Ripple’s legal battle with SEC continues with latest ruling from judge

03/07 07:43

According to Blockworks and U.today, the ongoing legal battle between the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Ripple Labs continues with a new court ruling. The court has now ruled on the parties' motions to preclude expert testimony from consideration at summary judgment and trial. In the ruling, Judge Analisa Torres granted some of the motions and denied others, with neither the plaintiff nor the defendants gaining the upper hand. However, one of the key outcomes of the ruling was the exclusion of Expert No. 1, Patrick Doody, from testifying about the perceptions of a reasonable XRP purchaser. It is worth noting that the SEC had previously hired Doody to analyze the expectations of token purchasers, but the judge has now granted Ripple's motion to exclude his testimony. The exclusion of Doody's testimony has implications for the SEC's case, as the agency has to prove that investors had a reasonable expectation of profits from Ripple's efforts. Without Doody's testimony, it is unclear how the SEC will prove "reasonable" reliance. Ripple’s most recent filing points to a recent Supreme Court ruling, which touches on the so-called “fair notice” defense employed by its counsel. The Due Process Clause of the US Constitution requires individuals be given fair notice of which actions are prohibited by law. For Ripple, the fair notice notice defense goes like this: It couldn’t have known to register XRP with securities regulators, as the agency had never provided enough clarity on what makes a security within the crypto context. Drawing supposed parallels between Bittner and Ripple execs, Ripple Labs’ counsel says Bittner’s recent ruling is analogous to its fight against the SEC, and should be taken into consideration. Ripple Labs relied on SEC’s previous statements and actions that led them to understand that XRP was not a security, or so its defense goes. Therefore, the firm had no reason to believe that they were violating securities laws. Whether Judge Torres feels the same way is another matter. Torres is expected to rule on both sides’ summary judgements sometime this year, which, outside of a settlement, would end the case without a jury.
bullishbullishbullish7bearishbearishbearish1LikeShare
DisclaimerThe content above does not represent HTX's positions.HTX does not provide any trading recommendations.

Related Articles

  • Image

    Analyst Declares XRP Will Hit $300 Target As Adoption Expands

  • Image

    Forget XRP, Market Expert Reveals The Real Winners If The CLARITY Act Is Passed

  • Image

    Ripple IPO Could Bring ‘Something Special’ For XRP Holders, CEO Suggests

All Comments0LatestHot

avatar
LatestHot

Related Articles

  • Image

    Analyst Declares XRP Will Hit $300 Target As Adoption Expands

  • Image

    Forget XRP, Market Expert Reveals The Real Winners If The CLARITY Act Is Passed

  • Image

    Ripple IPO Could Bring ‘Something Special’ For XRP Holders, CEO Suggests