digital assets and may violate federal internet tax protections and constitutional interstate commerce requirements. The DOJ said the tax undermines federal efforts to promote crypto innovation, citing the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and GENIUS Act. The DeFi coalition warned the rules could impose obligations on software developers and blockchain participants lacking customer information or control over funds.

cointelegraph1h ago

US Justice Department, business groups and DeFi firms challenge Illinois crypto tax

cointelegraph1h ago

DTCC Plans Solana Expansion as Wallet Rules Limit Access

DTCC plans to connect its tokenization service to Solana in the second half of 2027, allowing certain securities held by its DTC subsidiary to be converted into digital tokens on the network. Analysts say the move could attract more traditional financial institutions to Solana, which is known for fast transactions and low fees and had about $4.94 billion in total value locked as of Nov. 12. However, the impact may be limited by US regulatory rules. Alex Lin of Reforge noted that Solana's experience handling memecoin trading served as a public stress test, giving the network credibility to handle retail-scale volume reliably. Still, under a December 2025 SEC no-action letter, DTC participants must register wallets to hold tokenized securities, and tokens can only be transferred between registered wallets. Lin said the near-term impact is overstated because the tokens remain in a walled garden, inaccessible to permissionless retail and DeFi liquidity until regulators allow these assets to function as true onchain collateral. DTCC launched its tokenization service on the Canton Network and its private Besu network on Oct. 28, with 20 DTC participants signed on, though it has not said whether any plan to use Solana. Kha Nguyen of Birdeye said Solana has already seen growing demand for tokenized stocks, with trading volume reaching around $4.9 billion in H1 2026 and over 1 million accounts holding tokenized stocks by late September. However, broader Solana activity has slowed, with transactions down nearly 40%, DEX volume down 34.4%, and fees down 39%, while tokenized RWA value rose almost 7% to $4.76 billion. Nguyen said DTCC's integration would need banks, brokers, and issuers to actively issue, trade, and settle on Solana, with enough liquidity for large trades. He stressed that assets must be active rather than idle—traded around the clock, used as collateral, and earning yield. Lin agreed that long-term impact depends on where assets are used for secondary trading and collateral activity, not where they are issued.

cointelegraph2h ago

DTCC Plans Solana Expansion as Wallet Rules Limit Access

cointelegraph2h ago

Trading

Spot
活动图片