Author: Jake Koch-Gallup
Compilation: Deep Tide TechFlow
Deep Tide Introduction: As more and more people begin to question Ethereum's value capture ability, this article provides a contrarian perspective. The author directly responds to the argument that "Ethereum is losing its liquidity moat" and offers counterarguments from the perspectives of monetary premium, Layer-2 ecosystems, and stablecoin market share. For investors who are reassessing Ethereum's long-term positioning, this is a thought-provoking piece worth reading alongside contrasting views.
If you haven't read Carlos's newsletter from this Tuesday, go read it first. His core argument is: Ethereum is losing its final moat, liquidity. We debated this on the 0xResearch podcast (you can listen here), and I strongly disagree with his view (can you believe it? Blockworks analysts actually have different opinions).
His first example is that tokenized stocks on Ethereum have almost no trading volume, with only $25 million in trading volume over the past 30 days, representing about 3% of the supply. But Ethereum holds the second-largest share in tokenized stock supply. Carlos anticipated this, but I still believe the purpose of tokenized stocks is to expand global investors' access to US markets, not for lending and DeFi. On the podcast, his response was: tokenized stocks lying on your blockchain do nothing because they don't generate revenue, and trading volume generates revenue.

Dear reader, this is likely where you and I start to truly diverge. I don't believe Ethereum necessarily needs to generate revenue. It already possesses a monetary premium, like many other L1s. Real Economic Value (REV) alone is far from sufficient to explain the market capitalization of most L1s; ETH is trading at over 1100 times its REV from the past year. Since the market clearly prices Ethereum partly as a reserve asset and collateral asset (ETFs, treasury bonds, DeFi collateral), ignoring this is tantamount to saying ETH and most L1s are perpetually overvalued by 99%, which isn't a very useful statement.

His second argument is that flagship applications are prioritizing growth elsewhere. He cites Robinhood Chain accounting for 43% of Uniswap's trading volume over the past 30 days, while Ethereum accounts for only 32%. He also mentioned Ethena's growth on Base. Both points are valid, but Robinhood Chain and Base are both Ethereum Layer-2 networks. If we agree that REV is less important for L1s, then the growth of Ethereum Layer-2s is a victory for Ethereum. To be fair, Ethena has also expanded to Solana, TRON, and Avalanche, which are not Layer-2s. Ethereum's share in USDe has dropped from 88% to 56%, but it remains the majority. Ethena is increasing distribution channels, not leaving.

However, if you do believe REV is extremely important, consider this: In September, Base paid Ethereum about $15,000 in rent to publish data. In the same month, it paid the Optimism Collective $711,000. Now imagine a world, 3 to 5 years from now, where Ethereum says, "You know what, we want that kind of revenue Optimism is getting too," and raises the minimum fee for publishing data. Base might not like it, but if Layer-2 networks are 10 times larger by then, that's a lot of money. So market share matters, even if it's not generating much REV right now.

His final argument is that Ethereum's stablecoin dominance is slowly declining, which is true. But the stablecoin market is not winner-takes-all. Even if Ethereum's dominance drops from 51% to 30% over the next 10 years, the stablecoin market itself will continue to grow. If the total stablecoin market cap reaches $3 trillion in 10 years, Ethereum would have nearly $1 trillion in stablecoins, almost six times today's holdings of $155 billion. If you want to hear Carlos's response to my rebuttals here, be sure to check out the podcast. Setting those aside for now, let's look at why Ethereum remains valuable and will continue to be.
Reasons Why Ethereum Remains Valuable

Ethereum has by far the largest Total Value Locked (TVL) in DeFi, accounting for 65% of the total. Since 2022, it hasn't fallen below 62% for any single week.
Ethereum still possesses the deepest liquidity, the most secure network, and the most institutional participation of any blockchain besides Bitcoin.
Ethereum holds the largest on-chain Real-World Asset (RWA) management volume (though its share has fallen from 99% in 2022 to 45% today).
Institutions hold ETH as an asset, not for its revenue. Spot ETFs and corporate treasuries hold about 13% of ETH's total supply.
Robinhood and Coinbase could have launched their own L1s, but they chose to settle on Ethereum.
The largest tokenized funds, such as BlackRock's BUIDL, launched first on the Ethereum mainnet.
Ethereum has been running for over 10 years without a single network-wide outage.
Ethereum and its Layer-2 networks have the largest developer base in crypto, with EVM being the default toolkit, even copied by competing L1s.
36% of the ETH supply is staked, just hitting a new all-time high, providing native yield to holders, which institutions can access via staking ETFs.
Ethereum is the world's computer for crypto.
Ultimately, I am a fundamental investor. Crypto projects (usually) should have revenue, and that value should accrue to token holders. So believing ETH can survive on its monetary premium and minimal REV might just be holder self-soothing. But maybe, just maybe, Ethereum should be valued as a world computer.
Today's Highlight

After declining throughout the year, Plasma's stablecoin supply has almost doubled since July, reaching $1.41 billion, the highest level since mid-February. While still far from its peak of $5.2 billion when it launched, the competition for a stable chain isn't over yet.








